Redneck Mafia GAME OVER PARTNER!

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

[Elsa Jay]

A claims chart would be real useful right about now.

Elsa, you standing by your vig claim or you redacted that?

My latest claim is a type of Goo. I was asking if anyone visited me.

[Vecna]

Except Alchemist never brought up cookies, and he definitely was the first to bring up cookies.

And sure, cookies, happen all the time.

They just dont happen all the time at random, when the entire scumteam just happens to all be talking about poisoned cookies right at that same moment, A50 confesses he's about to die, and then dies the next night.....flipping a traitor that gives out poisoned cookies.

But sure, its all just one big coincidence ~

[Galron]

Vanilly Hillbilly

If that's true, you were told that you have two things. What are they?

[Froppy]

How did you make the selection of what to read?

Sounds to me like Froppy went and informed you in scumchat of us figuring the shit out.

I’m a team player what can I say

[Froppy]

Vanilly Hillbilly

If that's true, you were told that you have two things. What are they?

It was specifically my daily vote, and my voice.

[Elsa Jay]

Froppy who do you think are the villains?

[Galron]

Vanilly Hillbilly

If that's true, you were told that you have two things. What are they?

It was specifically my daily vote, and my voice.

Legit.

[Bingle]

was promised cookies. I want my cookies

Hm.

[DrippingGoofball]

Stop assuming scum are braindead. That's just my predecessor using the word "cookies" and nothing more - it's not exactly an uncommon word.

A scumfession!!!!

[DrippingGoofball]

Stop assuming scum are brain dead LOL

[DrippingGoofball]

VOTE: ThunThun

[Logicalicaltist]

Yo Pooky.
If you had to solve the game RN who would you say are scum?

[Vecna]

just read the bloody game and youd know....hes made it pretty obvious hes onboard with my theory

[Vecna]

was promised cookies. I want my cookies

Hm.

oh the irony. regardless, day1

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

just read the bloody game and youd know....hes made it pretty obvious hes onboard with my theory

[Vecna]

username sure was claiming VT early in the game already, and flashing that flavour around like his personal.armour, much like froppy is doing right now.

One of the provided scum fakeclaims/town role pms maybe? Itd at least explain to a certain extent why TL came out with his actual role pm when forced to claim.

[Vecna]

Anyways, Thun has reaponded Bingle, id like your input. clearly you were intrigued enough to start scouring isos for the references.

[Titus]

I counterclaim VT fwiw.

[Titus]

It is Vanilla Hilbilly as the name.

[Logicalicaltist]

It’s possible scum knows the VT flavour.

[Logicalicaltist]

I’d say 1 scum in VT and 1 scum in PR.

[Titus]

It’s possible scum knows the VT flavour.

I didn't claim my flavor for that reason. Let's see what they say.

[Bingle]

Anyone who was responsible for the A50 death should claim. Anyone with an impending death by biscuit that they know about should claim.

I expected thun, regardless of alignment, to claim the A50 death. The fact that he didn’t is very eyebrows. I should probably take a look at who would nk him here.

I don’t particularly buy into the theory of scum signaling A50 via ‘cookie’. For one thing, nothing in A50’s flip mentions a loud component to his power. Vecna’s cookie post was early D1, and was in fact the first usage of cookie in the thread. I intentionally removed the context to see if anyone would jump on Vecna for it, but if you want to check for yourself it was roughly around post 400.

In order for A50 to be signaling he’d poisoned himself and the scumteam to be able to know they’d been targeted he’d have to be informed his role backfired by the role he targeted, and he thus would have targeted an announcing self voyeurizing reflector. That’s a lot of moving parts and assumptions, and we have two external goo claims that really don’t jive well with the narrativ.

If logical is town, there is necessarily a scum role blocker. RB/GatedVig/VariantReflector/poisonertraitor is a weird scumteam in what we know/have claimed of this setup. Pooky is non targeting. The reflector would be a godfather, scum would have up to 3kpn and there’s a functional miller in the 3p. If instead of RB it’s a tracker that’s not much better, and there’s no reason for there to be a ninja modifier on the cop if there’s no tracker at all.

Thun may well be town

because

he shot chk (which we can assume he did unless the scumteam is exactly LC/Thun) because chk was claimed as SS/Bomb combo going into the night and it’s a risky maneuver to shoot that as scum. It was a bad shot because chk was pretty obvtown at that point, but more the kind of bad shot that comes from town not understanding the game than scum imo.

I’m going to sleep on this, but that’s roughly my thought process atm.

[Bingle]

Floppy if you haven’t done so please claim your flavor.