Open 779: Pick Your Power X/Y Game Over!

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Because they look like town. Also, Datisi has the number 1, I wouldn't lynch there until I had better reads on other 1 pickers anyway

What special about number 1?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Between melody and aldus, I’d prefer aldus

Running up brass is risky because of his position in the draft but otherwise there really isn’t a whole lot to townread about him

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I could do ico. Is anyone townreading ico?

[alimdia]

Farkset brings up a valid point that doctor scum could have claimed neighbouriser, that one of his lower scum buddies have picked.

THat seems like a genuine thought, even if Dunnstral slightly disproves it.
But the neighbouriser can still claim to have neighbourised someone dead, or their buddy etc.

The real neighborizer could be a lower scum pick and he won't get counterclaimed

Until said neighborizer starts, you know, neighborizing people, and it's not the guy who claimed the role

Questions to everyone:

- What are the odds that melody/cat are scum together?
- What are the odds of 1 scum in those two?

Take a look at 580 and 809 for primary reference. Melody & Cat, do you have any update to that?

I guess that from your POV it should be melody/cat/farkset because my reads are a close match to those ones, but that's the reason why i have a hard time scumreading them right now - like, either i am immensely wrong and they are both scum (i find it unlikely), or two of us are immensely wrong and the third one is scum (also unlikely).

-Farkran

I don't understand how those 2 posts reference melody and cat being scum together?

[alimdia]

I had a scum ping on Melody ages ago, will have to re-read them later.

[alimdia]

Pretty sure a consensus is gathering on Aldu.

@alim: Why Brass?

~Dawn

not much content, bad catch up post vote on Aldus in #736

[alimdia]

I could do ico. Is anyone townreading ico?

brutal, he's TRing you

[Cat Scratch Fever]

I had a scum ping on Melody ages ago, will have to re-read them later.

Who’s in your lynch pool today alim? Is brass your top scumread?

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Shrug emoji

[Cat Scratch Fever]

@farkset: My reads haven’t really changed much.

DC moved down because i don’t really remember his recent posting. drew moved up. Skitter moved up.

I don’t feel super strongly about any of my reads which is a weird feeling

[skitter30]

I could do ico. Is anyone townreading ico?

raises_hand

[Cat Scratch Fever]

on second thought, DC is probably still town

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Why is ico town? I feel like he was a lot townier when I played with him before

[skitter30]

His switch from pushing me for defending aldu to realizing ... alfu wasnt actually scummy was townie

[Cat Scratch Fever]

also what are your general thoughts on wagoning PoE-y people near the top of the draft like brass and jv

[skitter30]

Spoiler:

this gamestate is gross, like half the game isn't playing and i don't like the leading wagon

maybe we should lynch it anyways and if it flips scum we can lynch you next?

this gamestate is gross, like half the game isn't playing and i don't like the leading wagon

maybe we should lynch it anyways and if it flips scum we can lynch you next?

And if your vote isnt serious what is this

Can you find a serious place to vote please? Its not like there's a dearth of content to interact with ...

my vote on you was made prior to this, and it was not serious

this quote wasn't a joke tho, i found it interesting that you go half-way to defend a slot without really diving into it

Ok and
- i wouldnt really call my townread/defense of aldu 'half-way' or that 'i'm not really diving into it' given that like half my posts in the past couple of days are about this and i've beem very consistent in complaining about the wagon as it's being pushed

Like what's half-way about it exactly?

i only remember reading 1 post about you not liking the main wagon and that was that
even went thru your iso and didn't really notice you fighting against it therefore what i call half way

okayy uhhhh

just finished reading aldus ISO

FOS everyone voting there

i'm aware of what i wrote and the conflict in it

not sure what to make of it

[skitter30]

also what are your general thoughts on wagoning PoE-y people near the top of the draft like brass and jv

Give them a couple of days, if they're still not townie and their night actions dont look townie lynch them

If there's a cop or other investigative lower down those would be good slots to check

[Cat Scratch Fever]

idk I didn't understand how he thought you were half-defending Aldus if he didn't have an opinion on aldus to begin with

[skitter30]

Particularly 746 is townie

Idk it seems like he didn't actually know what my stance on him was when he said that

[Cat Scratch Fever]

It seemed like he did actually read your posts though based on the number of times he mentioned you

[skitter30]

I think at least part of it was a reference to tm

[Iconeum]

quickly went thru the wagon on aldus

drew is in that sweet scum spot where they can just hop on and he does have scum potential in his iso let me go quote it

Ico where are you at with your reads? What did you think of brass's vote on aldus esp in contrast to drew's?

i've provided what i had up until this point? you could ask for more but i already stated why there isn't so why are you asking for more if you haven't even engaged on what I did provide?

[Iconeum]

Iconeum slot is bad, i don't have experience with either of the players that filled it, but gameflaking is meh and when iconeum replaced in it was not improving, until he was prodded for it and (re)started the wagon on drew. Not a good position if drew is town, not a good position if aldus is scum. I am not voting towards ico because i want other flips first.

what's meh about it? I already spent time explaining exactly why it isn't meh and I don't believe you even touched that post so??

[Iconeum]

it's such a super easy discredit there, farkset, but if you just ignore my posts then yeah, this slot is meh.

super bad vibes from you here

[Iconeum]

quite the opposite, scumtisi would read it, while towntisi here saw walls and just skimmed past because i know i can just ask someone to give me a tldr of "should i unvote y/n"

VOTE: melody

uhhh if anyone has a case on why i should vote someone that's under 150 words i might read it

anyway drew's claim strikes me as town unless it's some weird gambit where one of his scumbuddies is the neighborizer (but that's super risky)

pedit: YES ABSOLUTELY CAN WE FINALLY GET THAT MELODY WAGON ROLLING FINALLY

VOTE: melody

not particularly fond of a melody wagon here
IIRC there's only a bunch of talk about setup spec and wifom wrt to the claim? Doesn't warrant this slot to be a D1 lynch imo