Redneck Mafia GAME OVER PARTNER!

[Logicalicaltist]

Care to find a way through the gif-love-stream to demonstrate where I went wrong?

You know this is not what I meant

What did you mean?

[Logicalicaltist]

gobble's ISO is a bunch of nothing

I second this.

[Logicalicaltist]

When has town not gotten rolled by third party BS players? How often do third party claims turn out scum?

C'mon people

If they are scum they will become more obvious later on.

[Logicalicaltist]

Imagine iso'ing that garbage. It's such anti-town behavior. I hate it passionately.

Let me guess.
Is your top scum reads the GiF and the 3P?
lol.
Please tell me that isn’t the case bud.

[Logicalicaltist]

@A50, here's your iso and my sense of each post:

Fun fact: I am disappointed I didn't roll scum in this game in particular. Drew said he wanted to be scum with me in the sign-up thread and I though "I wish that happens and our third would be Jay!". Looks like I didn't cross my fingers or press my thumb hard enough (or whatever you guys do to get your wishes to come true".

Fluffy first post referring to friends. Includes a reference to Pooky in the deleted part. No scumhunting.

Wasn't that the case in the baker's wrestling game we just finished?

Shooting the shit. Not scumhunting.

It's only @3 votes I believe???

Game state "helpfulness." Not scumhunting.

You obviously haven't played with Firebringer or Not_Mafia before.

Shooting the shit. Not scumhutning.

Do as you wish. You'd probably get a kick out of my flip anyway (but not what you're implying for certain).

This kind of comment is PR-hunting.

@Drew: Wouldn't you like yo wait to see a confirmation that the scum team is indeed of 3 persons? I mean, how would you feel if did lynch me, and I flipped Town, and some Vig shot a Redneck, and they flipped with a Role PM that said "You are Scum with [redacted], [redacted] & [redacted]" or "Hello [redacted], [redacted], [redacted] & [redacted]. You are the Rednecks team.." or anything similar?

ATE. Comes from a mindset that did not at all mirror mine at this point in my readthrough. Could reflect your history with players in the game (i.e., my thought expressed before that your relationship with Pooky or Drew could be a variable I'm not accounting for -- but Pooky said no at least for his vote).

You nailed it. Some of us (myself included) would try to claim or hint a role on RVS for the lolz. It also serves to hide any potential serious crumbs made by other TPRs. (I wish I could explain more, but I can't without revealing a couple of things I don't wish to reveal at this time, so maybe sometime later)

I guess this contextualizes your behavior that bothered me above. But it is flawed in that it errs if other players are not rational actors and it is noisy.

Town/Scum/SK/Survivor/Moderator/Spectator crumb detected. Now tell me HOW am I going to be wrong this time.

Noisy. Not scumhunting.

Noisy. Not scumhunting.

How the hell did you end up receiving one to begin with? UNBELIEVABLE!

Noisy. Not scumhunting.

Man. he's not saying he can confirm "1-shots". He is saying he gains a 1-shot of whatever ability he's targeted with, so can confirm the ability exists. (Ex: A Cop is on Alch. The Cop fails to get a result, but Alch gains a 1-shot Cop ability and that proves a Cop is in the game)

Being "helpful" while avoiding the more important point, which is whether Alchemist is scum and what to do if he is 3p.

It really isn't though. For instance; Janie's not a member of NRA, yet..

Noisy, not scumhunting.

This is a new one. He fake claims backup mod. Not even EJ could've thought of that.

Noisy, not scumhunting

A50: Mine comes from post-school era
JJD: Thanks for sharing
A50: Don't mention it. I'm always glad to give back to the community

Noisy, not scumhunting. You matched EJ/my behavior, apparently inferring that it was merely playful. But, it was actually tied into what EJ had indicated was the best mechanism for reading him (i.e., to do it in a schizoid way). But you did not observe our interaction as a way to collect information about alignments, despite this, fitting the pattern of engaging with the game in superficial ways that do not indicate a desire to find scum.

So, overall, you have posts that distract from the important town tasks, which is parsimoniously explained by a scum identity. There may be a way to explain it away that I do not know (e.g., some stuff I allude to above at times, maybe other things that I will not know unless you tell me).

Mmmmm

I really like this post.

It’s great that you like it and all.
But what do you like about it?

[Alchemist21]

I have a simple explanation for the unsolicited claim: he really, REALLY wants to be targeted at night because it benefits him.

At least you’re right about this.

[Logicalicaltist]

VOTE: DGB

[Doctor Drew]

I have a simple explanation for the unsolicited claim: he really, REALLY wants to be targeted at night because it benefits him.

At least you’re right about this.

