BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[Titus]

hi nomnom
from what ive seen i like your playstyle, im excited to play with you
VOTE: krazy

Cool

Krazy Katz is hard town already

While I think you might be right about KK, nothing specifically in that post exactly screams “hard town” to me. Why couldn’t scum have made that post?

~M

Wait, Xtoxm made that post NOT KK. Are you sr Xtoxm, is that the basis for your hardtown read on KK?

~M

Lmao it took like 300 posts but someone still did the thing even though I fully explained some shit later

I suggest you look at the post immediately after that where I vote xtoxm, and my later post where I explain that I quoted xtoxm by accident and voted because it made for rvs content due to the possibility of somebody questioning wtf was going on with my reasoning there

Where are you at currently?

[Venus and Mars]

Your whole PoV in that line of reasoning is arguing why Titus is town due to how she correctly/incorrectly identifies people’s roles lol?

I’m saying that’s not scum indicative for her.

[jjh927]

Where am I at where

I'm voting Dave with some conviction

[jjh927]

I voted Chronos because I decided that might be a decent place to put some pressure down based on the gif entrance

I voted Xtoxm originally because:
I accidentally quoted a post while making a point
I had no intention of expressing my reasons underlying the point
The quote, while not my reasons, could be seen as relevant to the point
So I voted Xtoxm because it sorta just made sense to do it and helped obfuscate things for content's sake

First post on the next page. This seems like an awful lot of explanation for such an early point in the game.
I'm 100% certain that I don't remember anything up to this due to that hard RL day so I'm going to need to re-read. But this caught my eye hard enough to mention it right now.

This is the scummiest post in the game rn

[Chronos]

Your whole PoV in that line of reasoning is arguing why Titus is town due to how she correctly/incorrectly identifies people’s roles lol?

I’m saying that’s not scum indicative for her.

?????????????

[Venus and Mars]

When’s that ever a town angle especially when you have no particular read on me and chkflip

I was asking WHY you sr her for that as opposed to assuming she’s wrong town, it’s not exactly rocket science.

[Auro]

This is the scummiest post in the game rn

Why?

[jjh927]

What's interesting it that nobody has ever given a shit about me explaining things in detail before. Because it's kinda dumb to think town!me isn't gonna give a full explanation for something when there os one and there's someone asking for an explanation, and there's no downside to me explaining it. I'd like those who think that post I made was weird to read it with context and explain why they think it's weird outside of this idea that I can explain my thought process.

Dave has played with me before. He doesn't get a free pass.
VOTE: davesaz

Interesting you vote me for something I noticed during catchup, but didn't refer to anyone else who made the same observation about it being a lot of explanation. It's also interesting to note that I specifically said that I didn't remember the context (and still don't). So you'd like to have it looked at in context -- fine, that's part of the plan anyway.

Then this is the second scummiest post

[Titus]

Where am I at where

I'm voting Dave with some conviction

I meant general reads. I don't like the exchange you and Dave had but I don't know why or which one. So maybe your reads elsewhere will help?

[Venus and Mars]

Lol hold on did VM just TMI all 3 of me / chk and auro town?

VOTE: Venus and Mars

???

I haven’t TMI’d anyone and the only one I’m tl is Auro, so I don’t even know how tf you’re even coming up with that.

So you had better explain exactly wtf you’re referring to here.

Wait you're not townreading me?

You haven’t posted anything to scumping me so for right now, I’m leaning town on you.

[Chronos]

When’s that ever a town angle especially when you have no particular read on me and chkflip

I was asking WHY you sr her for that as opposed to assuming she’s wrong town, it’s not exactly rocket science.

I never said I scum read her for that. I said it’s the post, I never implied it’s because of the accuracy of it.

You said I scum read her for that and then argued from the scum PoV of “her having wrong reads is not scummy”

How about you explain this mess cuz this looks really bad for you right now.

[chkflip]

You had my interest, now you have my curiosity.

Please expand on why you feel that way jjh.

[Chronos]

I literally explained how she’s world building on faulty, early, nonsensical assumptions that are too easy for a town to have such confidence on.

