SIR Disease Mafia - Game Over!

[Nero Cain]

Nero felt a bit performative from the start.

what is this?

Nero, are you related to Eddie Came in any way?

thankfully no.

Also kinda think ETL is scum.

Also kinda think ETL is scum.

maybe? I'm not so sure after all. Game is a lil' odd.

didnt like these posts. especially the "Game is a lil' odd" remark on, drum roll please, post 20.

Whats summy about any of those?

[OkaPoka]

fwiw ive played with quick before and he spent the entire game as town tunneling one player and they 1v1'd for almost the entire game while everyone else was engaged in a massive brawl

What game was that? You realize it's been a solid 2 years of therapy since then right?

newbie 1881

I was Scum that game. Wow.

wait really? lol oops

Yeah... Fucking "Oops" is right. How the fuck did you mess that up?

what do you want me to say? im a braindamaged deranged lunatic who suffers from amnesia?

[OkaPoka]

like this doesn't change the essence of why i scumread you, but im willing to back off for now because i concede i might have to reevaluate

[Nahdia]

Nero felt a bit performative from the start.

what is this?

Nero, are you related to Eddie Came in any way?

thankfully no.

Also kinda think ETL is scum.

Also kinda think ETL is scum.

maybe? I'm not so sure after all. Game is a lil' odd.

didnt like these posts. especially the "Game is a lil' odd" remark on, drum roll please, post 20.

Whats summy about any of those?

...it's peformative? i feel like we're going in circles here.

those posts to me look like someone immediately trying to jump in and appear town. first "look at me im scumhunting" and then immediately to "hmm actually... this game is confusing, im uncertain!" to hedge your bets and look like town trying to sort. but like, what are you even talking about. the game was on page 1, how could you possibly already be thinking things were off? i would agree the game is off NOW for a variety of reasons, but at that point it just feels like a forced towntell. woe is me, im so uncertain, blah blah, etc.

[Alchemist21]

old Ranger

I never knew that was you.

[Alchemist21]

About the same reason I’m Townreading Mastina.

ok y?

Transparency in their thoughts.

[OkaPoka]

honestly where is gobbles

[Nahdia]

old Ranger

I never knew that was you.

it wasn't, i just emulated their style.

[Alchemist21]

honestly where is gobbles

You’re a Spring Chicken. Gobbledygook is a Thanksgiving Turkey.

[Alchemist21]

old Ranger

I never knew that was you.

it wasn't, i just emulated their style.

Oh lol

[OkaPoka]

i know this is going to like the fifth time ive said sometihng along these lines and i always break it BUT IM GOING TO TRY AND STEP BACK AND LET OTHERS LEAD

[Nero Cain]

About the same reason I’m Townreading Mastina.

ok y?

Transparency in their thoughts.

good thing that's impossible to fake as scum.

[Nero Cain]

those posts to me look like someone immediately trying to jump in and appear town. first "look at me im scumhunting" and then immediately to "hmm actually... this game is confusing, im uncertain!" to hedge your bets and look like town trying to sort. but like, what are you even talking about. the game was on page 1, how could you possibly already be thinking things were off? i would agree the game is off NOW for a variety of reasons, but at that point it just feels like a forced towntell. woe is me, im so uncertain, blah blah, etc.

As someone that just ragged on me selectively quoting or w/e you wanna call it you sure have no trouble doing that.

I was thinking ETL was scum, yes. I think my 29 perfectly explains my 20 So yes, thinking 1 thing and then finding contradictory evidence would and should make me uncertain. Also really dislike how you are claiming that I'm trying to look town instead of just being town. How do u tell the difference?

[Nahdia]

...because... it doesn't actually look like town?

[50 Judge Powers]

I got caught up.. kind of.. and then I wanted to post and.. well.. I couldn't remember a single thing of what I had intended to comment about. Now this is why I usually post while catching up and I have no friggin' idea what made me decide I wanted to do it differently this time.

Also, my bloody internet is on and off all the time now, so it's a massive let down to try to click ANYTHING at all

[Alchemist21]

I got caught up.. kind of.. and then I wanted to post and.. well.. I couldn't remember a single thing of what I had intended to comment about. Now this is why I usually post while catching up and I have no friggin' idea what made me decide I wanted to do it differently this time.

Also, my bloody internet is on and off all the time now, so it's a massive let down to try to click ANYTHING at all

How much you wanna bet 5G is responsible for your internet issues?

[Nero Cain]

I'm not really sure if Nahdia actually believes that I was complaining about the gamestate on p1. Me thinking that ETL was initially scummy and then doubting myself b/c I found something that made me original criticism invalid is just good rational play but in Nahdia's world you can never ever change an opinion.

This deserves rope/vig

[davesaz]

This game has a tendency to burst updates when I'm not available. Marking my place at the bottom of page 159.

[Nero Cain]

I disagree immensely that we should only be focusing on Jake/Quick but with 5 days till deadline I doubt anyone gets lynched but them. I think my criticism of the Jake wagon is valid here. Still don't really think that a scum Jake who knew that infected know they are infected sorta CC's voted there. It would have to be VERY VERY poor scum play if it was. I mean, it's not really impossible since scum I could see a newb scum go "hey, I'm going to throw some doubt on Voted and get him lynched!" If he's town though he'll make an ez hedge 4 scum and eat our night actions so he makes for a decent d2 lynch. Consider my vote on Jake is sprit and I'll move there when I have to.

[Alchemist21]

I disagree immensely that we should only be focusing on Jake/Quick but with 5 days till deadline I doubt anyone gets lynched but them. I think my criticism of the Jake wagon is valid here. Still don't really think that a scum Jake who knew that infected know they are infected sorta CC's voted there. It would have to be VERY VERY poor scum play if it was. I mean, it's not really impossible since scum I could see a newb scum go "hey, I'm going to throw some doubt on Voted and get him lynched!" If he's town though he'll make an ez hedge 4 scum and eat our night actions so he makes for a decent d2 lynch. Consider my vote on Jake is sprit and I'll move there when I have to.

Outside of Jake and Nahdia who would you vote?

[Quick]

I disagree immensely that we should only be focusing on Jake/Quick but with 5 days till deadline I doubt anyone gets lynched but them. I think my criticism of the Jake wagon is valid here. Still don't really think that a scum Jake who knew that infected know they are infected sorta CC's voted there. It would have to be VERY VERY poor scum play if it was. I mean, it's not really impossible since scum I could see a newb scum go "hey, I'm going to throw some doubt on Voted and get him lynched!" If he's town though he'll make an ez hedge 4 scum and eat our night actions so he makes for a decent d2 lynch. Consider my vote on Jake is sprit and I'll move there when I have to.

It really has nothing to do with that FMPOV. I would just gather that Jake was telling the truth about what the mod told him but him being Scum tainted the question he asked. That is if he is Scum here, but YMMV.

[OkaPoka]

if you want to broaden the pool of suspects, you need to do some more casework imo because afaik you are pushing nahdia for things im not sure are indeed AI

[Quick]

if you want to broaden the pool of suspects, you need to do some more casework imo because afaik you are pushing nahdia for things im not sure are indeed AI

Except Nhadia's reasons for voting me are objectively terrible and that is actually Scummy.

[OkaPoka]

i am open to broadening the conversation soon fwiw, i just want a few slots to weigh in before we move on and they decide to latch onto other things and not talk about this

[OkaPoka]

sorry quick but i don't really feel like interacting with you right now, im directing that question towards nero