Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[farside22]

mmmm I'll go for my first scum ping
VOTE: TrueSoulEnergy

So what’s your ping on me?

Scum ping.

[farside22]

My bad, I must have missed that one.
So you read them based on a read of someone else?

And you didn't say anything about the card that was issued either.

You kind of just bypassed it. You don't look to be reading the game at all and just read lost. So first ping of the game it is.

[Two Girls One Vote]

My bad, I must have missed that one.
So you read them based on a read of someone else?

And you didn't say anything about the card that was issued either.

You kind of just bypassed it. You don't look to be reading the game at all and just read lost. So first ping of the game it is.

to be fair a lot of people havent mentioned the cards. it seems that everyone has one and it gives scum an advantage if we claim them. is there other stuff you wanna be talking about?

-the one who got paid better

[Hoctac]

Sigh, mafia Goon is so unbelievably boring; I wish I had a cool ability like the rest of you, but alas.

So instead, I'm going to play this game without checking my PT. If I don't know my partners, then I can pretend I'm a mafia reverse traitor. That's a pretty cool ability.

[Hoctac]

VOTE: farside

Might be a wolf. Not reading =/= scum. Not talking about cards when many already have =/= scum.

[Hoctac]

1) town
2) it looked like the most interesting game currently for signups
3) town because I enjoy scumhunting
4) purple
5) ircher. I will elaborate on this in the next post
6) do you want to start a wagon on ircher with me?

@hellbooks - isn't it a little early to be tunneling?

Just a weird comment from boring. Answering with Ircher to that question doesn't suggest tunneling. Feels a little forced. boring might be an Alien.

HURT: boring

Wolves:

farside

Aliens:

boring

Mafia Goon:

Hoctac

[Ircher]

All I need is for scum to crosskill. Then I'll win.

[Ircher]

HURT: Two Girls One Vote
HURT WITH A BLADE: chkflip
HEAL: TemporalLich

[TrueSoulEnergy]

My bad, I must have missed that one.
So you read them based on a read of someone else?

And you didn't say anything about the card that was issued either.

You kind of just bypassed it. You don't look to be reading the game at all and just read lost. So first ping of the game it is.

The Red Card?

[TrueSoulEnergy]

1) town
2) it looked like the most interesting game currently for signups
3) town because I enjoy scumhunting
4) purple
5) ircher. I will elaborate on this in the next post
6) do you want to start a wagon on ircher with me?

@hellbooks - isn't it a little early to be tunneling?

Just a weird comment from boring. Answering with Ircher to that question doesn't suggest tunneling. Feels a little forced. boring might be an Alien.

HURT: boring

Wolves:

farside

Aliens:

boring

Mafia Goon:

Hoctac

Which one you wanna lynch?

[Quick]

Still like my vote but I haven't started on notes for this game yet.

[Ircher]

Dayvig: hellbooks

Buh-bye.

[farside22]

My bad, I must have missed that one.
So you read them based on a read of someone else?

And you didn't say anything about the card that was issued either.

You kind of just bypassed it. You don't look to be reading the game at all and just read lost. So first ping of the game it is.

to be fair a lot of people havent mentioned the cards. it seems that everyone has one and it gives scum an advantage if we claim them. is there other stuff you wanna be talking about?

-the one who got paid better

Thats interesting that players are quick to defend this game.
Tbf i wasn't asking for color claims. Just seeing who would claim one once i found out what it did. Those who didn't were more then i expected. It was a good place to scum hunt the unclaimed.
And yes poking at players just to ask a question that is already in the game is a bit scummy.
Its not like a cop claim just a starting point.

[Chemist1422]

Dayvig: hellbooks

Buh-bye.

[Well, there goes my top townread.]

[Chemist1422]

[I get a strange feeling Ircher is a third-party of some sort.]

[hellbooks]

@boring, I'm now particularly interested in your response to my thoughts on ircher

Im impressed that you're paying so much attention, but I think you're hitting on personality quirks more than role-related behaviors. Iirc, Ircher is a bit bossy in the beginning, in most games. I think he thinks a lot about mechanics in his game-solving process, so he's ready with these ideas straight out the gate. Also, I think the pivot to his questiins was a valid response to players rejecting his idea of sharing page numbers.

