Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[hellbooks]

hows this

[Quick]

hows this

Fine. It's not like a human eating a baby so I think it's fine.

[Quick]

[hellbooks]

ew

[Chemist1422]

[Why do you think Hoctac would seriously claim goon, Quick?]

Because I think Hactoc is too smart to claim goon as like VT or something. I just don't see his nonsense being THAT nonsensical.

[That doesn't answer my question.]
[Why don't you think Hoctac is too smart to claim goon as goon?]

[Quick]

[Why do you think Hoctac would seriously claim goon, Quick?]

Because I think Hactoc is too smart to claim goon as like VT or something. I just don't see his nonsense being THAT nonsensical.

[That doesn't answer my question.]
[Why don't you think Hoctac is too smart to claim goon as goon?]

Stop misrepping me.

[ManateeDude]

Quick believing that people wouldnt claim goon as goon is easy to believe but hard to take as seriously as he did so I guess he can get some towncred for now?

[hellbooks]

Like... even in the hypothetical I am Scum here, I still think Hactoc is goon.

Quick can you explain what you meant by this.

[Chemist1422]

[Why do you think Hoctac would seriously claim goon, Quick?]

Because I think Hactoc is too smart to claim goon as like VT or something. I just don't see his nonsense being THAT nonsensical.

[That doesn't answer my question.]
[Why don't you think Hoctac is too smart to claim goon as goon?]

Stop misrepping me.

[I'm not.]
[I'm asking a different question and you're not answering.]

[Quick]

Like... even in the hypothetical I am Scum here, I still think Hactoc is goon.

Quick can you explain what you meant by this.

Sure. If I am Scum, then I have every intention of catching Scum, right? So that is why I think Hactoc is Scum. I'd gladly 1v1 with Hactoc today.

[farside22]

It feels like a single party in here with a lot of gossip and no one getting to dance.
I can't recall a struggle like this where just getting a wagon on someone meet with resistance and many disagreeing.

let's get a wagon going then. I like voting Quick, who seems to be comfortable to only be dipping his toes in here and there. happy birthday to him by the way!
VOTE: Quick
if people are willing to get a wagon going on Ircher or True Soul Energy, count me in there as well

Or hactoc is just Scum. Your pick. I don't think Hactoc claims goon as a nonserious joke actually. Like... even in the hypothetical I am Scum here, I still think Hactoc is goon.

In a game like this he could be a jester role or a role that requires he gets voted out. Why assume claim = scum in this type of game?

[Quick]

It feels like a single party in here with a lot of gossip and no one getting to dance.
I can't recall a struggle like this where just getting a wagon on someone meet with resistance and many disagreeing.

let's get a wagon going then. I like voting Quick, who seems to be comfortable to only be dipping his toes in here and there. happy birthday to him by the way!
VOTE: Quick
if people are willing to get a wagon going on Ircher or True Soul Energy, count me in there as well

Or hactoc is just Scum. Your pick. I don't think Hactoc claims goon as a nonserious joke actually. Like... even in the hypothetical I am Scum here, I still think Hactoc is goon.

In a game like this he could be a jester role or a role that requires he gets voted out. Why assume claim = scum in this type of game?

Unless it ends the game, it doesn't matter and I would be fine lynching it.

[Ircher]

It feels like a single party in here with a lot of gossip and no one getting to dance.
I can't recall a struggle like this where just getting a wagon on someone meet with resistance and many disagreeing.

let's get a wagon going then. I like voting Quick, who seems to be comfortable to only be dipping his toes in here and there. happy birthday to him by the way!
VOTE: Quick
if people are willing to get a wagon going on Ircher or True Soul Energy, count me in there as well

Or hactoc is just Scum. Your pick. I don't think Hactoc claims goon as a nonserious joke actually. Like... even in the hypothetical I am Scum here, I still think Hactoc is goon.

This is a really bad take. I can say from personal experience that this conclusion is strictly false.

[Why do you think Hoctac would seriously claim goon, Quick?]

Because I think Hactoc is too smart to claim goon as like VT or something. I just don't see his nonsense being THAT nonsensical.

