Open 785: Secrets of the Anuket Topaz [Game over!]

[Menalque]

also montosh’s relative indifference if he was mafia of being put into a losing position this close to eod would be odd.

Would it look better if he was desperately yelling that I was scum and that guillotining him was shit play?

[Menalque]

But I did have that thought. I just thought about it more and decided that a massive “don’t guillo me!” reaction would look just as bad?

[Ydrasse]

it wouldn’t even have to be that extreme but just anything other than “really guys?”

it could be that he doesn’t have time at this point to defend himself but it struck me as weird for maf. like literally any effort at all.

[RCEnigma]

VOTE: SS

[Umlaut]

So if either of these wagons is on scum then RCE and S_S

have

to both be town or else have balls of steel

[Umlaut]

(of course by the time we know one of the wagons is on scum the game is probably over, but still)

[Something_Smart]

(of course by the time we know one of the wagons is on scum the game is probably over, but still)

Not if one of them flees.

[Umlaut]

Oh, right.

[Eevee]

Eva, can you try to tell me where you think I’m going wrong on my montosh read then?

It isn't so much as there's anything wrong, it just doesn't resonate with me. I also mindmeld with Montosh more than I let on and I don't think he's scum(?)

~Eva

[Umlaut]

I

still

don't understand what happens if we lynch town today but scum tomorrow, as far as the escape mechanism goes. Does the last scum escape and we lose? Do they escape and we win? Do they hang around for Day 4?

[Eevee]

I still prefer A50.

If we do Montosh today and he flips town however, I am going to deadsheep him because it will give me confidence in my soul-solves. Montosh, what do you think?

~Eva

p-edit: if we lynch town D3, we auto-win?

[Umlaut]

Never mind, I read again and got it. So:

• If we get either scum today, we win
  
• If we get either scum tomorrow, we win
  
• If we don't get scum both today and tomorrow, then one escapes (and we learn who they are) and we have to get the other on Day 4 to win

[Menalque]

if we lynch town D3, we auto-win?

No, if we lynch scum D3 we auto-win

[Menalque]

Eva, can you try to tell me where you think I’m going wrong on my montosh read then?

It isn't so much as there's anything wrong, it just doesn't resonate with me. I also mindmeld with Montosh more than I let on and I don't think he's scum(?)

~Eva

Okay

I kind of don’t wanna fight you on it after yesterday but I think montosh and I’m not sold enough on A50 to want to change

[Eevee]

if we lynch town D3, we auto-win?

No, if we lynch scum D3 we auto-win

whOoPS! Yeah, that.

~Eva

[Eevee]

Argh, it's fine. Really, the problem is this day has gone on for too long. I think we're still in a good position and potentially any flip is good information so... let's end it, guys.

~Eva

[Umlaut]

Montosh is the leading wagon anyway Eva, I don't see anyone changing their mind now, so I'll vote it if you will. Save an hour waiting for deadline that way.

[Eevee]

Spoiler:

I feel like Montosh is a mistake... DOES ANYONE WANT TO GO A50? ANYONE? LAST CALL!!!

~Eva

[Menalque]

Sorry, Eva, I don’t or at least I don’t > montosh

[Eevee]

VOTE: Montosh

~Eva

[Umlaut]

VOTE: Montosh

[Ydrasse]

Spoiler:

me after the stress of this d2

[Menalque]

Weirdly maybe, I didn’t find it stressful. Maybe a little frustrating at points. Hopefully this is GG

[Montosh]

Unfortunately not, I am in fact town.

[Montosh]

I was gonna post when I got back from work but ended up taking a nap instead so whoops.

I'm slightly concerned about my Menalque read because I'm wondering how much they'd blatantly push a townie but if it to save themselves until they could escape maybe?

Anyway my reads right now look something like:

Town

Raya
RCE

Ydrasse

S_S
A50
Menalque

Scum

With the caveat that I think that A50 and Menalque probably aren't the same alignment.