Silent Star 1: Lunacy

[Morning Tweet]

I can't see Dunn getting killed forcing a Clover v. beeboy 1v1, doesn't seem right. But yeah may as well get another result just in case

[beeboy]

I was going to claim Dunnstrals role if I learned this game had another super high power PR.

[Raven Branwen]

Doesn’t a fast night just give scum an extra kill or am I missing something? I’m going to try and paraphrase what Skitter said to me in the PT.

Anyway, sorry Dru. I should have trusted Kanna/Skitter.

So Dunn got a no kill result on midway but how do we know we can 100% trust that, because if we can then who is it?

Skittter’s PoE was essentially the same as mine, except of course she was seriously pissed at how the Dru wagon got pushed through.

And if Dunn is telling the truth than, is it Clover? I don’t think it’s bee and I don’t even want to entertain the idea of MT scum.

So if our reads are right, I or MT is likely dying next but why no kill N3? Was scum trying to frame Dru?

I’m not speed voting anything. For all I know this might be my last chance to post in the main thread, because it’s obvious I or MT is next.

[beeboy]

I can't see Dunn getting killed forcing a Clover v. beeboy 1v1, doesn't seem right. But yeah may as well get another result just in case

I mean it forces the Dunnstral 1v1 with whoever is scum.
So basically even if it isn't Dunnstral we get to see who the last scum is for the following day.

[Raven Branwen]

Doesn’t a fast night just give scum an extra kill or am I missing something? I’m going to try and paraphrase what Skitter said to me in the PT.

Anyway, sorry Dru. I should have trusted Kanna/Skitter.

So Dunn got a no kill result on midway but how do we know we can 100% trust that, because if we can then who is it?

Skittter’s PoE was essentially the same as mine, except of course she was seriously pissed at how the Dru wagon got pushed through.

And if Dunn is telling the truth than, is it Clover? I don’t think it’s bee and I don’t even want to entertain the idea of MT scum.

So if our reads are right, I or MT is likely dying next but why no kill N3? Was scum trying to frame Dru?

I’m not speed voting anything. For all I know this might be my last chance to post in the main thread, because it’s obvious I or MT is next.

I don’t know how that laughy emoji got in there, I am extremely upset rn.

[midwaybear]

well if dunn is scum, it's dumb for him to false guilty(maybe not because we have little numbers)

[beeboy]

Because Dunnstral has to claim another Innocent?
So either Dunnstral is town and all his results are true or Dunnstral is scum in which case he forces a 1v1 with whoever his fake results point to.

Lynching now doesn't allow us to lynch both Dunnstral and whoever we get POE locked into calling scum.
We literally just lose information No Lynching.

[Morning Tweet]

I can't see Dunn getting killed forcing a Clover v. beeboy 1v1, doesn't seem right. But yeah may as well get another result just in case

I mean it forces the Dunnstral 1v1 with whoever is scum.
So basically even if it isn't Dunnstral we get to see who the last scum is for the following day.

Ah no i mean i just find it very unlikely. Since they already would have let Dunn get 1 result. Think he's probably just cornered

[beeboy]

If Dunnstral is scum, we can trust his innocent results since it gets us closer to a 1v1.
If Dunnstral is town we can trust his innocent results since he is town.

We literally should always no lynch here.

[Raven Branwen]

I can't see Dunn getting killed forcing a Clover v. beeboy 1v1, doesn't seem right. But yeah may as well get another result just in case

I think you’re the only I think I can trust rn. I feel lost without Skitter. :/

[beeboy]

I'd rather have a forced 1v1 against Dunnstral with just me.
Or just Clover vs Dunnstral.

Then lynch now and have it be Me v Dunn v Clover.
Feels like objectively the bad way to approach this.

[Raven Branwen]

Because Dunnstral has to claim another Innocent?
So either Dunnstral is town and all his results are true or Dunnstral is scum in which case he forces a 1v1 with whoever his fake results point to.

Lynching now doesn't allow us to lynch both Dunnstral and whoever we get POE locked into calling scum.
We literally just lose information No Lynching.

What part of either me or MT is probably dying tonight isn’t registering with people? I’m not fucking rushing any vote through, I could be dead before tomorrow.

[Morning Tweet]

I can't see Dunn getting killed forcing a Clover v. beeboy 1v1, doesn't seem right. But yeah may as well get another result just in case

I think you’re the only I think I can trust rn. I feel lost without Skitter. :/

The no-lynch isn't a trick.

