Redneck Mafia GAME OVER PARTNER!

[Titus]

How I analyze Titus is forever changing because she's a savvy lawyer and if I have the hook I better be fucking ready for a fire fight because she brings it.

Knock off the burden of proficiency and read me as any other player if you're town.

I bring the fire as either alignment. I defend better than I prosecute. I am a big believer in reasonable doubt.

Pretty strange stance for a lawyer to not account for proficiency.

Id wager your day does not go well if you do not account for the proficiency of opposing council.

Accounting for the proficiency of opposing council is a factor for defeating the argument, not for whether or not the speaker believes it to be true.

[Titus]

*counsel

[Vecna]

The annoying thing about this game is that all my reads can be discounted. No hardlock towns whatsoever. Most scum suspects have had some nice redeeming posts. TL and LC are going to get themselves lynched because their logic is all over the place and has no trajectory that people can identify with. The pisskop and username slots are skilled enough to fake that shit.

yegh

Have you considered that TL and LC have no trajectory because they're scum?

Reasonable doubt.

Also, I have a towntell for their type of players, and if they continue to gun for me in that stubborn way that every person does when they play with me for the first time, it usually means only good things.

Besides, every person has their own type of moon logic. I think theirs is consistent with their personality, but more importantly: genuine

[Vecna]

maybe ive just become a sucker for punishment.

Im convinced TL is going to flip town though

[Titus]

UNVOTE: TL

I'll unvote for now until I get some time to reflect at least and look at the VCs some more.

[chkflip]

Hm. Okay.

VOTE: Elsa Jay

It has been brought to my attention that I'm ignoring you. I wanted to hand wave it away as bullshit, but I know I can't because it's absolutely true. That one time you pocketed the fuck out of me, compounded by that one time we lost to Reck/Tripod scum give me mixed feelings about how to read you at all. So let's do this.

What are your reads?

What is your opinion of the gamestate?

Why are you only claiming Miller now instead of in post one?

How do you feel about the claims in this game?

[Thun]

Let's lynch Temp. Who should I shoot based on what he flips?

Whichever lurker you think is most likely to flip scum.

Regardless of everything else (and his alignment), chk is right that we have a lot of lurk and that needs to be addressed in order to keep the game state healthy enough to actually catch scum.

Sure. I won't say who then to keep scum guessing whether I'm targeting them.

[Elsa Jay]

Hm. Okay.

VOTE: Elsa Jay

It has been brought to my attention that I'm ignoring you. I wanted to hand wave it away as bullshit, but I know I can't because it's absolutely true. That one time you pocketed the fuck out of me, compounded by that one time we lost to Reck/Tripod scum give me mixed feelings about how to read you at all. So let's do this.

What are your reads?

What is your opinion of the gamestate?

Why are you only claiming Miller now instead of in post one?

How do you feel about the claims in this game?

My reads are jumbled at the moment. No solid foundation anyway I look at it.

The gamestate gives way for continuously shifting wagons more then I usually see, though I blame that more on the active players ass disagreeing where to go.

Well I specifically claimed a Gel that isn't helpful to town but I never even claimed to be an IC once. I let day 1 ride like normal. Contriversal claims like that are better day 2 IMO since then you at least have a basis of who did what.

Claims are interesting I guess. I'm paying more attention to those day 3 with more results tho.

[Elsa Jay]

and when I say *IC in the above post I meant a previous game, but am comparing it to my situation of not claiming day 1. Bleh

[Bingle]

Im convinced TL is going to flip town though

What do you think of his reactions to PR claims if he is indeed a PR?

Every time a PR claim comes up he shows absolutely no concern that it's a fakeclaim from my perspective. I agree that the emphasis on survivability does make sense from town PR, but literally everything else doesn't.

[Bingle]

Honestly this is where im at, and I think these reads are pretty controversial, but pretty decent

Town:

Vecna
Thun pisskop

TemporalLich

Logicalicaltist
PookyTheMagicalBear*
Titus Doctor Drew
DrippingGoofball*
Froppy username

3P:
Alchemist21

All scum in this pool?:
Almost50
Bingle gobbledygook
chkflip votato

Galron Pine
Elsa Jay

This list has a lot of overlap with my own. (bolded for comparison)

Also, I legitimately forgot monkey was in the game at all, and that's probably a giant red flag.

[Vecna]

Im convinced TL is going to flip town though

What do you think of his reactions to PR claims if he is indeed a PR?

Every time a PR claim comes up he shows absolutely no concern that it's a fakeclaim from my perspective. I agree that the emphasis on survivability does make sense from town PR, but literally everything else doesn't.

None of his reactions really have stood out as weird to me. Ive been working under the assumptions theres plenty of PRs in this game, so I dont really see a reason why him being a PR should significantly alter how he responds to claims.

[Froppy]

Honestly just mostly going off of other people's reads for this one.

VOTE: TL

[Vecna]

VOTE: Froppy

Maybe you shouldnt do that after you just replace in and it puts the slot as the likely lynch for the day

[chkflip]

My reads are jumbled at the moment. No solid foundation anyway I look at it.

Give me three reads you have.

The gamestate gives way for continuously shifting wagons more then I usually see, though I blame that more on the active players ass disagreeing where to go.

Where do you believe we should go? Why?

Well I specifically claimed a Gel that isn't helpful to town but I never even claimed to be an IC once. I let day 1 ride like normal. Contriversal claims like that are better day 2 IMO since then you at least have a basis of who did what.

Is Gel in the wiki? I've never heard of it.

Claims are interesting I guess. I'm paying more attention to those day 3 with more results tho.

D3 should be fun. At least more fun than whatever this is. But I mean in general, what do you think of them beyond a blanket "interesting"? Do you take them at face value? Do you believe all of them? And I do mean _all_ of them?

[TemporalLich]

forever at E-2, too late to do anything at all useful for risk of being quickhammered but too early to claim...

[chkflip]

If someone votes him I'll claim intent.

[Elsa Jay]

Gel is Goo. Alchemist is claiming Gold Goo. I'm a different type from him.

[chkflip]

That still doesn't mean anything to me.

You're third party?

[chkflip]

I just looked it up. Not necessarily 3p but that's interesting.

Why did you claim?

[Titus]

*checks name of game*
*checks role PM*

If this is redneck mafia, why is there so much goo?

[Elsa Jay]

Baker uses a lotta gel obviously.

[chkflip]

Gel is definitely a redneck thing. Can confirm.

Elsa I asked more questions please don't ignore me thanks.

[TemporalLich]

from what I'm aware the closest thing dimension 1 rednecks have to slimy substances is mud... more specifically driving through it

[Elsa Jay]

I'm at work can't type much only pun