Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[somestrangeflea]

Im toadsworth im peaches personal assistant, ive stood by her all of her life,
so no disguise can fool me. i cant comunicate with peach and she doesnt know who i am. i will be notified if shes kidnapped and who did it.
last night i was notified that she wasnt kidnapped see my other post.

Actually why would you be notified if you said that you can only be notified if she IS kidnapped?

The Princess being kidnapped (or not) is the subject of each notification, rather than the trigger which causes it.

I read it the wrong way at first glance too, but K7's claim makes sense.

Mod edit
Visible Votecount:
FaerieLord (1): Korts
ashmite84 (1): TheSweatpantsNinja

Not voting (19): iamausername, skitzer, Wintermute, forbiddanlight, somestrangeflea, Surye, killa seven, Gremwell, Alabaska J, farside22, ting =), DarlaBlueEyes, FaerieLord, Lord Gurgi, Cream147, Riceballtail, goborage, populartajo, ashmite84

[Gremwell]

Ok with that hopefully averted who looks good for our lynch today?

I'll be on limited access at best, possible V/LA from Monday to Friday just so everyone is aware.

[Alabaska J]

gurgi what reasons do you have for wanting me dead? Baseless tunneling is not exactly in the town's best interest right now IMO.

[Alabaska J]

gurgi what reasons do you have for wanting me dead? Baseless tunneling is not exactly in the town's best interest right now IMO.

[Alabaska J]

gurgi what reasons do you have for wanting me dead? Baseless tunneling is not exactly in the town's best interest right now IMO.

[somestrangeflea]

C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER

[Lord Gurgi]

C-C-C-COMBO BREAKER

No kidding.

gurgi what reasons do you have for wanting me dead? Baseless tunneling is not exactly in the town's best interest right now IMO.

gurgi what reasons do you have for wanting me dead? Baseless tunneling is not exactly in the town's best interest right now IMO.

gurgi what reasons do you have for wanting me dead? Baseless tunneling is not exactly in the town's best interest right now IMO.

I am not going to dredge up a case from the last 70 some-odd pages. I think you're scum. Anybody who argues can dredge up their own case against the person they suspect. I had to search back to find the case against Mr.Incrediball since

nobody would tell me what it was

.

[Korts]

Gurgi, you don't have to "dredge up" a full case, just give your reasons for thinking Alabaska's scum. Conviction on its own isn't going to get him lynched in my irrelevant opinion.

[Lord Gurgi]

Whatever.

Happy birthday FL.

Unvote

Not trusting K7 right now. Are you given a PM every night that Peach is

not

kidnapped telling you such?

Will claim if Pop wishes.

hey.

Claim now I'm pretty sure pop is cool with it.

Speaking for other players, especially when it isn't true.

The case iamausername has just posted on mr. incrediball deserves some looking into.

Also, although he is throughly Rosso-esque, killa seven should not be let off the hook completely, in my opinion.

Says the guy that has votes on him. Why don't you make your own case instead of following along.

What the hell…I said I was looking into it. I just got home and read his post… I can't magically analyze all of their posts and make cases right away. What I can do is say that the evidence he has presented piques my interest and is an impetus for further scumhunting. Also, I don't see what having votes on me has to do with anything, especially seeing that there is no sound basis for those votes IMO.

This.

Reasons people should vote for Alabaska: he's being awfully defensive

oh no I'm defending myself when attacked; as the dutiful town-aligned player I am I should role over and get lynched for extremely poor reasons you are right

and trying to get people to lynch me

this is an argument? if that counts, chock another argument up for RBT's lynch: he's trying to get people to lynch me

; yet there has yet to be a counterclaim

you may be that role, except that you are scum and steal the vote no matter what and that is why there is no counterclaim

, or proof that my claim is false

again, you are much more likely to be lying about your role than fakeclaiming; I have never said your claim was false outright today

. Basically, since I found him suspicious, now he has to OMGUS me to death

you are stealing this from other people who failed to read the game lol. Love how you just switched onto this after others used it for a reason, even though it doesn't apply at all, because I went after you first genius

. So, let us carry on and lynch this scum.

wrong lol.

Me in bold. FYI lurkers and noobs who are skimming the thread: there isn't a case on me at all. Don't randomly jump on me; you'll end up looking anti-town and foolish. Instead, read the thread. I have disproved every argument against me already and now RBT is grasping at straws trying to keep it afloat.

