25- Blackberry at L-1 already
50- Blackberry 3, Aegor 3
100- Aegor 2, Lquiz 2
110- blackberry decides on scumgroup [good]
116- Light gives scum percentages
125- Aegor 2, Lquiz 2
129- Light elaborates on scumlist
146- FL gives scumlist
150- yellowbounder 2
174- FL votes sun, gives fatherly advice [scummy]
175- sun 4 (IH, Aegor, farside, FL), Light 3 (mayhem, sun, popular)
179- gimbo replaces aegor, keeps votes on sun
180- yellow votes sun, 5th vote
182- sun votes gimbo
185- sun takes FL down with him(!!!)
187, 188- FL takes passive stance, thinks he's not voting sun [scummy]
192- killa asks for claim [odd]
197- popular points out "we're all vanillas" [scummy, coaching]
200- sun 5 (IH, farside, FL, gimbo, yellow)
231- sun hammers himself
236- Lowell votes sun in case vote needed
245- FL votes yellow
248- gimbo votes Lowell
251- farside votes Lowell
253- killa votes Lowell
257- farside points out post 185, votes FL
259- Lowell agrees, votes FL
261- gimbo votes FL
268- popular asks for votecount, doesn't commit to anything [scummy]
273- chelsea votes light
275- FL 3 (farside, Lowell, gimbo)
276- farside unvotes, votes Lowell
288- light votes Lowell
291- gimbo unvotes, votes Lowell
300- Lowell 4 (killa, farside, light, gimbo)
303- popular doesn't see case against FL
320- aegor wants back in...
Some pro-town players:
farside
- She pointed out the sun comment on FL, and was on the right side of the sun/light argument all of D1
gimbo
- Aegor wanted to replace in "any role." Unless he's just playing with us from outside the game, it means he started as town. Also, gimbo replaced and kept his vote on sun, even though his replacing would have been a perfect opportunity to unvote without having to explain himself.
light
- I don't think sun would have pursued this wagon against a fellow scum, and with such a large % of scum I don't think the TWO leading D1 wagons were both on scum (too much bussing). Some have criticized his "scum percentages" list early in the game, but I like it. People who have the willingness to be the first to post thoughts on everyone get points in my book.
Some scum:
FL
- been through this. First off, reread 185 if you haven't already. Why does sun quote FL and say he's "busted, IMO"? It makes no sense as a response to a town player. MORE indicting, perhaps, is FL's reaction. Instead of slapping back (the logical town response, and the response of someone who genuinely wants to push the case forward) he tries to soothe sun a little, worried the threats against him will become more explicit and obvious. He says he's not even VOTING for sun, only to realize later that he is. Clearly his being on the wagon was an ACCIDENT, yet he doesn't move his vote. This is NOT the same FL I've seen play as town.
popular
- A couple of things. First, he avoided the sun wagon like the plague D1. He made a very suspicious post 197, where he points out that "we're all townies." This reeks of coaching. A townie would want to try to give sun a chance to slip up and claim a powerrole or something. The fact that he just uses killa's post as an excuse to make it CLEAR that sun will claim townie is suspicious. As well, in post 303 he still doesn't see the case against FL. Big surprise. He asks for vote counts as a way to avoid putting suspicious votes on anyone, even though he knows full well the vote count is at the top of EVERY PAGE. He's too cautious, and too often on the side of scum.
)