Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[Battle Mage]

The posts by Iconeum don't make me glum
Which strongly suggests that he isn't a scum
So TSE, Ico in my town-pile.
Bonne matin Annie, J'adore your smile.
I don't understand Farside's rage
When nothing has happened at this early stage
Alignment indicative it could be
She is astute and excellent normally
Titus is quiet, unusually so,
and also defensive, for what reason though?
Saladman/Bingle must surely be scum
Or his lynch would have already been completed and done
Now please don't accuse me of being rude
But that Chemist fella is a really smart dude
And no offence to 2 girls, but hydras are lame
a negative impact on any mafia game
happy to lynch there based on attitude and play
and we can have a more productive following day.
We could also lynch Drew as he may screw the town
just to turn the game upside down
Could he be a cult leader? yes of course
and if he is town, no need for remorse.

VOTE: 2 girls 1 vote

Gotta go fast!

ROGNTUDJUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU

[Pigman]

I'm here sorry

Need to read

[Titus]

I was VLA and you got prodded BM. I am ready and willing to talk when you are.

Why are you supposing a lynch on a contested slot is unproductive?

[Doctor Drew]

BM, this post of yours just won me back, bravo.

And I only wish I was cult recruiter, definitely would have been more coy about it tbf. And I have noticed any secret winks aimed at me from scum, so I am not game throwing quite yet.

[Doctor Drew]

BM, this post of yours just won me back, bravo.

And I only wish I was cult recruiter, definitely would have been more coy about it tbf. And I have noticed any secret winks aimed at me from scum, so I am not game throwing quite yet.

*I haven't noticed.

Come on scum, try harder.

[boring]

Assuming for a second that our player list contains just one scum team, what's the effective size limit of the team? In this game, could there feasibly be a 6-7 person scum team? I feel like that would explain A LOT.

Townslip!

There'll be 2 or 3 different scumteams most likely. Very unlikely we just have the one since the roles were picked randomly.

If that's the case, can we assume 1-3 scum on each multi-player wagon? There's no way that all three on my wagon are town, and I was leaning town on all three until right now..

There can't not be scum on my wagon. Because if hellbooks, chemist, and 2girls were all town, wouldn't scum have jumped on to the whole "lynch boring because chemist said she's lying" thing? Heck, I could have collected 1-2 votes from each team by now and been lynched. Even if I was scum and they were town, I'd have collected more, right? Even if there was only one big scum team there would be 1-2 scum on me for the spread. I'm an easy target with an easy out when I flip green. And even if I was scum on a huge scum team, someone would be bussing, right? So whether you town read, null read, or scum read me, there HAS to be at LEAST one scum among those three. Most scenarios place two, and some could place all three. Either way, it makes {hellbooks, chemist, and 2girls} a really good pool. For POE, I think I need to remove chemist because he has committed to his conviction that I'm lying and scum. That seems townie. Hellbooks looks like she voted me to avoid committing to serious wagons, and 2girls has been claiming I'm scum for no reason for forever.

At the moment, Hellbooks seems most likely scum on my wagon, with 2girls is second most likely. That sucks because I want hellbooks to be town.

tl;dr: Hellbooks is pretty much guaranteed to be scum right now by my reasoning.
I'd willing to support either a Chateau or 2girls wagon to avoid another no-lynch, but we have over 72 hours left, and I need follow my nose here.

VOTE: hellbooks

[Iconeum]

yeah i've got nothing

if there's a consensus 'ill claim confirmeable or not and my card(s)

There's stuff i don't like about the Girls, and the stuff that I do like only came after being called out so… Still a good lynch imo

if anyone wants to engage over something let me know

[TemporalLich]

Chemist1422 has been prodded.

[Chateau Lobby]

if anyone wants to engage over something let me know

WRT Quick and Boring:

Do you like to lynch 3Ps or lairs?

[Chateau Lobby]

EBWOP

lairs = liars

Lairs are also good lynches btw.

[Iconeum]

if anyone wants to engage over something let me know

WRT Quick and Boring:

Do you like to lynch 3Ps or lairs?

i think most lynches would be great at this point, to move the game a bit

[farside22]

yeah i've got nothing

if there's a consensus 'ill claim confirmeable or not and my card(s)

There's stuff i don't like about the Girls, and the stuff that I do like only came after being called out so… Still a good lynch imo

if anyone wants to engage over something let me know

What's your thoughts on hellbooks?

[Iconeum]

i don't care enough about the hellbook slot to defend it (sorry nothing personal), but i wouldn't push it myself right now

neutral read

[Iconeum]

What's your thoughts on hellbooks?

do you think the gamestate would improve if I was something resembling a conftown?

[farside22]

What's your thoughts on hellbooks?

do you think the gamestate would improve if I was something resembling a conftown?

Not really. I don't see anyone scum reading you.
Unless you mean that you do something that moves this game in a direction towards a lynch of scum that would be awesome!

[Chemist1422]

Yeah at this point I kinda just want day to end so we can have something and move on with it

[farside22]

Yeah at this point I kinda just want day to end so we can have something and move on with it

Switch over to CL.
I don't see why there is still a scum read on 2giv from anyone.
Either that I hellbooks.

[Chemist1422]

VOTE: CL

why not

[Iconeum]

what's the case on CL?

[ManateeDude]

I think my 728 somewhere around there farside also posted somewhere

[Chateau Lobby]

what's the case on CL?

I have non comittal reads. Which is also what you have too. But I don't SR you for it and neither does Manatee.

Which is weird because AGAIN we have Manatee contradicting himself.

And I'm the non commital one.

[Titus]

I am beginning to think maybe I should move over to CL. BM's vote is bothering me. It could be a bus, and slots like Quick moved away from CL.

[Ircher]

VOTE: Hellbooks

Lynching Chateau here is a waste of time.

[Chateau Lobby]

I am beginning to think maybe I should move over to CL. BM's vote is bothering me. It could be a bus, and slots like Quick moved away from CL.

Be careful, or you might get a SR from Manatee with this type of non-committal votes.

But the fact that our brains were in sync for a little bit meant the world to me.

Please reconsider.

[Chateau Lobby]

VOTE: Hellbooks

Lynching Chateau here is a waste of time.

See.