[That doesn't answer my question.]
[Why don't you think Hoctac is too smart to claim goon as goon?]

Stop misrepping me.

[I'm not.]
[I'm asking a different question and you're not answering.]

Chemist1422's line of questioning here is looking good.

[Quick]

It feels like a single party in here with a lot of gossip and no one getting to dance.
I can't recall a struggle like this where just getting a wagon on someone meet with resistance and many disagreeing.

let's get a wagon going then. I like voting Quick, who seems to be comfortable to only be dipping his toes in here and there. happy birthday to him by the way!
VOTE: Quick
if people are willing to get a wagon going on Ircher or True Soul Energy, count me in there as well

Or hactoc is just Scum. Your pick. I don't think Hactoc claims goon as a nonserious joke actually. Like... even in the hypothetical I am Scum here, I still think Hactoc is goon.

This is a really bad take. I can say from personal experience that this conclusion is strictly false.

[Why do you think Hoctac would seriously claim goon, Quick?]

Because I think Hactoc is too smart to claim goon as like VT or something. I just don't see his nonsense being THAT nonsensical.

[That doesn't answer my question.]
[Why don't you think Hoctac is too smart to claim goon as goon?]

Stop misrepping me.

[I'm not.]
[I'm asking a different question and you're not answering.]

Chemist1422's line of questioning here is looking good.

Okay, well you are wrong or Scum. I don't care what fruitcake reasons you have. Claiming Scum should get lynched.

[Chemist1422]

[Why does scum have motivation to claim scum over town who thinks it's funny?]

[Quick]

[Why does scum have motivation to claim scum over town who thinks it's funny?]

Maybe you are intentionally not getting my point.

Claiming Scum is something you lynch. Why not?

[Battle Mage]

Making my return to the mafia game
Another defeat would be such a shame
I know nothing yet to greatly assist
But perhaps that's because I'm already pissed
Maybe some sleep will help me repair
and I'll have something insightful to share
Bonjour Annie, tu est magnifique
although our future already looks bleak
Lynching me today would be bad recourse
And the town would experience due remorse
Some words of wisdom before I go
Town should take things nice and slow

VOTE: Quick

Gotta go fast!

ROGNTUDJUUUUUUUUU

[Chemist1422]

[Why does scum have motivation to claim scum over town who thinks it's funny?]

Maybe you are intentionally not getting my point.

Claiming Scum is something you lynch. Why not?

[My logic isn't "why not".]
[It's "why".]

[Ircher]

VOTE: Quick

[Quick]

[Why does scum have motivation to claim scum over town who thinks it's funny?]

Maybe you are intentionally not getting my point.

Claiming Scum is something you lynch. Why not?

[My logic isn't "why not".]
[It's "why".]

It's a fucking stupid joke to claim goon as VT.

[Ircher]

Ftr, don't think Quick is necessarily scum here, but a wagon on them would be healthy.

[Quick]

It feels like a single party in here with a lot of gossip and no one getting to dance.
I can't recall a struggle like this where just getting a wagon on someone meet with resistance and many disagreeing.

let's get a wagon going then. I like voting Quick, who seems to be comfortable to only be dipping his toes in here and there. happy birthday to him by the way!
VOTE: Quick
if people are willing to get a wagon going on Ircher or True Soul Energy, count me in there as well

Or hactoc is just Scum. Your pick. I don't think Hactoc claims goon

as a nonserious joke

actually. Like... even in the hypothetical I am Scum here, I still think Hactoc is goon.

[Quick]

Ftr, don't think Quick is necessarily scum here, but a wagon on them would be healthy.

Are you by any chance Hactoc's partner? voting for a wagon? I thought standard Mafia theory is to vote to lynch. Am I wrong here or are you using faulty logic?

[Ircher]

I do not subscribe to standard mafia theory. I subscribe to the Theory of Mafia as envisioned by Ircher.

[Pigman]

Strange that BattleMage and Iconeum have not posted yet.
VOTE: Battle Mage

Why’s that strange?
People are busy.

do you know battle mage or something?