Guns & Roses IV [Game Over]

[votato]

preferred wagons were cakez, lilith, chkflip at least. well really pretty much anyone, although knightmares posts at the very end had me reconsidering.

is it strange that both ABR and DC are alive? those are safe shots for scum right? or are they not good shots cuz they give town too much info?

scum probably shot both SS and firebringer right?

DC needs to claim now.

There's a very real chance that DC is scum who took rose and fakeclaimed gun yesterday.

Why not see if there is a CC? Or what makes you think scum wouldn't lie about being a rose N1

Im just wondering what makes one more likely then the other for claims.

well if DC says I shot xyz and xyz is alive and picked rose n2 instead of n1, then we know one of them is scum.

and killing one scum is a free win? you were so sure yesterday that DC AND cakez were scum. We now know at least one of those was wrong. Why should we still think that the other part is right?

[farside22]

preferred wagons were cakez, lilith, chkflip at least. well really pretty much anyone, although knightmares posts at the very end had me reconsidering.

is it strange that both ABR and DC are alive? those are safe shots for scum right? or are they not good shots cuz they give town too much info?

scum probably shot both SS and firebringer right?

DC needs to claim now.

There's a very real chance that DC is scum who took rose and fakeclaimed gun yesterday.

Why not see if there is a CC? Or what makes you think scum wouldn't lie about being a rose N1

Im just wondering what makes one more likely then the other for claims.

well if DC says I shot xyz and xyz is alive and picked rose n2 instead of n1, then we know one of them is scum.

You seem pretty confident DC is lying without a CC.
Consider this a preFos on you.
Pending info.

I want to see what icon claims for last night.

[votato]

didnt ico retract the claim? or was that just pussyfooting to claim but not get shot by scum?

[DonCorleone]

Icon hardclaimed gun around the close of D1 and said he was going to shoot me with it which he evidently didn’t do either because he (1) changed his mind given farside’s appeals to him or some other element of his own judgement or (2) because he doesn’t have a gun at all

[DonCorleone]

DC needs to claim now

Lol, do one ABR I’ll claim when I’m good and ready, and not before I hear what icon has to say

[DonCorleone]

Alfred “bold text” rampage

[DonCorleone]

The simple answer in my own mind was that scum thought I would be easier to lynch or maybe get vigged compared to Knightmare that came out of left field. But I'm not surprised, everyone who townreads me gets paranoia of me. I'm MafiaR remember

I don’t think you realise how much I want this to be true but depending on what icon says the game feels too easy if you’re town

As in, if there’s no CCs on guns, then there’s 3 clears, I think my failed kill may be a softclear on that person, if icon has another different failed kill softclear then we’re at like 5 clears/softclears

So if you’re also town then that puts it at 3 scum in 4 remaining players out of 10, within which I have one other solid TR too

[DonCorleone]

Can you be more clear on what you're asking? More so I don't get what you're asking.

Oh right, also this: I think we should be sorting into two pools — most likely scum on-wagon and most likely scum off-wagon, then decide which group to lynch within. I’m thinking off-wagon is stronger if we have 2 ICs within it (again, assuming no CC on icon who I’m still struggling to believe is town and am quite frankly astonished that no one has CC’d his gun) and then 2 left. Which would mean pretty much a lock on 1 scum in (vecna, votato) unless all 3 scum were on the D1 wagon which I find unlikely

[votato]

Can you be more clear on what you're asking? More so I don't get what you're asking.

Oh right, also this: I think we should be sorting into two pools — most likely scum on-wagon and most likely scum off-wagon, then decide which group to lynch within. I’m thinking off-wagon is stronger if we have 2 ICs within it (again, assuming no CC on icon who I’m still struggling to believe is town and am quite frankly astonished that no one has CC’d his gun) and then 2 left. Which would mean pretty much a lock on 1 scum in (vecna, votato) unless all 3 scum were on the D1 wagon which I find unlikely

those pools seem wayyyyy more complicated than they need to be. why not just sort people into either scum or not scum? then we lynch all the scum and go home. ezpz.

[Iconeum]

@iconeum claim your shot

i'm not a N1 gun

[Iconeum]

i'm a N2 gun tho

[votato]

better lynch me because i'm shooting you tonight

Hardclaim gun

have fun with that

I find it mildly hilarious that I explicitly called how bad it was for town for a massclaim to happen and yet all 3 guns have now claimed D1.

i'm not a gun, probably, but i was making a statement that 20 pages in less then half a day is a little much to keep up with

fair warning if i'm a gun i'm shooting in the pool of anyone in the +200 post count

hmmm... that is all

[chkflip]

You're terrible at this, y'know?

[Iconeum]

@me?

[chkflip]

No Ico I knew you were town the whole time bb you get no sweat from me.

[chkflip]

Matter of fact. Shouldn't have moved off of this yesterDay.

VOTE: votato

[votato]

FoS on you for really liking some of my posts. Im objectively bad at this game. although i did say knightmare was town and a stupid lynch...

[Iconeum]

k DonC ur up

[votato]

Saying im bad is iioa, and it's info everyone knows.

[FakeGod]

VoteCount 2.1

Vecna [3] - MariaR, DonCorleone, lilith2013
eyestott [1] - Albert B. Rampage
votato [1] - chkflip

Not Voting [5]

- Iconeum, farside22, votato, Vecna, eyestott

With 10 alive it takes 6 votes to be chosen.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2020-05-12 15:35:31)

[chkflip]

Buzzword roulette! Oh man. Come to the game with someone that isn't word vomit and maybe I'll move my vote.

[chkflip]

some

thing

, that is.

[Vecna]

Can you be more clear on what you're asking? More so I don't get what you're asking.

Oh right, also this: I think we should be sorting into two pools — most likely scum on-wagon and most likely scum off-wagon, then decide which group to lynch within. I’m thinking off-wagon is stronger if we have 2 ICs within it (again, assuming no CC on icon who I’m still struggling to believe is town and am quite frankly astonished that no one has CC’d his gun) and then 2 left. Which would mean pretty much a lock on 1 scum in (vecna, votato) unless all 3 scum were on the D1 wagon which I find unlikely

Youre just building assumption upon assumption here though.

There were 3 shots. We do not know if those were actual misses, the scum NK or a combination of factors. We also do not know of the 3 town guns how many of them are N1 guns.

Scum has a ton more info than town here, and they can produce easy claims regardless if even one of them had a N1 gun

[Vecna]

i'm a N2 gun tho

Why did you claim gun at all? Especially if its N2? That signalled to scum you were a free kill

[Vecna]

Hmmm, @ that last part, that could actually have good implications as well