BooneyToonz UPick: Boon There, Done That [END]

[Venus and Mars]

Caught up, and I've got next to nothing.

Far, far too much "[Person A] did [thing B] to [Person C] in [game D]"

I basically switched off after a few pages, so TBH I don't have much to add. Many of the things that stood out as interesting have been discussed and dealt with already so no point in bringing them up again, except...

@Vecna/chkflip chkflip said he couldn't let Vecna's role live but then doesn't vote Vecna. Vecna doesn't comment on it. What the? It's an odd interaction.

This is blatant misrepresentation of what was said, don't like.

If I missed anything relevant in pages 21 to 25-ish can some please tell me what it was, i decided to skip the dissection of a previous game.

snip...
But if they can stay alive long enough they will give us good info.
...snip

Imagine I don't have the vaguest clue about Nancy and explain why the above is true please.

Reads so far...

Vecna and Chronos are most likely town

KK is (are?) town leaning

Virtually everyone else is null

Titus is slight sumread because of the above post.

I actually tl the bolded.

[Krazy Katz]

I kinda dislike the way fonz skated away the conflicts on day 1 tbh

it certainly would have been townier to be like... at least nominally peacemakery

[Michael Scott]

"skated away"? more detail with quoted posts?

[Michael Scott]

krusty krabz is this the point at which we start tunneling each other? :3

[Venus and Mars]

I kinda dislike the way fonz skated away the conflicts on day 1 tbh

it certainly would have been townier to be like... at least nominally peacemakery

The only thing bothering - other than of course his horrible read on me - is there seems to be a bit of a disconnect from how he interacted with me in TBORTB and this game. The main reason I townlocked him in that game was practically every post of his oozed sincerity. I know this is really weak but I’m finding it harder to see that here. Definitely agree with you on SF. I feel pretty confident on them being town now.

[Venus and Mars]

krusty krabz is this the point at which we start tunneling each other? :3

Is this going to be like that King Arthur game again? I hope not.

[Michael Scott]

he's not jokey enoiugh to be town

[Krazy Katz]

Well I mean we need a lynch and every option gets shut down

I'm jokey when the game is on track to be won lol

-K

[Krazy Katz]

@Kakeguri: it is strongly my belief that alignment is not randomised prior to role creation, and that someone who wanted to be scum could influence role allocation by picking scum only roles for the Booneytoonz list, or quotes from players from games where they were scum, etc.

I didn't particularly like the attempted angle shot onto scum reading chk

@Kakeguri: it is strongly my belief that alignment is not randomised prior to role creation, and that someone who wanted to be scum could influence role allocation by picking scum only roles for the Booneytoonz list, or quotes from players from games where they were scum, etc.

Your strong belief is wrong. Undivulged non-randomness is bastard. Alignment is assumed to be randomised.

Upicks are inherently non random.

or this

Boon actively refused to answer the "Which came first, alignments or roles" type question btw, but implied it could be worked out based on in thread information.

Actually, in retrospect I think *this* was the post that made me townlean fonz for a while through day 2 and looking at it again I don't townread him for it at all

Oh God we're going to get into another of those arguments about which specific escalation between "Your reads are wrong" and "I wish actual rl suffering on you and your loved ones" was the one that actually crossed the line. I'mma tap out for 24hrs for the sake of my mental health as I find these things deeply uncomfortable. Hopefully something happens to allow me to get a firmer read on the game on my return.

feel like this was a missed opportunity to be townie

Back. No real new insights. I guess nothing I've seen from
Dave precludes scum. Happy there's a George wagon.

didn't like this at the time and I think I said so

This is tough because a lot of the argumentation seems to be meta claims between pairs of players I've not seen together before

Hey, the Boon Shakespeare game was really unpleasant for me mentally, and I make zero apologies for stepping out of this one for the sake of my wellbeing when it looked like it was going that way again. That wasn't a prodge, because I was active prior to it. I was very much actively in the game at that moment and needed to stop being.

As for the second I'm not making up a fucking read just to satisfy you, so go away.

I appreciate this but I mean the activity never really picked up from Fonz even though this game got a lot less toxic than it was early day 1

Eh, I think this is a reasonable twist on a juvenile delinquent; instead of potentially disabling all cops N1, it slowly removes cop abilities from the thread. And it makes sense for it to be a penalty you can remove, but it costs you a town lynch. It's also possible that certain roles are immune; my own role has a modifier whose in game effect is explicitly unknown, so I'm guessing there may be other unexplained modifiers out there, one of which might confer immunity.

this almost feels like... semi tmi?

idk I just find a lot from the early iso I still don't particularly like

why is this slot so townread by people I don't get it?

