Newbie 2011 - Game Over

[Battle Mage]

can one of the above please do that quickly then? jesus...

It'll probably take more than one.... Or I REALLY good one.

then you're probably dead today

[midwaybear]

not today, tonight
i think

[Battle Mage]

not today, tonight
i think

???

[Freddiethelady]

So if you're town, what you've actually done is put loads of heat on yourself, and to a lesser extent me, and allowed scum to completely free-ride. I

worry a bit about AGar

for instance because although he is seeming fine and playing well, there's no opportunity to put him under any real pressure and test him because the whole thread is dedicated to you defending your play and attacking me.

I echo these sentiments. Last night I was trying to articulate this, but I didn’t want to be rude, and I couldn’t find the words. I appreciate sleeper being so dedicated, especially as a newbie, but there isn’t any room for anyone to jump in. I think that’s dangerous because the lurkers (aside from gobbles, who is the king of lurking in this game) blend in with the people who are a little fatigued by the back and forth...there’s a lot of arguing being done that isn’t super constructive. So how do we re-engage everyone?

Starting with my favorite Land-narwhal: Hi, you! Come play, please!
Gobbles, who are you? I would like to hear from you!
Apogee, what do you think of the BM/sleeper interaction? In post 292 you had BM as town and Sleeper towards scum. Do you still hold that opinion about the two of them after the exchange?
General, where did you go?

I agree with BM here sleeper. It’s true we need a lynch and though I’m not voting for you, it does look pretty bleak for you. If you hard claim then we can refocus and try to have a productive first day. Also, I might have gotten this wrong but if you’re a power role, you don’t say that part...just say town or something like that. Don’t forget, scum know who town are, but not power roles, so claiming isn’t better for scum, but it helps town keep more townies alive.

[Battle Mage]

Freddie, I love ya, but Sleeper claiming "town" but not his actual role isn't gonna help

If he's a power role he should claim so we dont lynch him haha

[SleeperSoul]

I appreciate sleeper being so dedicated, especially as a newbie, but there isn’t any room for anyone to jump in.

You are so careful with your words! Thank you for being kind.

Sorry for spamming. I'll take a break.

I see that BM is probably not going to be lynched today, so I'm joining the midway wagon. I'll come back later to claim if I need to.

VOTE: midway

[Battle Mage]

taking a break is the last thing we need you to do...

maybe claim and then take a break? or if you wont listen to me and freddie, just...don't take a break and wait for other people to convince you.

[midwaybear]

SleeperSoul is either openwolving or being super noob-town...

[Apogee]

Agar where do you think we should be looking?

[Apogee]

I'm really getting scum flailing over town flailing vibes from Sleeper but I can't be certain on that.

[Apogee]

BM is town today. Based on his own description of his scum game this is a slot to be paranoid of later on, but today he has put a ton of effort and thought into the thread and has put quite a few good cases into play

[Battle Mage]

BM is town today. Based on his own description of his scum game this is a slot to be paranoid of later on, but today he has put a ton of effort and thought into the thread and has put quite a few good cases into play

ah thanks man

[AGar]

Agar where do you think we should be looking?

I would prefer to lynch within {Midway,GWu}

I absolutely do not want to lynch {Battle Mage, votato}

Sleeper falls in the "do not want to lynch" category but is also the leading wagon with ~24 hours until deadline so if it comes down to no-lynch or sleeper, I'll begrudgingly vote Sleeper, but I'm p sure that's just a new town player.

Other than that, I'm ambivalent on a lot of players.

Also, lol@Midway firmly believing BM's hyperbolic claims regarding gameplay.

[Freddiethelady]

Freddie, I love ya, but Sleeper claiming "town" but not his actual role isn't gonna help

If he's a power role he should claim so we dont lynch him haha

Oh jeeze. I hopeless

I thought just saying town was good since you don’t want to tell scum you have a power role. I’m going to find the answers but thats the impression I was under. Sorry!

[midwaybear]

Also, lol@Midway firmly believing BM's hyperbolic claims regarding gameplay.

wut?

Also, I hardclaim "town".

[Battle Mage]

I'm not interested in a Midway or GWu lynch today, sorry.

[Battle Mage]

Also, lol@Midway firmly believing BM's hyperbolic claims regarding gameplay.

wut?

Also, I hardclaim "town".

great, I'm considering you and Freddie confirmed-town now then.

[Battle Mage]

I really want to hear from Votato on how sure he is that Sleeper is town.

[SleeperSoul]

taking a break is the last thing we need you to do...

Also, lol@Midway firmly believing BM's hyperbolic claims regarding gameplay.

wut?

Also, I hardclaim "town".

great, I'm considering you and Freddie confirmed-town now then.

Can we be a little more serious and concise? Town is asking for us to spam the thread less, not more.

p:edit more spam from BM.... please make an effort to reduce your amount of posts.

[Battle Mage]

Freddie, I love ya, but Sleeper claiming "town" but not his actual role isn't gonna help

If he's a power role he should claim so we dont lynch him haha

Oh jeeze. I hopeless

I thought just saying town was good since you don’t want to tell scum you have a power role. I’m going to find the answers but thats the impression I was under. Sorry!

No problem pal, it made me laugh!

[Battle Mage]

taking a break is the last thing we need you to do...

Also, lol@Midway firmly believing BM's hyperbolic claims regarding gameplay.

wut?

Also, I hardclaim "town".

great, I'm considering you and Freddie confirmed-town now then.

Can we be a little more serious and concise? Town is asking for us to spam the thread less, not more.

p:edit more spam from BM.... please make an effort to reduce your amount of posts.

Erm, no? It's not a competition...

but if it was, I would win!

[AGar]

I'm not interested in a Midway or GWu lynch today, sorry.

¿Por que no?

[votato]

sleeper could claim scum and i still wouldnt lynch there today. my preferred lynch is BM. i could go for GWu. maybe gobbles. probably not midway. i would definitely go for an apogee wagon. this doesnt feel the same as town!apogee ive seen in the past.
VOTE: apogee in fact

[Battle Mage]

Votato, can you tell me why you're so sure sleeper is town here?

[midwaybear]

I am pretty confident that this is a town apogee. He's playing mostly similar to last game...
What's the big difference?
I do think we need to consolidate and group together.
I prefer lynching in between sleep and gobbles.