Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[Ircher]

Quick you got some explaining to do along with the people quickhammering

Don't ask me.. I have no idea what is even going on right now. I didn't get lynched which is like... wut? and there was no NK. I have no clue what is going on in this game tbh.

That's strange. Maybe there is a lynch disabler or something...

VOTE: ManateeDude

Simple enough. Too obvious. Nothing genuine here.

Quick you got some explaining to do along with the people quickhammering

Dont think TSE quickhammers and draws FoS as scum here

This thought changed quick.

Decent point but not vote worthy.

More stuff is happening: Pregame, I got a green card, but now I have a yellow card too. As far as I know, I'm still town, and it was right at the beginning of N1, so any recruitment-like night actions couldn't have happened yet.

Did anyone else get another card?

Yup.

Also think Quick is lying and I'm going to say scum based on something that I got this morning.
But I'm pretty sure when you see player lynch proff at flip that isn't 1x, maybe wrong but I'm not going to be testing that theory right now.

TSE: Why did you hammer without a claim?

I Hammered because I was bored and thought I’d goof around.
Not the greatest idea but I was like “oooo I can hammer!”
I don’t think I was 100% at the time lol.

Zzz How do you expect us to win if everyone were to hammer on a whim?

I also got a card. We really should not be color claiming.

I agree. We already discussed cards Day 1 anyway. Why is this being brought up again?

What are the chances that TSE is jester, but only on certain days? I think I remember that kind of stuff in the Grand Idea thread.

I’m legit just a bit more then a VT.

Isn't VT one of the more fun roles though? (Sure, it's Grand Idea Mafia, but VT allows you to do stuff that having a role does not.)

When I say "FENCE"
Y'all say "SITTING"

"FENCE!"

....

SITTING!

VOTE: boring

[According to the Card Game Cheater role which was quoted earlier, green cards do not exist.]

Yeah, I noticed that too. I'm not sure why scum!boring lies about card colors though.

[Ircher]

You want Quick to claim but you're voting boring because? A green card seems like a dumb thing to make up.

Quick and Manatee are far better lynches.

I more or less agree with this. Maybe less so with regards to lynching Quick.

[boring is claiming they received something which should not be possible to receive.]
[Therefore, they are lying.]

[But lying does not imply scum.]

i have an announcement to make

Go right ahead; what's stopping you?

im willing to vote boring but I'd like some sort of explanation from him. chemist is becoming more and more towny today and im liking it

You didn't think he was townie yesterday?

You want Quick to claim but you're voting boring because? A green card seems like a dumb thing to make up.

Quick and Manatee are far better lynches.

how on earth is voting someone who was lynchproof yesterday a better idea... do you not see the many issues with that?

Because there's not likely a role that's infinitely lynchproof. The moderator would declare that broken.

Ummmmmmmmm thats not broken if he can be killed.

Eh, it's potentially broken if it's a role associated with scum. Town isn't guaranteed a full vig, and even with one, a lot could bank on that vig shooting scum!Lynchproof correctly. (Town vigs are notorious for making hero shots rather than sensible choices.)

Town Guesser

Each night, may submit 2

Guesses

of the exact roles of two separate players.
You will be told if 0, 1, or both of your guesses are correct. You will not be told which guess is correct for the case you get 1 correct.
You may not submit a guess for the same player more than once in the game.
For each correct guess, you receive a

One-Shot Doctor Heal.

Heals can be stacked, and multiple can be used in the same night along with the guesses.
You may self-target with a heal no more than once during the game.

Well it can't hurt to tell us what you guessed Night 1.

The silence is deafening. Is everyone scum here???

It's Sunday afternoon. Be patient.

The silence is deafening. Is everyone scum here???

I don't want to be conftown. I want to live and play myself. I signed onto this game to play D1 and get better at my early game. Becoming conftown defeats that purpose.

VOTE: Titus

your primary focus in a game should always be winning

This is a very bad vote.

[Page 313. My role shouldn’t be too difficult to figure out.]

[Noted. I'll take a look.]

[Ircher]

Okay so I wasn't sure how my role worked. I picked from page 230 and I received Town Effort Saver.
When Quick stated he wasn't aware of being lynch proof I thought maybe the role I picked might be the reason and I verified it with the mod.
So in a sense Quick being lynched day 1 would have ended the game right there and he would have won on day 1 if he is indeed 3P.
This leads me to believe Quick is a 3p that should be shot with this knowledge. I'm also scum reading titus whom seems to pushing this idea of Quick as scum and trying to say that lynchproof is impossible.

vote: Titus

Hmm... Very interesting... Quick being third party would not surprise me.

VOTE: Manatee

Quick, please claim.

