We lynched a townie, and a townie was NKd. We STILL have to worry about the jester, and we haven't found scum at all. This is a bad start.
Why so forlorn?
That's Mafia sometimes. Sun Tzu was essentially a deadline lynch, not really an informed lynch. And I think Apothecary was an honest attempt by the Mafia to hit the jester.forbiddanlight wrote:We lynched a townie, and a townie was NKd. We STILL have to worry about the jester, and we haven't found scum at all. This is a bad start.
Why so forlorn?
I've hosted face to face games and found everyone usually complains about a town kill at around the same time. But, either way, I guess I was honestly hoping to hit scum or see the jester dead.
I've found in my face-to-face games that the first player to complain about losing a townie is often a member of the Mafia. Most people don't comment in the manner that you just did in online games (since it attracts unnecessary attention and doesn't really add anything to the game), so I'm not sure if it holds up. It's still notable, though.
Yeah, I suppose I know this, I've played enough games...but I guess because I'm used to screw ups due to 72 hour deadlines (at the other places I play), I hoped a 3 week game would lead to more...discernable lynches.
That's Mafia sometimes. Sun Tzu was essentially a deadline lynch, not really an informed lynch. And I think Apothecary was an honest attempt by the Mafia to hit the jester.
Argh, this is so annoying how scummy you are. I want to vote you but the WIFOM is suspenseful (anyone who gets that reference gets a cookie)Because we've got 2 townies out the way.
TJ is Jester.
True. I've often seen people overreact though as Mafia (or werewolves, which is what we usually play).forbiddanlight wrote: I've hosted face to face games and found everyone usually complains about a town kill at around the same time. But, either way, I guess I was honestly hoping to hit scum or see the jester dead.
Yeah, our lynches are usually slightly more informed here, but I think (from what I've seen anyway) the quality of play on this site is generally higher than other sites. Unfortunately, that goes for the Mafia as well. Bad players (like Sun Tzu was) often get lynched on Day 1.forbiddanlight wrote: Yeah, I suppose I know this, I've played enough games...but I guess because I'm used to screw ups due to 72 hour deadlines (at the other places I play), I hoped a 3 week game would lead to more...discernable lynches.
Right, I hosted werewolf. I just use mafia as an umbrella term.
True. I've often seen people overreact though as Mafia (or werewolves, which is what we usually play).
That's true. My first game, still ongoing, was a horrible example of trying to transition to a different tier of play. I'd like to think I've at least improved a little.
Yeah, our lynches are usually slightly more informed here, but I think (from what I've seen anyway) the quality of play on this site is generally higher than other sites. Unfortunately, that goes for the Mafia as well. Bad players (like Sun Tzu was) often get lynched on Day 1.
?
.