Grand Idea GPick [Game Over]

[Chateau Lobby]

why do you wish you protected Bingle, the flipped NON-town?

I don't mean for it top be interpreted as I am sad that Bingle died. I am more curious as to how the kill on Bingle was successful and negating the protect.

[TrueSoulEnergy]

Fucking bingle and titus were fucking aliens ! Gggraaahhh! Vindication!!!!

I could tell they were groupscum.
Didn’t think Aliens though.

[TrueSoulEnergy]

[Oh sorry I didn't buy into the whole Titus is an alien thing by the way. To be honest, i thought it was a red herring and we were mostly dealing with the red scum or at least some kind of scum trying to take away our leashed double kill power]

[If I had to guess right now, I'd say Looker is probably the card dealer. Just a preemptive guess though because I haven't started investigating people yet]

[Oh!]

[Pork, why'd you get an innocent result on Bingle? Does your Cop ability only detect mafia?]

I would say the 3 players that look the worse for the card dealer is TSE, CL or Looker.

Well at least I now understand bingle desire not to push titus. I'm glad not to go up that mountain anymore.

I wonder if all those people died because of the bomber.
I think I will go this way today for the claim. I'm looking at TSE or Looker for scum. I just found out pigman was an alt of ELT

VOTE: Looker

I’m also curious on CL and Looker was well.
I’m not the card dealer and in the chance I was I would have to be confident that BM would be Town.
I can’t 100% know that’s the case if I was Card Dealer.

[Porkens]

So titus loverized starbuck and battlemage? You h oh maybe they redscum made contact with the aliens somehow

How do you know this? You seem to always be pretty confident in assumptions. Wasn't it just yesterday you proclaimed me to be scum with titus???

“Know” is a misrepresentation, I was theorizing so because there were four dead and lovers would account for some of that (although not all, that’s still one kill too many). I was expecting you to claim vig in fact.

What are you accusing me of, how would I know anything about who got loverized? Titus wouldn’t loverize herself or Titus. Do you think there were four individual kills last night?

[Porkens]

Quick (9) -

Titus

, farside22,

hellbooks

,

Battle Mage

,

Ircher

,

Doctor Drew

, boring (porkens), Chateau Lobby, TrueSoulEnergy [LYNCH!]

Two Girls One Vote (9) - Iconeum, Chateau Lobby,

Titus

, Pigman (looker),

Battle Mage

,

ManateeDude

,

Doctor Drew

, Chemist1422(MT),

Ircher

[LYNCH!]

Ircher (7) -

Titus

, boring (pork), farside22,

Doctor Drew

,

ManateeDude

, Chateau Lobby,

Ircher

[LYNCH!]

hellbooks (7) - farside22,

Starbuck, Titus,

TrueSoulEnergy, Morning Tweet, Porkens,

ManateeDude

[LYNCH!]

ManateeDude (7) -

Battle Mage

, Porkens, Chateau Lobby, farside22, Morning Tweet,

Starbuck, Titus

[LYNCH!]

So what your showing us here is you were on every lynch with hellbooks except hers.

[Porkens]

why do you wish you protected Bingle, the flipped NON-town?

I don't mean for it top be interpreted as I am sad that Bingle died. I am more curious as to how the kill on Bingle was successful and negating the protect.

What? You are contradicting yourself here. You lament that you didn’t save him but wonder why your save didn’t work?

Fucking bingle and titus were fucking aliens ! Gggraaahhh! Vindication!!!!

I could tell they were groupscum.
Didn’t think Aliens though.

It seems fairly onvoois they were paired in retrospect.

Gatta go to work, I’ll do my homework when I can.

[Chateau Lobby]

What? You are contradicting yourself here. You lament that you didn’t save him but wonder why your save didn’t work?

There is a reason my protect didn't work, I was wondering why that was. Regardless of Bingle's alignment.

FTR, I understand it is good that it didn't work but still the question of why remains.

[Chateau Lobby]

Quick (9) -

Titus

, farside22,

hellbooks

,

Battle Mage

,

Ircher

,

Doctor Drew

, boring (porkens), Chateau Lobby, TrueSoulEnergy [LYNCH!]

Two Girls One Vote (9) - Iconeum, Chateau Lobby,

Titus

, Pigman (looker),

Battle Mage

,

ManateeDude

,

Doctor Drew

, Chemist1422(MT),

Ircher

[LYNCH!]

