tyIn post 2071, Chara wrote:when i read Nahdia's flip. after that i went through the thread backwards and it became apparent that werewolves were town.
2. i mean i guess i think that it's more likely dru is telling the truth than not, but i don't see why *you* think that?In post 2072, Clover Ebi wrote:1) Yeah it is pretty weird, but we don't know what the scum have so it's best to not overthink and go into what ifs right?
2) Why is that odd?
3) Really? Tux was someone I was scumreading from before all this started so this is odd.
I understand that! I get why people are doing it, but I wouldn't consider that the most important thing to be talking about in my own eyes. You seem very pleasant it's a shame you weren't here from the start!In post 2074, Chara wrote:i was wondering if you were scum but this makes me really doubt it.
it's okay, ahaha. maybe i'd be upset if i'd been here since the beginning, but it's fine. still, even in that case i'd consider it a good thing to grill the player you're going to vote... in the majority of situations?
and like do you just automatically believe all investigative claims by default?In post 2060, Clover Ebi wrote:We have a guilty claim from her that we have no reason to doubt! Plus if she was scum why guilty a partner?
I'm a player who likes thinking of future events. I also like to townread people until proven otherwise. The main reason I've seen to doubt Drusilla is a reason I myself brought up but almost no one commented on. Along with a Nahdia interaction. Regardless of my personal viewpoint on her is it not as simple as we lynch Chara and Drusilla if it's wrong?In post 2076, beeboy wrote:Clover why are you playing in absolutes?
Don't get me wrong I strongly believe me and Skitter are wasting our time but I think it's the correct way of doing it.
I just find it odd you're approaching your read on Drusilla this entire game with utmost certainty.
Noughts and Crosses you just didn't strike me as someone to play like this at all?
Well, this game is different. I can't play this game like I would normally it goes against my entire style because people were playing like werewolves and all of day 1 I was saying I couldn't find scumreads. I would have to restart the game all over again and feel even more useless than before. I'm not confident, in fact this is probably the least confident I've been in any mafia game. That's why I'm trying to rely on others than myself. Is that what feels different? 2) Why shouldn't I think that?In post 2077, skitter30 wrote:2. i mean i guess i think that it's more likely dru is telling the truth than not, but i don't see why *you* think that?In post 2072, Clover Ebi wrote:1) Yeah it is pretty weird, but we don't know what the scum have so it's best to not overthink and go into what ifs right?
2) Why is that odd?
3) Really? Tux was someone I was scumreading from before all this started so this is odd.
3. can you give me a refresher? why did you think tux was scum?
Do you have any reason to doubt the claim?In post 2079, skitter30 wrote:and like do you just automatically believe all investigative claims by default?In post 2060, Clover Ebi wrote:We have a guilty claim from her that we have no reason to doubt! Plus if she was scum why guilty a partner?
2. i mean i guess between dru/chara why do you think dru is telling the truth? like i'm not sure i have a reason to doubt the claim but the circumstances are a bit weird (like why is she even alive to be able to give this is confusing me) so the fact that you don't have any doubt i'm finding a bit strangeIn post 2081, Clover Ebi wrote:2) Why shouldn't I think that?
3) The way he played the early game felt really scummy to me. Along with the fact me and Dru noted that Tux probably slipped a few times. We just didn't push it because fear of getting night killed when we thought the game was multiball but Tux has always been a scumread of mine.
i think bee is p strongly town, for how he reacted immediately after the ww -> town thing, and for how strongly he's defending dunn (saying things like if he'd rather himself flip to prove dunn town than flipping dunn, etc)In post 2083, Chara wrote:skitter: how are you feeling about beeboy?
drusilla doesn't really feel like scum with a fakeclaim, and it'd honestly be an awful play to me. at the same time, looking at flips i can't think of an explanation for a false guilty besides that she's lying for some reason. what were you and beeboy referring to when you said you wouldn't reevaluate them on my townflip?
2) I'm positive that Drusilla is telling the truth skitter you should trust me on this. Look at the most likely option and it starts making a ton of sense.In post 2085, skitter30 wrote:2. i mean i guess between dru/chara why do you think dru is telling the truth? like i'm not sure i have a reason to doubt the claim but the circumstances are a bit weird (like why is she even alive to be able to give this is confusing me) so the fact that you don't have any doubt i'm finding a bit strangeIn post 2081, Clover Ebi wrote:2) Why shouldn't I think that?
3) The way he played the early game felt really scummy to me. Along with the fact me and Dru noted that Tux probably slipped a few times. We just didn't push it because fear of getting night killed when we thought the game was multiball but Tux has always been a scumread of mine.
3. can you give some examples of tux slipping?
re:confidence, kinda?In post 2080, Clover Ebi wrote:I'm a player who likes thinking of future events. I also like to townread people until proven otherwise. The main reason I've seen to doubt Drusilla is a reason I myself brought up but almost no one commented on. Along with a Nahdia interaction. Regardless of my personal viewpoint on her is it not as simple as we lynch Chara and Drusilla if it's wrong?
Are you saying it's weird that I'm showing a bit of confidence? Well, this game is different. I can't play this game like I would normally it goes against my entire style because people were playing like werewolves and all of day 1 I was saying I couldn't find scumreads. I would have to restart the game all over again and feel even more useless than before. I'm not confident, in fact this is probably the least confident I've been in any mafia game. That's why I'm trying to rely on others than myself. Is that what feels different?
This is when we thought the game was multiball and Tux was talking about 2 man scumteams. From a multiball pov that looked like a pretty big slip to meIn post 2090, skitter30 wrote:wait why is that a slip vs all of thinking we're in a 2man werewolf team?
maybe i'm jaded, but i think town makes a bad false guilty more often than scum fakes a guilty on a slot that was pretty votable.In post 2087, skitter30 wrote:*why she does this as town lying about having a guilty on you
so like if her result is wrong i'd think she's scum since i don't think town!you lies about visiting her either
but i also thought i was on a 2man scumteam at the time too ....In post 2094, Clover Ebi wrote:This is when we thought the game was multiball and Tux was talking about 2 man scumteams. From a multiball pov that looked like a pretty big slip to meIn post 2090, skitter30 wrote:wait why is that a slip vs all of thinking we're in a 2man werewolf team?
no, your slot was very likely to be voted out today regardless of what dru did/said (barring her coming in with a guilty on someone else, i suppose)In post 2095, Chara wrote:is that likely?