TSPN, please reread all of my post refuting the argument against me and then tell me why I am scummy. And if you say I'm being defensive, I will steal mod privileges, replace Elias into this game, give him a dayvig, and have kill you

so damn hard

.



Let me say this again:

BEING DEFENSIVE IS IN NO WAY, SHAPE, OR FORM A SCUMTELL.

This even more.

Voting patterms: RS, Cream, RS, Cream, RBT, Cream, RBT.

[populartajo]

Ok Ive been thinking abut this and we need to coinclaim and to pool our coins to investigate people tonight. I already said its pretty easy for scum to find Peach tonight.
I dont know yet if I believe Alabaska's claim. It is easily testable if we give coins to a confirmed player to buy a fireflower and then make Ala to protect that player. Now I dont find it necessary since Im thinking that claiming Dr Mario is a very risky claim if scum but hey anything can happen.
But if you want to test it then thats why we need to put all our coins in one place and then we can decide what to do with them.
I have 5 coins.
I think that I might have an idea about what FL isnt telling us about her role. But Ill stop speculating and Im going to 100% believe her.
Coinpooling go!

[goborage]

Give one coin to popular.

Coin-pool ahoy!

[Riceballtail]

Tonight's play by Alabaska should be to protect K7.

[goborage]

Just re-read. I'm confused. Why do we believe K7? Has anyone considered the possibility that he's lying? It's either him or the mod and my experience is that the mod does not lie. If K7 is scum, it is a perfect play. It gets town to stop hunting for the kidnapper and wraps up the game after the mislynch.

[killa seven]

^ i never said stop hunting scum.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

I am a Toad (Mushroom Kingdom). I am loyal to Princess Peach, and try to keep her from getting kidnapped.

Now, this presents a bit of a moral dilemma here. . . but tell me other people see why we should be lynching ashmite.

Assuming he doesn't get modkilled.

[FaerieLord]

I think he'll be modkilled honestly, so let's not discuss him for now.

Cannot coinpool here since well...I don't have coins.

[Riceballtail]

Can someone explain why he'd be modkilled? I don't get it.

[DarlaBlueEyes]

I'm confused

Ashmite's role pm he claimed the

I am a Toad (Mushroom Kingdom). I am loyal to Princess Peach, and try to keep her from getting kidnapped.

isnt a full quote of the PM and is a bit off from the full one, so if he is a toad and he changed it why would he be MK'd? And if he isnt a toad and is BSing the PM (its close but not exact) then why would THAT be a MK?

I think I missed something :S

[forbiddanlight]

isnt a full quote of the PM and is a bit off from the full one, so if he is a toad and he changed it why would he be MK'd? And if he isnt a toad and is BSing the PM (its close but not exact) then why would THAT be a MK?

I think I missed something :S

Agreed. I'm not sure I see what the deal with the MK is. Also,

give one coin to popular

. All I got .

[Gremwell]

Give two (2) coins to pop

[DarlaBlueEyes]

give one (1) coin to Pop

my one and only

[killa seven]

can i get a coin or 2

[forbiddanlight]

Alright, I'm thinking about it...and I'm beginning to wonder if the best play might be to lynch K7. Wait, hear me out. If he's honestly what he says he is, then the lynch won't lose us the game. However, the claim he made is perfect for bowser, so by lynching him it might save the game after all. Course, there's probably some gaping hole in this idea...I just thought I'd put it out there.

[Korts]

Hm, I see what you're saying. But by lynching him, we lose a great asset for the town if he isn't lying. The risk/reward ratio isn't so good here.

[Alabaska J]

ITT we learn that Gurgi still thinks defensiveness is a scumtell.

Also, your thing about talking for other players? Yeah, that's a load of BS. If we wait for pop to come in and okay everyone, we are gonna be here until 2009. ashmite84 was at the top of plenty of scumdars and pop said he didn't know who should claim other than me.

Also, no comment on my claim? I guess you don't believe it, or else just skipped that page. Reasons?

Also, I am more than willing to protect K7. If anyone can grant something to protect me from being targeted by scum power (roleblock or bus driver, who knows what could be out there), that would reassure me, as I'm sure the scum are gonna want K7 dead pretty badly.

How many coins (if any) should I pool?

@forbiddanlight: if we lynch K7 then we lose valuable info about Peach being kidnapped. If/when she is kidnapped for real (assuming FL and K7 are telling the truth), K7 will be able to give us the kidnapper's name.