I haven't made a solid judgement on whether it's his personality or his alignment yet, but I'm hoping to settle that as much as I can. your point about the pivot is good.

What boring answers! Meh, I can't think of any useful comments about this set of answers.

I recognize that I'm jumping the gun here, but with the tunneling comment from boring and this extremely awkward comment from Ircher, I think we should scrutinize for potential boring/ircher partner interactions in the future

[hellbooks]

Dayvig: hellbooks

Buh-bye.

[Well, there goes my top townread.]

I'll believe it when I see it for now, I'm just assuming it's another distraction from Ircher's bag of tricks. although, I am also considering switching on to truesoulenergy, really just looking for a wagon to get this game into gear. I'll wait to see if I have to keep playing this game though.

[Two Girls One Vote]

Dear sirs and madammes,

The two ladies of the single vote would like to announce that we have a read, and we intend to share that read with you all for your enjoyment and analysis.

Faithfully yours,

The girl who is getting paid more

[Quick]

@boring, I'm now particularly interested in your response to my thoughts on ircher

Im impressed that you're paying so much attention, but I think you're hitting on personality quirks more than role-related behaviors. Iirc, Ircher is a bit bossy in the beginning, in most games. I think he thinks a lot about mechanics in his game-solving process, so he's ready with these ideas straight out the gate. Also, I think the pivot to his questiins was a valid response to players rejecting his idea of sharing page numbers.

I haven't made a solid judgement on whether it's his personality or his alignment yet, but I'm hoping to settle that as much as I can. your point about the pivot is good.

What boring answers! Meh, I can't think of any useful comments about this set of answers.

I recognize that I'm jumping the gun here, but with the tunneling comment from boring and this extremely awkward comment from Ircher, I think we should scrutinize for potential boring/ircher partner interactions in the future

Who would you lynch first?

[Hoctac]

This is the most I've ever seen Ircher joke around in a game. He must be some kind of Confused Jester Survivor role.

[TemporalLich]

VC 1.3

farside22 (3) - Titus, Two Girls One Vote, Hoctac
Chemist1422 (2) - Doctor Drew, ManateeDude
ManateeDude (1) - Chemist1422
Two Girls One Vote (1) - Chateau Lobby
No Elimination (1) - Ircher
Ircher (1) - hellbooks
Hoctac (1) - Quick
Battle Mage (1) - TrueSoulEnergy
TrueSoulEnergy (1) - farside22

Not voting: boring, Pigman, Battle Mage, Saladman27, Iconeum

With 17 alive it takes 9 to eliminate.

Day 1 will end in (expired on 2020-06-02 15:30:00) or when an elimination is reached.

As a friendly reminder, play to win and remember to post from the correct account.

[Doctor Drew]

My bad, I must have missed that one.
So you read them based on a read of someone else?

And you didn't say anything about the card that was issued either.

You kind of just bypassed it. You don't look to be reading the game at all and just read lost. So first ping of the game it is.

I would also say that asking what caused the ping is a ping in and of itself.

[Quick]

My bad, I must have missed that one.
So you read them based on a read of someone else?

And you didn't say anything about the card that was issued either.

You kind of just bypassed it. You don't look to be reading the game at all and just read lost. So first ping of the game it is.

I would also say that asking what caused the ping is a ping in and of itself.

No? Why?

[Doctor Drew]

My bad, I must have missed that one.
So you read them based on a read of someone else?

And you didn't say anything about the card that was issued either.

You kind of just bypassed it. You don't look to be reading the game at all and just read lost. So first ping of the game it is.

I would also say that asking what caused the ping is a ping in and of itself.

No? Why?

ScumTSE wants to find out what is giving out scum vibes so he stop doing it.

It's not a end all be all tell, but it is something to kick the tires on

[Quick]

My bad, I must have missed that one.
So you read them based on a read of someone else?

And you didn't say anything about the card that was issued either.

You kind of just bypassed it. You don't look to be reading the game at all and just read lost. So first ping of the game it is.

I would also say that asking what caused the ping is a ping in and of itself.

No? Why?

ScumTSE wants to find out what is giving out scum vibes so he stop doing it.

It's not a end all be all tell, but it is something to kick the tires on

You can't draw that deduction. Weak is what it is. Otherwise, it's just asking a question and nothing more.