Open 775: Hard-Boiled Eggs [Game Over]

[72offsuit]

Hiraki

Overall tunnelling on me with 0 reasoning. Worse yet, doesn't direct any questions at me or dissect any posts to try to sort out my slot.
Scummy ++
Yes, I know, i know only I know my alignment, but my point still stands.
The proposed lynch pool of 5 players is way too much, does not feel townie, feels like a survivalist scattershotgun approach. Any lynch, just not me. sort of mindset.
Pretty much guaranteed that (probably just single) 1 scum is in these 4 if Hiraki is scum.

141 Townie vibe - Feels genuine and the analysis sounds town-motvated.

187 Townie vibe - Agree with the questioning of Ico - the reasoning of the vote on Allom felt odd. Opportunistic hop on if Allom is town.

228 Scummy vibe - Disagree with the contradicting himself. Town is more like to change their mind relative to scum who are more likely to tunnel.
I dont see it as contradiction, but rather a change of mind post meta reading.

[72offsuit]

Allom - reasons stated earlier. Post since then have been pretty much NAI, so still just a scumlean.

[Madoka]

yall be scumreading me you should vote me

I think a better option would be you contributing more, don't you think?

[72offsuit]

DDL

Overall fluff galore, votes for the sake of it, mostly not even creating pressure - too short a time on any 1 player to create any pressure ---- scummy

216 Totally dismissive of questioning about his tet vote - scummy


269 to 275 - In real-ish time discussion with Madoka, between 1040 and 1052.

275 - feels like scum with no defense to their scummy behaviour

277 Scummy vibe - 10:40-10:52: comes up with a nothing-content / nongenuine feeling read, which I agree with Hiraki, I dont agree with his reasoning.
Its a read for the sake of a read, after pressure was on him from Madoka.

299 Votes me with little reasoning, seemingly hoping to get onto wagon early.

303 Scummy vibe - no order to his lynch priority. Anyone other than me will do attitude. Survivalistic

306 Scummy ++ 2nd most strongest scumread is looker, the zero content nullest slot ever???? Does not feel like town scumhunting at all.
Mentions vague meta, which given trhe lack of explanation feels lamisty that he went to the effort of doing a super shallow meta "dive"

[72offsuit]

Alora

Overall lots of dry questions that arent really probing or authentic-scumhunting feeling
Not only feels like pretend scumhunting but also liek scum trying to interact with several slots for distancing purposes, just something fake scum tend to do.

238 Townie vibe - Feels like an authentic read on the hiraki v battle mage

339 Basically pushing for the non clear not to out reads for the benefit of town if the hider dies - non pro-town AT ALL.

340 Backpedals, knowing he has been scummy in his previous post.

OVerall probably a scumlean rather than scumread.

[72offsuit]

DDL is a scumread over a scumlean

[Madoka]

yall be scumreading me you should vote me

I think a better option would be you contributing more, don't you think?

Like as town why would you waste our time and a lynch.

[72offsuit]

A50/Ejji

In Ejji's town game mini normal 2121,
viewtopic.php?p=11611446&user_select%5B ... #p11611446
he outs reads thick and fast and early.
He has 61/610 posts in a 13 player game, so is an above average poster in a fairly busy game. He is also easily read as town by fellow town (obvtowns) (the Leaf player forgot the exact name, cbf relooking)
Here, he has 0 reads early and just posts fluff, and not many psots at all. The disinterest and replace out in this game is scummy (yes i know he had internet issues, but we all had, so its obv not specific to just him)

Agree with Madoka's 468 - A50's defense in 164 that it is overly rambly, longwinded and overjustifying.

[72offsuit]

Ejji or DDL for lynch today

[Looker]

yall be scumreading me you should vote me

I like your dialect.

---

• @Madoka:
  • Your vote on Almost50 is weird. Does it really count if I have to force it? (More like beg for it)
  • Raya deserved what she got for the way she played
  • I appreciate your townread, but I don't know how much credence to give it. You've read some of my games and can see my avatar, but you haven't figured out that I'm a man yet, lol
  • Ico is right: I feel like I've done literally nothing alignment-indicative yet. It's possible that that's even scummy in itself. [Don't let 72 pawn off your reads as his own, though]

MONKEY! At what point will you cast a vote of your own?

[Madoka]

@Madoka: Your vote on Almost50 is weird. Does it really count if I have to force it? (More like beg for it)

I don't know what you're saying here? Are saying the vote itself is weird because I didn't want to vote? I'm trying to keep my strongest town read from becoming apathetic. Did you read my case?

Raya deserved what she got for the way she played

She was pretty townie throughout most of the game. You chose her as your tunnel slot in RVS and stuck with her throughout the game for no reason, just as you voted Quantum here and are sticking with it.

I appreciate your townread, but I don't know how much credence to give it. You've read some of my games and can see my avatar, but you haven't figured out that I'm a man yet, lol

You've literally said multiple times that you're a girl.

Ico is right: I feel like I've done literally nothing alignment-indicative yet. It's possible that that's even scummy in itself. [Don't let 72 pawn off your reads as his own, though

I've been able to read you off a few posts each game. See: Purgatory (though I was scum that game, I town read you before I replaced in; I'm not pocketing you this time I swear!). Also did in TRF. And some games that I wasn't in.

[Madoka]

Who have you previously played with?

Looker
ejji
Dk
72
clidd

Oof, I didn’t recognize you cuz of the avatar change. Hi!