We're in evens right now. If we let scum kill me and force Dunn to give another innocent result, then we basically solve the game no matter if Dunn is town or mafia.

Let's say Dunn gets an innocent on Clover and I die. that makes the remaining players:

Raven (wolf)
Clover (innocent)
midway(innocent)
beeboy(?)
Dunn(detective)

We can then kill both Dunn and beeboy. Dunn's innocents are correct if he's town, and if he's scum it doesnt matter cause he'll die anyway

[Raven Branwen]

I'd rather have a forced 1v1 against Dunnstral with just me.
Or just Clover vs Dunnstral.

Then lynch now and have it be Me v Dunn v Clover.
Feels like objectively the bad way to approach this.

Is there some reason we need to make this decision right now? We have like what 6 days?

[Morning Tweet]

Really what scum could do is not kill you and I, Raven, cause technically Clover/midway would be mechanically confirmed town in that situation and we're just like 99% confirmed town.

[midwaybear]

it seems like scum might have been informed that dunn was a detective...

[beeboy]

Because Dunnstral has to claim another Innocent?
So either Dunnstral is town and all his results are true or Dunnstral is scum in which case he forces a 1v1 with whoever his fake results point to.

Lynching now doesn't allow us to lynch both Dunnstral and whoever we get POE locked into calling scum.
We literally just lose information No Lynching.

What part of either me or MT is probably dying tonight isn’t registering with people? I’m not fucking rushing any vote through, I could be dead before tomorrow.

Sure take your time to do it.
But I am not compromising on the outcome.

[Morning Tweet]

If we don't NL, and instead exile Dunn, we win if he's scum. However if he's not scum, and I die, that leaves us with

Raven(wolf)
midway(inno)
beeboy(?)
Clover(?)

You can only choose one. One of the "?" gets to live, and we lose if that person is scum.

Whereas if we NL, all three "?"s are accounted for (Dunn/Clover/beeboy)

[Raven Branwen]

I can't see Dunn getting killed forcing a Clover v. beeboy 1v1, doesn't seem right. But yeah may as well get another result just in case

I think you’re the only I think I can trust rn. I feel lost without Skitter. :/

The no-lynch isn't a trick.

We're in evens right now. If we let scum kill me and force Dunn to give another innocent result, then we basically solve the game no matter if Dunn is town or mafia.

Let's say Dunn gets an innocent on Clover and I die. that makes the remaining players:

Raven (wolf)
Clover (innocent)
midway(innocent)
beeboy(?)
Dunn(detective)

We can then kill both Dunn and beeboy. Dunn's innocents are correct if he's town, and if he's scum it doesnt matter cause he'll die anyway

So I’m still confused and we don’t know it’s you. Skitter confirmed me, so it could easily be me.

But I don’t see why we’re rushing this. That didn’t work out so hot with Dru.

[Morning Tweet]

Well it doesn't matter who they kill we're all VTs

[Raven Branwen]

Really what scum could do is not kill you and I, Raven, cause technically Clover/midway would be mechanically confirmed town in that situation and we're just like 99% confirmed town.

Would that make it bee? I’m sorry, I’m not following any of this.

[Morning Tweet]

I'd be down for some gambling and killing off Dunn immediately today but i'd feel immensely stupid if that fails cause otherwise the game was an auto-win via NL so long as Raven and I are wolves

Really what scum could do is not kill you and I, Raven, cause technically Clover/midway would be mechanically confirmed town in that situation and we're just like 99% confirmed town.

Would that make it bee? I’m sorry, I’m not following any of this.

Scum can kill anyone in Raven/Morning/midway cause we're all solidly wolves.

The only people eligible for us to exile for the rest of the game are Clover/beeboy/Dunn.

If we NL today, we can use Dunn's night action to clear beeboy or Clover, then we exile Dunn the next day. If Dunn was town, we kill the final player in that three and win for free.

[beeboy]

I'd be down for some gambling and killing off Dunn immediately today but i'd feel immensely stupid if that fails cause otherwise the game was an auto-win via NL so long as Raven and I are wolves

I am not throwing this game to save us 48 hours.

[midwaybear]

are you saying we basically have won?

[beeboy]

If Raven and MT are town and we no lynch.
We literally always win.