You instantly assuming I was calling her out for BoP though, well damn.

[Chronos]

How can you argue on that line of reasoning unless you have all the alignments in mind already?

[jjh927]

This is the scummiest post in the game rn

Why?

Without going into a looong post while I'm on my phone-
Because he shades based on something other people have mentioned but doesn't commit to a read. I also don't think he has any reason to think it's odd considering he is familiar with my play. The thing that stood out most to him in catchup is something that other people already addressed far beyond its merit that I don't think he should care for.

[Venus and Mars]

Your whole PoV in that line of reasoning is arguing why Titus is town due to how she correctly/incorrectly identifies people’s roles lol?

I’m saying that’s not scum indicative for her.

?????????????

Anyone who’s played with Titus, wouldn’t see that post as scum indicative but like I said, for you to jump to the conclusion that my question to you was some sort of TMI, is an extremely over the top, suspicious reaction, so no - I don’t tr you for that because that’s exactly the kind of reaching that scum do.

So for right now, I’m not liking either you or Xtoxm. I can also see jjh’s case on Dave. So consider you three, slots I’m not currently tl.

[Titus]

I literally explained how she’s world building on faulty, early, nonsensical assumptions that are too easy for a town to have such confidence on.

Except I didn't have extreme confidence?

[Venus and Mars]

When’s that ever a town angle especially when you have no particular read on me and chkflip

I was asking WHY you sr her for that as opposed to assuming she’s wrong town, it’s not exactly rocket science.

I never said I scum read her for that. I said it’s the post, I never implied it’s because of the accuracy of it.

You said I scum read her for that and then argued from the scum PoV of “her having wrong reads is not scummy”

How about you explain this mess cuz this looks really bad for you right now.

You’re the ONLY one who seems to think that. Which is why I’m asking if you’re just bad town or scum here? I already explained my post and it’s scummy for you to just ignore that.

[jjh927]

Then he tries to deflect attention back to the other people who discussed the long explanation, and it looks like he also tries to diffuse the situation by backing off. However, I quite clearly stated that the reason I've singled him out is because he's played with me before and doesn't get the free pass to misunderstand my play that people who haven't played with me get.

[Titus]

What if it's just Chronos and chkflip and Auro was pocketed?

[Venus and Mars]

When’s that ever a town angle especially when you have no particular read on me and chkflip

I was asking WHY you sr her for that as opposed to assuming she’s wrong town, it’s not exactly rocket science.

@Chronus

Explain why I shouldn’t switch my Xtoxm vote to you? Are you seriously being this dense here?

[Chronos]

You just straw manned my whole reasoning for accusing me and you’re holding a scum read based on it?

Hell nah you got some explaining to do. You dun’ goofed up and you not realizing it is because you’re scum that TMI’d us all town.

A town never defends a slot based on THE ACCURACY OF THEIR READS WITHOUT FLIPS.

You are arguing from a scum mindset and are oblivious to the point I’m making because of course you can’t see it. The difference between you and me is that I’m uninformed and you’re informed.

P-edit: Already explained. I AM NOT SCUM READING TITUS FOR THAT. Read my ISO, I explained why I did.

[Venus and Mars]

I literally explained how she’s world building on faulty, early, nonsensical assumptions that are too easy for a town to have such confidence on.

Except I didn't have extreme confidence?

Exactly, her reaction seems a bit too defensive if she’s actually town here.

[Chronos]

You’re not even obtuse you’re just scum for not seeing it lol. I never claimed I scum read Titus for her accuracy on reads, BECAUSE THAT’S AN INHERENT SCUM MINDSET BECAUSE TOWN DOESN’T HAVE FLIPS.

And the best part is you can’t even grasp my point because you’re scum lmfao

[Chronos]

You are the one that argued I was scum reading her for that. I never did.

I said it’s “the post where...” not why. You just planted a why, wanted me to enter your frame, which I did not, I explained what my frame was and you’re calling me scum for not arguing from your frame.

For real?