SIR Disease Mafia - Game Over!

[Nahdia]

bc this game feels like we're just spinning our wheels doing nothing.

Why do you think this?

town isn't really working together, theyre just bickering about mechanical stuff which has no bearing on actual scumhunting. wagons aren't coalescing, pressure is nonexistent.

{OkaPoka}
{Alchemist, Ari}
{davesaz}
{TSE, A50}
{Auro, Creature, Hoctac, gobbledygook, Voted}
{Tchill, Jake, Flavor Leaf}
{mastina}
{Nero, 5G}
{Quick, Saudade}


not sure what i think of the Jake thing. feels overblown tbh, though oka's progression on it reads town to me.

also @Jake, i dont actually think it's against the rules to word-for-word your own message to a mod. as long as you're not like, PROVING you actually sent that message by actually quoting the PM or whatnot. you could say for example "I asked the mod 'blah blah blah blah blah blah blah' and then they answered (paraphrased answer)". maybe im wrong about that but like, you could always lie about the way you worded the question so i dont think it breaks a rule.

[Quick]

Oka, don't be dumb. I was the first person to see you as Town since you replaced in.

[Quick]

town isn't really working together, theyre just bickering about mechanical stuff which has no bearing on actual scumhunting. wagons aren't coalescing, pressure is nonexistent.

That's... Kinda BS since I have been working with my TRs for like 20 pages, but you do you.

[Nahdia]

and you have what to show for it?

[Quick]

and you have what to show for it?

I don't understand the question. What exactly do you expect me to get out of it? Town

is

not really cooperating but that is mostly due to all my TRs SRing each other.

[Jake The Wolfie]

bc this game feels like we're just spinning our wheels doing nothing.

Why do you think this?

town isn't really working together, theyre just bickering about mechanical stuff which has no bearing on actual scumhunting. wagons aren't coalescing, pressure is nonexistent.

{OkaPoka}
{Alchemist, Ari}
{davesaz}
{TSE, A50}
{Auro, Creature, Hoctac, gobbledygook, Voted}
{Tchill, Jake, Flavor Leaf}
{mastina}
{Nero, 5G}
{Quick, Saudade}


not sure what i think of the Jake thing. feels overblown tbh, though oka's progression on it reads town to me.

also @Jake, i dont actually think it's against the rules to word-for-word your own message to a mod. as long as you're not like, PROVING you actually sent that message by actually quoting the PM or whatnot. you could say for example "I asked the mod 'blah blah blah blah blah blah blah' and then they answered (paraphrased answer)". maybe im wrong about that but like, you could always lie about the way you worded the question so i dont think it breaks a rule.

The fact that I already game their exact answer means that I can't give the exact question.

[Quick]

I'll wait for your follow up.

[Jake The Wolfie]

The more I think about this, the more I find it silly that you are attacking an answer the mod gave me rather than finding another angle to dig at. It almost feels like not only you think that I purposefully lied, but that at any second I'll reveal the rest of my hand and say "Yeah, you got me."

[Nahdia]

it's because theyre all desperate for something concrete to cling to.

because again we have next to no information in this game, and town is failing at traditional scumhunting bc of all the lurkers/replacements/game length.

[Quick]

it's because theyre all desperate for something concrete to cling to.

because again we have next to no information in this game, and town is failing at traditional scumhunting bc of all the lurkers/replacements/game length.

pl0x An4 me!!!

[Jake The Wolfie]

This seems like an incredibly stupid thing for me to defend tbh. Can we just act like I just said "I lied, I didn't actually ask the mod anything" and move on, or is there some merit to this discussion?

[Quick]

This seems like an incredibly stupid thing for me to defend tbh. Can we just act like I just said "I lied, I didn't actually ask the mod anything" and move on, or is there some merit to this discussion?

It's too late. A mob has formed...

[Jake The Wolfie]

This seems like an incredibly stupid thing for me to defend tbh. Can we just act like I just said "I lied, I didn't actually ask the mod anything" and move on, or is there some merit to this discussion?

It's too late. A mob has formed...[/quote

A mob will form on anything.

Hell, remove everything in the universe, and a mob will still form over *something*

[Quick]

This seems like an incredibly stupid thing for me to defend tbh. Can we just act like I just said "I lied, I didn't actually ask the mod anything" and move on, or is there some merit to this discussion?

It's too late. A mob has formed...

A mob will form on anything.

Hell, remove everything in the universe, and a mob will still form over *something*[/quote]

I appreciate this.

[OkaPoka]

Jake you forget that you took initiative in pushing voted for his question to the mod. It is you who found a contradiction and pushed it, not him. You can't have your cake and eat it too.

[OkaPoka]

And Quick, I really don't care if you managed to nail me as town first. That's not indicative of anything except that you have me as town.

[OkaPoka]

Like if you did lie and not ask the mod anything, then of course we go back to the square of why did you lie? You can't still explain that and the most reasonable answer to me is an insidious one.

[Quick]

And Quick, I really don't care if you managed to nail me as town first. That's not indicative of anything except that you have me as town.

Okay Mr. Poka. Just know that when you flip Jake and he turns out to be villa, don't let me tell you I told you so...

[OkaPoka]

Quick, if you believe Jake is town. And let's assume you are town from your PoV. Do you really think that nero/TSE are town? You think its possible that four townies collectively shit the bed and sided with a lie and none of them did their due diligence?

[Jake The Wolfie]

Jake you forget that you took initiative in pushing voted for his question to the mod. It is you who found a contradiction and pushed it, not him. You can't have your cake and eat it too.

In a world where I didn't lie, my actions are completely justified. I saw a contradiction and I announced it.

[OkaPoka]

Yeah except now you are saying its not a contradiction? Or are you maintaining that Voted is a liar?

[davesaz]

I kinda want to SR everyone who is nagging Jake about the "no comment" post.
Seriously folks, it's easy to mess up a question in such a way that the mod can't answer without spilling the key details of a setup.
There are cases where almost any reaction by the mod to a question, including no reaction at all, could spoil the setup.

There are better reasons to SR the slot. I propose we look at people who look like they are genuinely uninformed and want to learn alignments vs people who look like they don't care about that or want to fit actions into a read. That is to say, play mafia. What a concept!

[Nahdia]

and you have what to show for it?

I don't understand the question. What exactly do you expect me to get out of it? Town

is

not really cooperating but that is mostly due to all my TRs SRing each other.

wagons, pressure, cases, anything really.

[OkaPoka]

I kinda want to SR everyone who is nagging Jake about the "no comment" post.
Seriously folks, it's easy to mess up a question in such a way that the mod can't answer without spilling the key details of a setup.
There are cases where almost any reaction by the mod to a question, including no reaction at all, could spoil the setup.

There are better reasons to SR the slot. I propose we look at people who look like they are genuinely uninformed and want to learn alignments vs people who look like they don't care about that or want to fit actions into a read. That is to say, play mafia. What a concept!

Jake is maintaining that him and Voted are in contradiction. He hasn't taken his Voted vote back this entire time.

[Quick]

Quick, if you believe Jake is town. And let's assume you are town from your PoV. Do you really think that nero/TSE are town? You think its possible that four townies collectively shit the bed and sided with a lie and none of them did their due diligence?

I think you are being a terrible town leader, how does that sound?