Ircher (7) -

Titus

, boring (pork), farside22,

Doctor Drew

,

ManateeDude

, Chateau Lobby,

Ircher

[LYNCH!]

hellbooks (7) - farside22,

Starbuck, Titus,

TrueSoulEnergy, Morning Tweet, Porkens,

ManateeDude

[LYNCH!]

ManateeDude (7) -

Battle Mage

, Porkens, Chateau Lobby, farside22, Morning Tweet,

Starbuck, Titus

[LYNCH!]

So what your showing us here is you were on every lynch with hellbooks except hers.

Or that TSE on both of the scum lynches. TSE and MT are pining me the most when I compare all lynch VCAs. Porkens is still sus to me.

TSE, MT, and Pork in that order for my preferred lynch order.

[Chateau Lobby]

VOTE: TrueSoulEnergy

[Porkens]

What? You are contradicting yourself here. You lament that you didn’t save him but wonder why your save didn’t work?

There is a reason my protect didn't work, I was wondering why that was. Regardless of Bingle's alignment.

FTR, I understand it is good that it didn't work but still the question of why remains.

Did you target bingle last night?

[Morning Tweet]

Quick (9) -

Titus

, farside22,

hellbooks

,

Battle Mage

,

Ircher

,

Doctor Drew

, boring (porkens), Chateau Lobby, TrueSoulEnergy [LYNCH!]

Two Girls One Vote (9) - Iconeum, Chateau Lobby,

Titus

, Pigman (looker),

Battle Mage

,

ManateeDude

,

Doctor Drew

, Chemist1422(MT),

Ircher

[LYNCH!]

Ircher (7) -

Titus

, boring (pork), farside22,

Doctor Drew

,

ManateeDude

, Chateau Lobby,

Ircher

[LYNCH!]

hellbooks (7) - farside22,

Starbuck, Titus,

TrueSoulEnergy, Morning Tweet, Porkens,

ManateeDude

[LYNCH!]

ManateeDude (7) -

Battle Mage

, Porkens, Chateau Lobby, farside22, Morning Tweet,

Starbuck, Titus

[LYNCH!]

So what your showing us here is you were on every lynch with hellbooks except hers.

Or that TSE on both of the scum lynches. TSE and MT are pining me the most when I compare all lynch VCAs. Porkens is still sus to me.

TSE, MT, and Pork in that order for my preferred lynch order.

[Wtf and Looker doesn't even register as sus to you?]

[Morning Tweet]

I am Town Shielder
Targets:
N1: Drew
N2: Titus
N3: Titus
N4: BM
N5: Bingle

No factional kills - N1: Drew (no deaths)
Mafia or Werewolf kill - N2: Titus (Hoctac dies to scum)
No factional kills - N3: Titus (Drew dies to Pork)
No factional kills - N4: BM (no deaths)
Alien x1, Mafia x1, Werewolf x1 - N5: Bingle (Starbuck and BM die to aliens, Titus dies to werewolves or mafia, Bingle dies to werewolves or mafia)

[Still don't see why the werewolves and mafia haven't been killing. Your protection on BM might have saved him, and mayybe scum tried killing Titus, I guess. But there are supposed to be two factional kills every night here!]

[in any case we're out of role claims that could be causing scum to not kill. Perhaps your protections combined with some kind of gambit by the werewolves could explain it.]

[Porkens]

Ohhh I get it “I should have protected bingle” wasn’t a regret, you are saying the protection didn’t work. What color card did you have CL?

[Morning Tweet]

[OH maybe scum yellow carded themselves on some of the nights]

[Porkens]

[

Iconeum

- Friendly Neighbour - Verified Town]
[

Morning Tweet

- Claims One-shotizer] I know this power exists

Farside22

- Claims Effort Saver turned VT] day proves this I believe
—-
[

TrueSoulEnergy

- Claims Knowledgable BM is town]
[

Looker (Pigman)

- Claims Named VT]
[

Chateau Lobby

- Shielder

só any of the bottom three could be card dealer. BM was widely townread so I can’t rule out that TSE was taking a calculated gamble.
Looker seemed so burned out and sour about town yesterday I don’t see him as either redscum or wolf, though this could be faked as well as the named townie claim.
Chateau’s shielder clam is plausible but as card dealer he would be very well aware of the yellow card effects and that would have a lot of the same effect.

[Looker]

Oh shit there’s a wolf faction what up my brothers

Did I miss something? Did you claim werewolf already?

So titus loverized starbuck and battlemage? You h oh maybe they redscum made contact with the aliens somehow

How do you know this? You seem to always be pretty confident in assumptions. Wasn't it just yesterday you proclaimed me to be scum with titus???