-K

[Krazy Katz]

I actually don't even super mind if you push me some time this game auro but I'm a really bad lynch this day specifically for reasons I don't want to get into right now

I'm almost totally indifferent to endgaming or not though so if you decide you want to lynch me tomorrow let me know and we can talk about it

-K

[Venus and Mars]

Ok yeah Vecna's scum. I didn't read that fight in detail but accusing Nancy of lying and saying I should know better is enough for a scumread combined with his role.

I also don't trust the infect back comment. Infect back only works if we never lynch the slots he targets but

he refuses to townread Nancy and Auro

(I think this is what Vecna meant by pops hydra) who I feel are the most likely obvtown slots.

Howdy partners. I've arbitrarily decide Michael Scott is town VOTE: BTE

I think he is too, what does that have to do with BTE?

That's where MS is voting and I trust him undoubtedly.

I still have never gotten an answer as to why MS is so trusted.

Krazy, this is why MS is town. She tmi’d him town in 1492.

[Venus and Mars]

he's not jokey enoiugh to be town

He’s a lot more jokey here than in that game.

[Krazy Katz]

I mean the issue is we still don't have a lynch

whoooo doooo weee lynnchhhhh

-K

[Krazy Katz]

I mean all I have heard on fonz town is "auro thinks he is town because [reason]" which is great when I'm only barely above nulltown on auro lol

-K

[Venus and Mars]

Spoiler:

When did I say you were ascetic? I said I got no result.

~Amrun

Then the logical conclusion is roleblocked not guilty, particularly when someone else already has a fake guilty on me. Yet, you jumped to the scum conclusion implying I was ascetic.

When did I say you were ascetic? I said I got no result.

~Amrun

Then the logical conclusion is roleblocked not guilty, particularly when someone else already has a fake guilty on me. Yet, you jumped to the scum conclusion implying I was ascetic.

What?

Why would me being roleblocked mean you were not guilty? How are those related?

I got some strange virus thing that totally mutated my role. I have no idea how that interacts with my results. It is the logical conclusion that my results are unreliable vs nomnom.

~Amrun

Then why are you voting as if your results matter rather than just blocked.

Why aren't you suspecting the guy who claimed the same role as you?

But damn 3 night 1 cops, I am kinda lost in what is going on here.

~Venus

The one cop that got a result is fucked with.

Krazy should claim their prize btw.

@Conspire, none of these read like buddy posts to me.

@Auro, this is why KK isn’t scum.

[Michael Scott]

he's not jokey enoiugh to be town

He’s a lot more jokey here than in that game.

Was joking lol, a reference to Excalibur

[Michael Scott]

I'm almost totally indifferent to endgaming or not though so if you decide you want to lynch me tomorrow let me know and we can talk about it

I mean I'm slightly concerned about our read differences also given I find your "not lynch" reasonings kinda bleh
Why do you want SF in the game again?

[Krazy Katz]

If I explained I know 100% that xtoxm would get annoyed at me and I also guarantee that 0 other people in this game would find it convincing

I just lean town for one very dumb reason

-K

[Venus and Mars]

I think the barb sender is probably scum but I can neuter that probably.

BTE also spewed town by this.

[Krazy Katz]

like if you want to lynch xtoxm you can I just... will only hammer to avoid no lynch basically

-K

[Venus and Mars]

he's not jokey enoiugh to be town

He’s a lot more jokey here than in that game.

Was joking lol, a reference to Excalibur

Yeah that’s it. You were wrongly sr him for not being jokey enough and Maria misvigged you both.

[Krazy Katz]

like this would be a weird question but Nancy do you have a read on duckling's head specifically?

-K

[Krazy Katz]

Yeah that’s it. You were wrongly sr him for not being jokey enough and Maria misvigged you both.

nah maria wasn't the vig, it was kokichi who actually was the bp killer right?

[Venus and Mars]

like if you want to lynch xtoxm you can I just... will only hammer to avoid no lynch basically

-K

No, I don’t want to lynch Xtoxm, I’m pretty sure he’s town because of his cop post stuff.

[Michael Scott]

It was Kokichi lol