Silent Star 1: Lunacy

[beeboy]

I feel kinda bad >______>

[beeboy]

I don’t believe both Dru and Dunn are investigative

she's technically a backup

She backs up like 2-3 investigative roles though

[Dunnstral]

One of the theories I had with the night flavor is that people who were previously werewolves days 1/2 would start turning into mafia, until there was a team of 4 mafia

So the game would have started with 2 mafia, and then 2 more people would be 'infected', or by the flavor 'have their amnesia removed'

That would explain the missing kill last night, I don't know if the game wouldn't just end if all the mafia died though

[Dunnstral]

On the other side of speculation, something happening to people that hammer doesn't seem very likely to me

[drusilla]

(；﹏；)

people are so sure i'm somehow the third mafia in a game in which i don't even believe there to be a third mafia and having the knowledge that they are very wrong and yet so sure and not being able to convey that to them even though i feel it is very obvious from my play across the board and skitter being the only one who sees it while i'm not even sure i'm aligned with her is

(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)

[midwaybear]

But I thought the werewolves are the good guys, so it does not make sense for them to turn into mafiosos.

[drusilla]

One of the theories I had with the night flavor is that people who were previously werewolves days 1/2 would start turning into mafia, until there was a team of 4 mafia

So the game would have started with 2 mafia, and then 2 more people would be 'infected', or by the flavor 'have their amnesia removed'

That would explain the missing kill last night, I don't know if the game wouldn't just end if all the mafia died though

there are no midgame alignment changes. it stated that in queue specifically.

[Dunnstral]

UNVOTE:

Well it's not me + beeboy

[Raven Branwen]

But it to some degree would show he thought he was a WW that could use that PT for actions

My action counted

Can confirm they work in the PT. also,

You can see that I stopped calling Clover scum on day 3

AH that makes sense.

Although I wouldn't really expect scum to be havin ppl other than Nahdia/Tux kill on those first two nights

VOTE: drusilla

I think the watcher was a fake claim

the even-night watcher is a flipped werewolf. i am a werewolf global backup.

Do you not agree that a ww even night watcher, a ww bg, a ww AC, a ww detective, plus a ww global backup is a lot of ww power - not to mention ridiculously cop heavy?

I think it’s highly unlikely both you and Dunn are ww investigatives and Dunn’s claim is more believable than yours.

yes, obviously, the amount of power is one of the reasons i thought it was very likely there was an additional non-werewolf.

why is dunnstral's claim more believable to you?

Because Chara/Tux was a gonner, so a watcher guilty on them was unnecessary. My Nahdia ISO read, your suspiciously confident claim that mafia had been eliminated. You initially pushing me and Skittter as 3P scumteam, when there’s evidence of Nahdia trying to frame us. As MT already pointed out, it would definitely explain the no kill. What has Dunn done that is even remotely agenda-y to you? And he he was scum here, he 100% would be pushing one.

[Raven Branwen]

I don’t believe both Dru and Dunn are investigative

she's technically a backup

Still a lot of town/cop power against two flipped goons?

[beeboy]

UNVOTE:

Well it's not me + beeboy

Idk I really just don't think Dru is town, even if I feel about pushing them this hard :\
I don't think we have particularly better options, I know scum held back the kill so the Skitter result is meaningless.
But like I just am not ready to look elsewhere right now.

[beeboy]

@Midway talk reads for me, you aren't doing that and it is making me sad.

[beeboy]

Come and suffer like the rest of us!!!

[Raven Branwen]

One of the theories I had with the night flavor is that people who were previously werewolves days 1/2 would start turning into mafia, until there was a team of 4 mafia

So the game would have started with 2 mafia, and then 2 more people would be 'infected', or by the flavor 'have their amnesia removed'

That would explain the missing kill last night, I don't know if the game wouldn't just end if all the mafia died though

This game wasn’t advertised as bastard though.

[drusilla]

This game wasn’t advertised as bastard though.

it said no midgame alignment changes but there may be other bastard elements.

[Morning Tweet]

(；﹏；)

people are so sure i'm somehow the third mafia in a game in which i don't even believe there to be a third mafia and having the knowledge that they are very wrong and yet so sure and not being able to convey that to them even though i feel it is very obvious from my play across the board and skitter being the only one who sees it while i'm not even sure i'm aligned with her is

(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)(；﹏；)

idk where else to go \(;﹏;)/

I'm not sure at all but I don't think we're dealing with a third party. And if that's the case, then who would the third mafia even be?

[Raven Branwen]

But I thought the werewolves are the good guys, so it does not make sense for them to turn into mafiosos.

One of the theories I had with the night flavor is that people who were previously werewolves days 1/2 would start turning into mafia, until there was a team of 4 mafia

So the game would have started with 2 mafia, and then 2 more people would be 'infected', or by the flavor 'have their amnesia removed'

That would explain the missing kill last night, I don't know if the game wouldn't just end if all the mafia died though

there are no midgame alignment changes. it stated that in queue specifically.

I very much doubt I would ever knowingly sign up for game like that. I recently played in one where the mod never informed us and I was seriously pissesd, because it fucked up all of my reads.

[drusilla]

it said no midgame alignment changes but there may be other bastard elements.

/in to mod

Is it possible your game has any of the following bastard roles or mechanics?

No cults or mid-game alignment changes. There may be other bastard elements.

[Morning Tweet]

UNVOTE:

Well it's not me + beeboy

like, if we're dealing with a 2 man non-mafia team, that's probably what it'd have to be. Right? So i can't really accept that there isnt more mafia cause i dont think beeboy/Dunn is the case

[Dunnstral]

One of the theories I had with the night flavor is that people who were previously werewolves days 1/2 would start turning into mafia, until there was a team of 4 mafia

So the game would have started with 2 mafia, and then 2 more people would be 'infected', or by the flavor 'have their amnesia removed'

That would explain the missing kill last night, I don't know if the game wouldn't just end if all the mafia died though

This game wasn’t advertised as bastard though.

We're all werewolves and there was mafia in werewolf pts

[beeboy]

I feel like getting a wolf role pm as town is a bastard element.

[beeboy]

Dru making me feel so bad trying to lynch her wtf.
Can you just roll over and flip scum >:(

[drusilla]

Dru making me feel so bad trying to lynch her wtf.
Can you just roll over and flip scum >:(

i won't though. if you're willing to look at them i'll link you all of my completed games as mafia. like i am clearly not here.

[Dunnstral]

UNVOTE:

Well it's not me + beeboy

like, if we're dealing with a 2 man non-mafia team, that's probably what it'd have to be. Right? So i can't really accept that there isnt more mafia cause i dont think beeboy/Dunn is the case

Why can't they be in other pts like the mafia were

And if that's the case people who were in pts with power roles aren't necessarily clear

[beeboy]

Dru making me feel so bad trying to lynch her wtf.
Can you just roll over and flip scum >:(

i won't though. if you're willing to look at them i'll link you all of my completed games as mafia. like i am clearly not here.

Idk who I should be voting then.
And I don't understand this setup.

I just feel like you make the most sense here