[TemporalLich]

VC 2.2

Titus (4) - ManateeDude, Hoctac, hellbooks, farside22
boring (2) - Chemist1422, Chateau Lobby
ManateeDude (2) - Titus, Ircher

Not voting: TrueSoulEnergy, boring, Quick, Two Girls One Vote, Pigman, Battle Mage, Saladman27, Doctor Drew, Iconeum, ManateeDude

With 17 alive it takes 9 to eliminate.

Day 2 will end in (expired on 2020-06-03 02:15:00) or when an elimination is reached.

[Quick]

I am down for Quick or Manatee. If Quick is town, I am really down for Manatee.

There's no reason town!Quick should be unlynchable on the top of my head. That's why I am ok voting Quick.

Manatee's defense of Quick seems far too over the top.

If Quick is town, I bet somewhere towards the end of his wagon were slots that knew Quick was lynchproof. Probably if he's scum too.

V]Titus[/V]

[Quick]

You want Quick to claim but you're voting boring because? A green card seems like a dumb thing to make up.

Quick and Manatee are far better lynches.

Why is that dumb and not scummy based on the role?

Because, boring gains zilch by claiming a green card. Eventually, he will have to answer for it if massclaim happens. It's not like the actual scummy things we've seen in thread.

[boring is claiming they received something which should not be possible to receive.]
[Therefore, they are lying.]

Should not =/= is impossible.

Didn't the mod claim tweaks were possible?

Also, what does boring claim by making up a green card?

That makes no sense.
You want to lynch a player you don't know if really is lynchproof (which there are a few in the game design) and keep a player that got caught in a lie alive?


Who are you and what have you done with titus?

Quick renounced his lynchproof status. So there's a lie somewhere.

Second, my vote isn't on Quick but on MD because he is waking Quick.

Third, I don't believe boring is lying because he has no reason to. I'd explain what I think happened but boring would copy my answer.

OMG you are so full of shit!

VOTE: Titus

[Ircher]

Quick, are you 3rd party?

[Chemist1422]

[I would be surprised if Quick isn't a jester at this point, given how overblown his reaction to Titus seems.]

[Quick]

I'm just VT...

[Ircher]

Chemist, why do you think boring's lie was a scum move?

pedit: In Grand Idea Mafia where you get to pick a page? Seems unlikely.

[Quick]

[I would be surprised if Quick isn't a jester at this point, given how overblown his reaction to Titus seems.]

Titus does this to me pretty much every game we play together. And LOL, a lynchproof Jester, yeah, because that makes so much sense...

[Ircher]

Although who makes a game-ending Jester role? Most jesters simply exit the game upon winning.

[Chemist1422]

Although who makes a game-ending Jester role? Most jesters simply exit the game upon winning.

[You.]
viewtopic.php?f=5&t=59348&p=10369740&hi ... #p10369740

[Ircher]

Ah I did lol.

[hellbooks]

im a bit occupied but keeping up on my phone yea
VOTE: titus

{Would you like to be cleared?}

i'll consider it because i like being cleared, but claiming my role makes it useless. also, quick is definitely anti-town

[farside22]

Chemist, why do you think boring's lie was a scum move?

pedit: In Grand Idea Mafia where you get to pick a page? Seems unlikely.

Why would town claim half truth?

[Ircher]

Well town could have misread the color of the card... So sure, they lied but it was unintentional in that case. That's just one possibility.

[hellbooks]

While looking up jester roles in the grand idea roles thread, I came across this.

Superjester

You win if you can get two people to accuse you of being a Jester.

Not to be overly paranoid, but I think TemporalLich might have a higher chance of choosing his own roles to see them in action. maybe we ought to be careful when talking about quick.

[Ircher]

Nah Quick isn't that. They wouldn't win by getting lynched, so Quick would've been lynched yesterday.

[hellbooks]

Effort Saver

Roles that end the game when they win cannot win until Day 2 or later. They are deathproof until Day 2 to compensate.

it seems compatible with farside's thing here.

[ManateeDude]

While looking up jester roles in the grand idea roles thread, I came across this.

Superjester

You win if you can get two people to accuse you of being a Jester.

Not to be overly paranoid, but I think TemporalLich might have a higher chance of choosing his own roles to see them in action. maybe we ought to be careful when talking about quick.

assuming modbias is not something we should do

[Quick]

Is it weird that I kinda just want to sheep Manatee?

[ManateeDude]

Is it weird that I kinda just want to sheep Manatee?

not at all

where you informed what page number your predecessor picked from? if so could we have it?

[Quick]

Is it weird that I kinda just want to sheep Manatee?

not at all

where you informed what page number your predecessor picked from? if so could we have it?

I don't think the mod provided that info to me. I would have to go back and check...

[farside22]

Well town could have misread the color of the card... So sure, they lied but it was unintentional in that case. That's just one possibility.

That's a bit bias why of looking at it.
Oh that player misread there color we should believe that?
You town reading boring for some reason?