mini 2126: the game is OVRE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Auro]

SS I will blindly sheep you so you better have good reads and hit scum!

[OkaPoka]

SS I will blindly sheep you so you better have good reads and hit scum!

moving from one buddy to the next i see

[RCEnigma]

It's scummy but I'm not going to make up a read when I don't have one.

And yes, I imagine Alchemist backing off as I explained, I don't imagine him unvoting right at that timing.

If he wasn't backing off, he'd have to answer my questions.
He'd have to make up other reasons to scumread me.
Sure one alternative is to lurk, but I don't see that as more likely than just cutting engagement then by unvoting.

I also don't know that you have enough clout behind you this game for your hard push to be super threatening.

Current clout ≠ Potential clout

For the most part Alchemist has been on the winning end of the push/response between you two.

I doubt scum gives that up arbitrarily.

[Auro]

Friendship ended with OkaPoka
Now Something_Smart is my best friend

[RCEnigma]

It would be dishonest to say yes. It's a mechanics thing and I wouldn't have that info as either alignment. I've never rolled GS before.

But you didn't read up on how your role worked when you rolled it this game?

Nope. Check a slot. Has a gun / doesn't have a gun seemed self explanatory.

[Auro]

I mean, I still check the wiki for play strategy etc, and since gunsmith isn't cop I'd also wonder about false positives, blah bla

[RCEnigma]

But I made the post about not giving false positives so I looked it up in case I was full of it. I didn't think GS showed up as a gun carrier.

[Auro]

I doubt scum gives that up arbitrarily

What does he lose by conceding?
The loss of an Auro lynch?
Is that a big deal?

[RCEnigma]

I mean, I still check the wiki for play strategy etc, and since gunsmith isn't cop I'd also wonder about false positives, blah bla

Not my thing.

[RCEnigma]

I doubt scum gives that up arbitrarily

What does he lose by conceding?
The loss of an Auro lynch?
Is that a big deal?

He wouldn't have to unvote you or even discontinue your 1v1 to get a lynch elsewhere. So it doesn't really serve a purpose.

[Auro]

I think scum!Alch would gain by throwing me off developing my scumread by backing down but w/e if you think "Auro has no clout can't push lynch lol"

Will take a small break from the game, you guys do your stuff

[Dannflor]

were/are you not curious how my question of your Comical identity read helps me assess your Comical alignment read? If something felt inconsequential to me enough to bother me I'd probably challenge it - so why aren't you?

I am curious, but I thought you wouldn't explain until I'd given Comical's identity. Should I directly ask you?

[Something_Smart]

SS I will blindly sheep you so you better have good reads and hit scum!

I appreciate the sentiment, but you should pretty much under no circumstances sheep my scumreads.

What's your read on my slot?

[OkaPoka]

SS you should have more faith in yourself! You did well in TM

[Auro]

@dann: could've asked with variables , I don't recall specifics but something along the lines of if Comical was FL then stuff you town/scumread him for should be much closer to null, or something. Thanks for taking time to respond to my questions. I think that should come from a place of being co-operative town rather than respecting a player though

@SS: I like your reads and pushes and acknowledge Oka's point about your changed style but also think you'd actually tend to prefer being laid back as scum. So, town?

[Something_Smart]

I mean it's not that I'm incapable of having good scumreads. It's just that a lot of times I don't, and even when I do, they're usually on people who are widely agreed to be scummy (such as unwnd and pops in TM, or STRQ and Amrun in Purgatory), so that it wouldn't be necessary to sheep me since you can just see for yourself.

Sheeping my townreads, especially my confident ones, is more reasonable since they tend to be for unusual or offbeat reasons.

[Auro]

if Comical was FL then stuff you town/scumread him for should be much closer to null

If you thought* and that would be scummy vs if you didn't think he was FL in which case I can buy the thought process(es)

[OkaPoka]

sheeping trs is boring

i only sheep scumreads

[Auro]

I mean it's not that I'm incapable of having good scumreads. It's just that a lot of times I don't, and even when I do, they're usually on people who are widely agreed to be scummy (such as unwnd and pops in TM, or STRQ and Amrun in Purgatory), so that it wouldn't be necessary to sheep me since you can just see for yourself.

Sheeping my townreads, especially my confident ones, is more reasonable since they tend to be for unusual or offbeat reasons.

Issok I was just curious to see how you'd react
Yeah, I agree with Luna town reasoning.

[Alchemist21]

Auro's managed to move himself into my Townpile now.

[Dannflor]

co-operative town

I wasn't feeling very much like co-operative town last night so I had to search for motivation from elsewhere

[Dannflor]

VOTE: Alchemist

[Dannflor]

if Comical was FL then stuff you town/scumread him for should be much closer to null

If you thought* and that would be scummy vs if you didn't think he was FL in which case I can buy the thought process(es)

I thought he was FL

[Alchemist21]

VOTE: Dannflor

[OkaPoka]

okay what just happened did i miss some context somewhere