Actually, this may be a partner slip. Aloratom hadn't posted until then so Ejj wouldn't have seen his avatar unless they were posting in PT.

[Aloratom]

Alora

Overall lots of dry questions that arent really probing or authentic-scumhunting feeling
Not only feels like pretend scumhunting but also liek scum trying to interact with several slots for distancing purposes, just something fake scum tend to do.

238 Townie vibe - Feels like an authentic read on the hiraki v battle mage

339 Basically pushing for the non clear not to out reads for the benefit of town if the hider dies - non pro-town AT ALL.

340 Backpedals, knowing he has been scummy in his previous post.

OVerall probably a scumlean rather than scumread.

Think about it. Assume DkKoba says their 3 strongest Town reads and the reads are correct. That leaves 6 people left for the hider to hide behind, and 6 people for the mafia to shoot in order to double kill. Next night it leaves less if DkKoba keeps saying essentially who they're not going to target.

This is not an original thought of mine, by the way. Mathdino deserves the credit.

[Aloratom]

Who have you previously played with?

Looker
ejji
Dk
72
clidd

Oof, I didn’t recognize you cuz of the avatar change. Hi!

Actually, this may be a partner slip. Aloratom hadn't posted until then so Ejj wouldn't have seen his avatar unless they were posting in PT.

Nice thought. But last time ejji saw me was in that 2121 mini normal that 72offsuit cited in his breakdown of ejji. I'm not sure why he commented on ejji's meta from that game and not mine.

[Aloratom]

Ejji or DDL for lynch today

But you're voting Allomancer?

[Aloratom]

Nice thought. But last time ejji saw me was in that 2121 mini normal that 72offsuit cited in his breakdown of ejji. I'm not sure why he commented on ejji's meta from that game and not mine.

Or the two games he's played with me in the last two months for that matter.

[Madoka]

Who have you previously played with?

Looker
ejji
Dk
72
clidd

Oof, I didn’t recognize you cuz of the avatar change. Hi!

Actually, this may be a partner slip. Aloratom hadn't posted until then so Ejj wouldn't have seen his avatar unless they were posting in PT.

Nice thought. But last time ejji saw me was in that 2121 mini normal that 72offsuit cited in his breakdown of ejji. I'm not sure why he commented on ejji's meta from that game and not mine.

That's what I mean. You had the clown avatar then. But Ejj said he didn't recognize you despite the fact that you hadn't posted yet.

[Aloratom]

Who have you previously played with?

Looker
ejji
Dk
72
clidd

Oof, I didn’t recognize you cuz of the avatar change. Hi!

Actually, this may be a partner slip. Aloratom hadn't posted until then so Ejj wouldn't have seen his avatar unless they were posting in PT.

Nice thought. But last time ejji saw me was in that 2121 mini normal that 72offsuit cited in his breakdown of ejji. I'm not sure why he commented on ejji's meta from that game and not mine.

That's what I mean. You had the clown avatar then. But Ejj said he didn't recognize you despite the fact that you hadn't posted yet.

Gotcha.

[Madoka]

Ech. Not a fan of that after thinking about it for a moment.

Not a fan of what? I can't remember if I already asked this.

[DkKoba]

my only solid tr right now is 72

[DkKoba]

yall be scumreading me you should vote me

idk about yall but .. i really like this post for some reason. I just really do, and I don't see myself lynching DDL today.

[DkKoba]

i still don't trust the rest of yall, the play is sloppy today.

[Tet]

Who have you previously played with?

Looker
ejji
Dk
72
clidd

Oof, I didn’t recognize you cuz of the avatar change. Hi!

Actually, this may be a partner slip. Aloratom hadn't posted until then so Ejj wouldn't have seen his avatar unless they were posting in PT.

He posted before ejji in this very quote chain. Or im high.

[Hiraki]

Actually, re-reading 418 and 423, I'll retract.

UNVOTE: Battle Mage

This is beautiful. Knew I wasn't wrong here.

Explain please.

Better than expected posting.

What's the purpose of discussing it right now? Philosophy discussion just gives scum a way to post stuff without actually contributing.

This is stupid.

I feel like this is a lot of drumroll for something that promises to be anticlimactic.

This is correct.

468 to 471 is just one stinky poo poo split into 4 posts.

I wanna say that I respectfully disagree with your ejjilmost scumread, I was townreading that based off of tone and the post related to hider claiming (which didn't benefit scum AT ALL)

Thank you. A50 has been redeeming eji, not making him worse. I don't think a flaking player justifies the current response of the current player.

i like the position of most of your reads, kinda

Yucky.

The proposed lynch pool of 5 players is way too much, does not feel townie, feels like a survivalist scattershotgun approach. Any lynch, just not me. sort of mindset.

It's called townhunting?

Worse yet, doesn't direct any questions at me or dissect any posts to try to sort out my slot.

Coincidentally, this is also the first time you've posted real content. Look at that. Why do I need to ask you questions to sort out your slot? Can't I do that without consulting you? All I really need is to convince other people, hopefully townies, that you are scum and then hopefully I'm right. That's the name of this game - it's not about you proving your innocence. That would be my judgment to make.

Ech. Not a fan of that after thinking about it for a moment.

Not a fan of what? I can't remember if I already asked this.

The post above it.

my only solid tr right now is 72

Yikes

[Hiraki]

Btw - I can join orange if it is actually L-2. I don't want to count atm and I don't want to accidentally hammer.

@Mod: Votecount please?