SIR Disease Mafia - Game Over!

[gobbledygook]

I mentioned this earlier, but the game has ended now so I can post about it. Ari’s play here so far reminds me of his play in Ginngie Pick 4 U. Ari’s play was lackluster there and it seems lackluster here but he has been putting in a modicum of effort similar to that game.

You didn't mention what Ari's alignment was in that game, so this isn't as useful a post as it could be.

My mistake. He was town in that game. I think he is probably town in this game because his play looks really similar to his play in that game. I incorrectly scumread him in that game for the majority of the game.

[gobbledygook]

VOTE: Suadade

Why, Mr. Cancer Causer?

[Jake The Wolfie]

Throw at me hard math problems. Prefer probability questions :3

These are averages. What do you do with them?

6.95 4.16 126.26 1.2 62.13 56.73

Consume

[gobbledygook]

Whatever. Why did I come back here?

VOTE: Jake the Wolfie

Also, is a good reason not to vote someone because they have 5 votes or did I not see the full argument there?

Okay...

VOTE: Saudade

Let's just get the day over with already.

farside has a lot of empty votes? or is it just me?

I might be able to vote for Auro, but only if they show up soon.

P-Edit: Priceless.

[/v]Auro[/v]

VOTE: Auro

These can go at this point:
Jake
5G
Hactoc
Creature
Ari

Okay, that's not a bad list rn.

These were the posts that I remember pinging me when I did a quick skim of Quick yesterday. After reading more of his iso today it looks like he is really just trying to get anyone lynched. If you look at his iso when he votes, he votes almost everyone. His vote doesn't carry any weight because he moves it so much and he is generally making the gamestate harder to play in. I think both of those things are scum traits. Plus, he hypocritically shades Farside for having empty votes when he empty votes the majority of the time he votes.

I think looking at Quick's vote on ETL is important too. His vote swung the tide over onto ETL. It is interesting he didn't vote Ari despite Ari frequently appearing in a list or Quick suspecting him throughout the day. I could be wrong on Ari!town, especially if Quick flips scum.

Quick (2504), Miss Lynch (2558), Vecna (2589), Elements (2594), Auro (2597), Flavor Leaf (2638), mastina (2663), 5G Tower (2684)

I think these votes are the worst votes on the ETL wagon. Specifically, I find Quick, Miss Lynch, Elements, Flavor Leaf, and 5G Tower to be bad votes.
I am giving Mastina a pass for her vote because I think her play today places her as solid town unless she randomly decided to want to try as scum in this game in which case gg us. I am also giving Vecna the benefit of the doubt for his vote because I think he was pretty townie yesterday. Same with Auro.

Of the votes I noted, I think the worst ones are 5G Tower, Quick, Elements, Flavor Leaf. 5G Tower has an absolutely TERRIBLE iso. Somehow that slot has 21 posts in a 130 page game. That needs to die. Quick for the reasons I have stated. Elements is also a really bad vote because he called ETL town and then ignored that slot until he placed a vote on it. Flavor Leaf is bad because I have seen FL do this type of play as scum before. However, he at least gave clear reasoning for the vote. The others did not.

{Quick, 5G, Elements} have highest scum equity with FL in there as well.

{Nero Cain, Mastina} is my town core that I need to add to. I think I am comfortable putting Auro and TSE in there for the time being.

[Nero Cain]

I'm still here but not all that interested in this game. Still feel Dave and tchill should die. And a50.

[Quick]

I've consistently pushed the same people over and over in D1. Try harder. It boils down to lynching useless slots to get people who actually put in effort. I have never been good at pushing lynches though on my correct Scum reads.

[Quick]

I'm still here but not all that interested in this game. Still feel Dave and tchill should die. And a50.

Explain A50 because I am pretty sure I agree. I also agree on Tchill, but I feel dave is Town here.

[Jake The Wolfie]

Am I dead yet?

[davesaz]

I'm still here but not all that interested in this game. Still feel Dave and tchill should die. And a50.