Knowledge of night actions makes me suspicious as well. I'm confused why, if Porkens' Green Glass Door claim is to be believed, the possibility of him being a Mafia Green Glass Door isn't. They're all on the same page.

TSE, MT, and Pork in that order for my preferred lynch order.

53% Porkens | 18%

Ico

, Farside, or Morning Tweet | 15% Chateau Lobby | 14% TSE

---

• Why did farside22 say that Chateau Lobby had claimed when he hadn't?

VOTE: Porkens Titus had a point - lynching Porkens and me would have been optimal play for scum if we were both town.

[farside22]

[Oh sorry I didn't buy into the whole Titus is an alien thing by the way. To be honest, i thought it was a red herring and we were mostly dealing with the red scum or at least some kind of scum trying to take away our leashed double kill power]

[If I had to guess right now, I'd say Looker is probably the card dealer. Just a preemptive guess though because I haven't started investigating people yet]

[Oh!]

[Pork, why'd you get an innocent result on Bingle? Does your Cop ability only detect mafia?]

I would say the 3 players that look the worse for the card dealer is TSE, CL or Looker.

Well at least I now understand bingle desire not to push titus. I'm glad not to go up that mountain anymore.

I wonder if all those people died because of the bomber.
I think I will go this way today for the claim. I'm looking at TSE or Looker for scum. I just found out pigman was an alt of ELT

VOTE: Looker

I’m also curious on CL and Looker was well.
I’m not the card dealer and in the chance I was I would have to be confident that BM would be Town.
I can’t 100% know that’s the case if I was Card Dealer.

Informed could be scum and scum had informed player on there side.

Oh shit there’s a wolf faction what up my brothers

Did I miss something? Did you claim werewolf already?

So titus loverized starbuck and battlemage? You h oh maybe they redscum made contact with the aliens somehow

How do you know this? You seem to always be pretty confident in assumptions. Wasn't it just yesterday you proclaimed me to be scum with titus???

Knowledge of night actions makes me suspicious as well. I'm confused why, if Porkens' Green Glass Door claim is to be believed, the possibility of him being a Mafia Green Glass Door isn't. They're all on the same page.

TSE, MT, and Pork in that order for my preferred lynch order.

53% Porkens | 18%

Ico

, Farside, or Morning Tweet | 15% Chateau Lobby | 14% TSE

---

• Why did farside22 say that Chateau Lobby had claimed when he hadn't?

VOTE: Porkens Titus had a point - lynching Porkens and me would have been optimal play for scum if we were both town.

I thought it was a sift claim and mt pointed it out and thought as much as well.

[Porkens]

Why would boring soft a scum role?

They were scum, and they were both voting for us, so yeah your theory checks out- we are both town.

[Porkens]

VOTE: chetau

I’ll roleblock tse tonight

[TrueSoulEnergy]

HOLD UP.
HOLD UP.

What is Farside?
What’s their claim and are they confirmed in any way?
They decided to mention Card Dealer first and didn’t even mention the possibilities of other scum being alive.
That’s why I’m thinking Farside might be CD here. But I need to know what their role is because I forgot.
And if they haven’t claimed anything and aren’t confirmed in any way then why aren’t we voting them for at least Pressure.

[Porkens]

Okay so I wasn't sure how my role worked. I picked from page 230 and I received Town Effort Saver.
When Quick stated he wasn't aware of being lynch proof I thought maybe the role I picked might be the reason and I verified it with the mod.
So in a sense Quick being lynched day 1 would have ended the game right there and he would have won on day 1 if he is indeed 3P.
This leads me to believe Quick is a 3p that should be shot with this knowledge. I'm also scum reading titus whom seems to pushing this idea of Quick as scum and trying to say that lynchproof is impossible.

vote: Titus

[TrueSoulEnergy]

Right right.
Thanks for the refresh Porkens.

[TrueSoulEnergy]

Ok so yeah unless Farside is a Neutral role that can choose their own abilities then yeah they are Town.

[farside22]

And the wolf vanillizer targetted me, which I stated 2 game days ago and unless you think I'm wolf, but BM stated the same think Day 5 as being turned into a VT.

[farside22]

VOTE: chetau

I’ll roleblock tse tonight

I'm good with this. I think the card dealer happens at the end of the day, because that is when I receive a card.

I'm going to be damn curious why some many players died night 5. Can't wait to see the mod notes on this game when it's over.