Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[Titus]

You want Quick to claim but you're voting boring because? A green card seems like a dumb thing to make up.

Quick and Manatee are far better lynches.

how on earth is voting someone who was lynchproof yesterday a better idea... do you not see the many issues with that?

Because there's not likely a role that's infinitely lynchproof. The moderator would declare that broken.

[hellbooks]

1. i agree with titus

boring does urgently owe us an explanation though

[ManateeDude]

im willing to vote boring but I'd like some sort of explanation from him. chemist is becoming more and more towny today and im liking it

[farside22]

You want Quick to claim but you're voting boring because? A green card seems like a dumb thing to make up.

Quick and Manatee are far better lynches.

Why is that dumb and not scummy based on the role?

Because, boring gains zilch by claiming a green card. Eventually, he will have to answer for it if massclaim happens. It's not like the actual scummy things we've seen in thread.

[boring is claiming they received something which should not be possible to receive.]
[Therefore, they are lying.]

Should not =/= is impossible.

Didn't the mod claim tweaks were possible?

Also, what does boring claim by making up a green card?

That makes no sense.
You want to lynch a player you don't know if really is lynchproof (which there are a few in the game design) and keep a player that got caught in a lie alive?


Who are you and what have you done with titus?

[Titus]

MD, why are you so invested in lynching anyone not named Quick?

[Doctor Drew]

Titus, remember I was lynchproof in Big 4, there is a good possibility that Quick is lynchproof the entire game.

[Hoctac]

I'm allowed to link my role from the Greater Idea page, yeah?

[ManateeDude]

You want Quick to claim but you're voting boring because? A green card seems like a dumb thing to make up.

Quick and Manatee are far better lynches.

how on earth is voting someone who was lynchproof yesterday a better idea... do you not see the many issues with that?

Because there's not likely a role that's infinitely lynchproof. The moderator would declare that broken.

We cant spec how the mod would run the setup it does us absolutely no good.. the best thing to do is lynch [boring?] and let some town PR kill or leash Quick

[Hoctac]

I should've claimed yesterday

[farside22]

You want Quick to claim but you're voting boring because? A green card seems like a dumb thing to make up.

Quick and Manatee are far better lynches.

how on earth is voting someone who was lynchproof yesterday a better idea... do you not see the many issues with that?

Because there's not likely a role that's infinitely lynchproof. The moderator would declare that broken.

Ummmmmmmmm thats not broken if he can be killed.

[Titus]

You want Quick to claim but you're voting boring because? A green card seems like a dumb thing to make up.

Quick and Manatee are far better lynches.

Why is that dumb and not scummy based on the role?

Because, boring gains zilch by claiming a green card. Eventually, he will have to answer for it if massclaim happens. It's not like the actual scummy things we've seen in thread.

[boring is claiming they received something which should not be possible to receive.]
[Therefore, they are lying.]

Should not =/= is impossible.

Didn't the mod claim tweaks were possible?

Also, what does boring claim by making up a green card?

That makes no sense.
You want to lynch a player you don't know if really is lynchproof (which there are a few in the game design) and keep a player that got caught in a lie alive?


Who are you and what have you done with titus?

Quick renounced his lynchproof status. So there's a lie somewhere.

Second, my vote isn't on Quick but on MD because he is waking Quick.

Third, I don't believe boring is lying because he has no reason to. I'd explain what I think happened but boring would copy my answer.

[ManateeDude]

MD, why are you so invested in lynching anyone not named Quick?

1. Wasting a lynch is very possible regardless
2. I think hes towny but like I said someone should just vig him for security reasons

[ManateeDude]

okok hoctac give us the information

[Titus]

You want Quick to claim but you're voting boring because? A green card seems like a dumb thing to make up.

Quick and Manatee are far better lynches.

how on earth is voting someone who was lynchproof yesterday a better idea... do you not see the many issues with that?

Because there's not likely a role that's infinitely lynchproof. The moderator would declare that broken.

Ummmmmmmmm thats not broken if he can be killed.

Based on how few people died last night, I would say absolute lynchproof is broken here. Second, quick didn't claim total lynchproof. So, if he is, a vig has a guaranteed correct kill.

[Hoctac]

Town Guesser

Each night, may submit 2

Guesses

of the exact roles of two separate players.
You will be told if 0, 1, or both of your guesses are correct. You will not be told which guess is correct for the case you get 1 correct.
You may not submit a guess for the same player more than once in the game.
For each correct guess, you receive a

One-Shot Doctor Heal.

Heals can be stacked, and multiple can be used in the same night along with the guesses.
You may self-target with a heal no more than once during the game.

[Hoctac]

(That's my role from the page, not my role PM)

[Hoctac]

So, would two people who are town like to claim to me so that I could confirm them?

[Hoctac]

The silence is deafening. Is everyone scum here???

[Titus]

The silence is deafening. Is everyone scum here???

I don't want to be conftown. I want to live and play myself. I signed onto this game to play D1 and get better at my early game. Becoming conftown defeats that purpose.

[ManateeDude]

I cant claim my role so someone else step right up

[Hoctac]

Okay, so Titus is scum.

[farside22]

Well your asking for a claim. I had a theory so im asking the mod a question. Once i get a response i dont mind testing your claim.

[ManateeDude]

The silence is deafening. Is everyone scum here???

I don't want to be conftown. I want to live and play myself. I signed onto this game to play D1 and get better at my early game. Becoming conftown defeats that purpose.

VOTE: Titus

your primary focus in a game should always be winning

[Hoctac]

The silence is deafening. Is everyone scum here???

I don't want to be conftown. I want to live and play myself. I signed onto this game to play D1 and get better at my early game. Becoming conftown defeats that purpose.

Not wanting to claim is one thing, but making this excuse is another.

[Hoctac]

VOTE: Titus

Alright, farside.