You certainly like controversial stances this game. I don't see scum trying to take this particular hill. Or at least not at this time.

[Aristophanes]

So like, why does a post like that make me even more likely to be scum in your eyes?

It's part of a non-activity scumtell I have on you.

It's not an absolute 100%-guaranteed-accurate-lockscum tell, but it

is

a solid 75-90%ish sure indicator of you being scum here--and respectfully, I'm not your scumbuddy here so I am under no obligation to out it. I can, and will, if I need to. But I would prefer to lynch you without resorting to outing the tell, because I would

prefer

to lynch you based on the merits everyone can see about you and still have the tell in my arsenal in future games and not give you the chance to correct it.

Quoting the post is, at this time, the only hint you'll get as to the nature of the tell.

So, to answer you: if you are town, I understand why you are asking and the value that'd have to a town-you. But because I think you are more likely scum here, and I'd rather not out the tell if I don't have to, I must decline, sorry.

I can respect that! And I am now quite intrigued! XD

[Aristophanes]

I mentioned this earlier, but the game has ended now so I can post about it. Ari’s play here so far reminds me of his play in Ginngie Pick 4 U. Ari’s play was lackluster there and it seems lackluster here but he has been putting in a modicum of effort similar to that game.

You didn't mention what Ari's alignment was in that game, so this isn't as useful a post as it could be.

My mistake. He was town in that game. I think he is probably town in this game because his play looks really similar to his play in that game. I incorrectly scumread him in that game for the majority of the game.

The turkey is correct!

[Hoctac]

Quick, lynch Saudade before skitter can replace in and save his slot!

I agree with the assessment on Creature.

[Hoctac]

Loving the wall posts btw. Keep them coming and I might even make a couple.

[Hoctac]

In fact, here's a teaser:

[Tchill13]

If you have time, I would invite you to take her up on her word and actually skim a few of her recent scumgames, and give me an evaluation on how they compare. If you find this close to her towngames and farther from her scumgames, that implies she's suddenly changing her scum meta this game - and that would be a little unlikely, yeah? The farther back you go, the stronger this argument gets. This isn't a matter of capabilities, or whether she *could*, instead whether she *would*.

I pretty much refuse to use meta unless is natural from my games played with someone where I can go off memory.

[Alchemist21]

Mastina and Nahdia both Town af.

I know she shouldn’t say it out loud but I kinda want to know what Mastina’s looking for from Creature.

[Tchill13]

Why does the source matter? On a side note, I engage fully with people I scumread also

in setup spec specifically theres no point to engage scum imo.

[Tchill13]

UNVOTE:

shes not getting lynched today. Wall posts= town right?

VOTE: suadade

[Alchemist21]

UNVOTE:

shes not getting lynched today. Wall posts= town right?

VOTE: suadade

The actual content of her posts is Town. She’s laying out every single read in a way that anyone can see the progression and how they’ve developed. I also doubt scum goes this hard on a self meta argument.

[Aristophanes]

7/11 on Saudade fyi

[Tchill13]

The actual content of her posts is Town. She’s laying out every single read in a way that anyone can see the progression and how they’ve developed. I also doubt scum goes this hard on a self meta argument.

scum cant do that? Just because she has more time and effort she's town right? cool.

[gobbledygook]

I'm still here but not all that interested in this game. Still feel Dave and tchill should die. And a50.

I disagree about Tchill. Why do you want Dave and A50? What do you think of Quick, 5G, and Elements/Nadhia?

[gobbledygook]

The actual content of her posts is Town. She’s laying out every single read in a way that anyone can see the progression and how they’ve developed. I also doubt scum goes this hard on a self meta argument.

scum cant do that? Just because she has more time and effort she's town right? cool.

I mean... yeah lol. You sound unhappy about this development, though. Are you unhappy because of the principle of the reads on Mastina or is it something else?

[gobbledygook]

Why are we wagoning a slot that is being replaced and not Quick?

[Aristophanes]

Why are we wagoning a slot that is being replaced and not Quick?

Because Quick is towny?