Alch, you were scum in Big 4 mafia, right?

[Logicalicaltist]

will there be a tomorrow for you?

VOTE: Pooky

This was DGB’s first post.
I feel as if he has ignored the progression on Pooky’s Slot.
Yes Pooky has been only speaking in GiF’s But the game state leans them to be more likely Town Aligned then scum Aligned.
I think DGB here disagrees with me.
I’m curious to see their readslist.

[Alchemist21]

I have a simple explanation for the unsolicited claim: he really, REALLY wants to be targeted at night because it benefits him.

At least you’re right about this.

Alch, you were scum in Big 4 mafia, right?

Yeah.

[DrippingGoofball]

But the game state leans them to be more likely Town Aligned then scum Aligned.

How can you even read an alignment from a bunch of pictures?

[Logicalicaltist]

But the game state leans them to be more likely Town Aligned then scum Aligned.

How can you even read an alignment from a bunch of pictures?

Wagonomics.

[Logicalicaltist]

Plus if there scum only posting GiF’s.
There would be times where it’s probably best to not respond to a certain post.
But it appears they tend to have always respond to posts direct at them or concerning them.

[Doctor Drew]

I have a simple explanation for the unsolicited claim: he really, REALLY wants to be targeted at night because it benefits him.

At least you’re right about this.

Alch, you were scum in Big 4 mafia, right?

Yeah.

Hmm, I thought I remember you fake claiming that game. After a quick refresher, you didn't really.

Also, couldn't really discern any similarities from D1 in that game and D1 in this game from you.

So basically I just wasted my time.

[DrippingGoofball]

TOWNIES

DrippingGoofball
username
vecna
Elsa Jay
Doctor Drew
aLMOST50

SUBURBANITES

pisskop
Lavender
TemporalLich

FARMERS

Logicalicaltist
gobbledygook

???PASTURE???

Pooky
Pine
Alchemist21

[Logicalicaltist]

I have a simple explanation for the unsolicited claim: he really, REALLY wants to be targeted at night because it benefits him.

At least you’re right about this.

Alch, you were scum in Big 4 mafia, right?

Yeah.

Hmm, I thought I remember you fake claiming that game. After a quick refresher, you didn't really.

Also, couldn't really discern any similarities from D1 in that game and D1 in this game from you.

So basically I just wasted my time.

Logically speaking you didn’t waste your time.
You learnt that Alchemist didn’t fake claim.
I looked over that game and pretty sure one of their scum members called them out or something.

[Logicalicaltist]

TOWNIES

DrippingGoofball
username
vecna
Elsa Jay
Doctor Drew
aLMOST50

SUBURBANITES

pisskop
Lavender
TemporalLich

FARMERS

Logicalicaltist
gobbledygook

???PASTURE???

Pooky
Pine
Alchemist21

What do you mean by “Farmers”?
And why is Pine below Gobble when both have barley posted a thing.

[votato]

TOWNIES

DrippingGoofball
username
vecna
Elsa Jay
Doctor Drew
aLMOST50

SUBURBANITES

pisskop
Lavender
TemporalLich

FARMERS

Logicalicaltist
gobbledygook

???PASTURE???

Pooky
Pine
Alchemist21

im very sad now

also town wants as many people left in the game as possible, yes? so by targeting the 3p we help them win which hurts town by getting us to lylo faster. its not helpful to confirm someone as non-scum if they simply fuck off and arent in the game anymore.

[Logicalicaltist]

Also, did you forget Iecerint exists?

[Logicalicaltist]

Oh yeah Votato is also not on that list.

[Logicalicaltist]

I want more content from both Pine and Gobble before I make my own readslist.

[votato]

I want more content from both Pine and Gobble before I make my own readslist.

why? you cant sort anyone else without hearing from those two?

[DrippingGoofball]

TOWNIES

DrippingGoofball
username
vecna
Elsa Jay
Doctor Drew
aLMOST50

SUBURBANITES

pisskop
Lavender
TemporalLich

FARMERS

Logicalicaltist
gobbledygook

???PASTURE???

Pooky
Pine
Alchemist21

What do you mean by “Farmers”?
And why is Pine below Gobble when both have barley posted a thing.

"Farmers" is scum
"Pasture" is gifposters, massive lurkers and third party bullshitters.

[DrippingGoofball]

I want more content from both Pine and Gobble before I make my own readslist.

why? you cant sort anyone else without hearing from those two?

I forgot you

I'm going to have to put you in the null pile because I was wrong about you being town in another game.

[DrippingGoofball]

Also, did you forget Iecerint exists?

I have him as null, for some reason I forgot to type his name.