A warlock, a werewolf, and a vampire... [Game Over]

[Lady 6]

I don't really understand g9 partnering with l3 being scummy anymore

I feel like as scum he wouldn't wanna risk partnering with someone random early on? It's pretty believable to me as a spur of the moment town decision

[Gentleman 5]

i find it hard to believe that you would place a pair as your "favorite pair" if you don't townread one of the two.

But she said she townread Lady 3 in her post

[Lady 7]

I don't really understand g9 partnering with l3 being scummy anymore

I feel like as scum he wouldn't wanna risk partnering with someone random early on? It's pretty believable to me as a spur of the moment town decision

Ye every time I re-evaluate him he ends up being more town

[Gentleman 4]

Gent 4 I have a problem with you testing the waters by saying we may need to consider me when I don't think you are able to provide much of a case for me being scum

ok, then maybe it's just L8 and you're still town.

[Gentleman 5]

I don't really understand g9 partnering with l3 being scummy anymore

I feel like as scum he wouldn't wanna risk partnering with someone random early on? It's pretty believable to me as a spur of the moment town decision

Ye every time I re-evaluate him he ends up being more town

I think it's time to let Gent 2 go

[Gentleman 2]

Shouldn't endgame:

Gentleman 9 - Lady 3
Gentleman 5 - Lady 8
Gentleman 4 - Lady 2

[Gentleman 5]

Gent 4 I have a problem with you testing the waters by saying we may need to consider me when I don't think you are able to provide much of a case for me being scum

ok, then maybe it's just L8 and you're still town.

Based on what?

The problem is you're throwing shade at me when it looks like it might pick up, but then it doesn't really and then you switch to lady 8, which is picking up

[Lady 3]

We shouldn't pretend I am ignoring this grandiose scum case and am just sitting on my hands calling them town.
Their just isn't a scum case in the first place.

pedit: sorry I didn't vote with you.

I've scumcased L4 a couple times, I know it's not grandiose and it's not the kind of stuff where I'm surprised it's not found to be compelling but I don't like the implication that I'm playing town lazily. I've given i thought; call it a bad argument not no argument.
The threshhold for what is bad enough I want to flip it is pretty low in a game where so many people seem towny

[Lady 8]

i find it hard to believe that you would place a pair as your "favorite pair" if you don't townread one of the two.

on the motivation front? It's a strategy to just OwO the way through this game with a smitten partner, while being nice and friendly and happy with everyone to make it to endgame. this involves only weakly scumreading people who are under heat at the moment, which is something that I feel like you are doing. Now another explanation is that you are easily swayed by the excellent opinions by the participants of this ball, but your reads and posts themselves seem more consensus driven than any other player in the lobby

I was excluding my own pair / the IC pair i assume. There was no pair outside of those two where I hard townread both as far as i can remember. I really dont remember why i townread you up a bit higher than the other gents

I have the benefit of reading through everyone's ISOs and finding who I like the most in hindsight now, like Gent 4 / Lady 2 i found things i somewhat like that relate to Gent 7's flip

i don't do the cuteness stuff as a strategy ;-; I guess having weak reads that mostly stay around consensus is a good point. I'm unhappy about not finding scum but I'm not super surprised i didnt

[Lady 7]

We shouldn't pretend I am ignoring this grandiose scum case and am just sitting on my hands calling them town.
Their just isn't a scum case in the first place.

pedit: sorry I didn't vote with you.

I've scumcased L4 a couple times, I know it's not grandiose and it's not the kind of stuff where I'm surprised it's not found to be compelling but I don't like the implication that I'm playing town lazily. I've given i thought; call it a bad argument not no argument.
The threshhold for what is bad enough I want to flip it is pretty low in a game where so many people seem towny

You are the exception.
It's mainly L5 who is pushing for "reasons".

[Lady 7]

VOTE: Lady 4

Fine L3 I'll place the vote for you.
Whatever let's move the game forward, even if I think this is bad.

[Gentleman 5]

We shouldn't pretend I am ignoring this grandiose scum case and am just sitting on my hands calling them town.
Their just isn't a scum case in the first place.

pedit: sorry I didn't vote with you.

I've scumcased L4 a couple times, I know it's not grandiose and it's not the kind of stuff where I'm surprised it's not found to be compelling but I don't like the implication that I'm playing town lazily. I've given i thought; call it a bad argument not no argument.
The threshhold for what is bad enough I want to flip it is pretty low in a game where so many people seem towny

You are the exception.
It's mainly L5 who is pushing for "reasons".

I think everything Gent 2 has posted in response to the push on himself can easily come from scum? Like I'm not convinced, but I'm not seeing a reason that has convinced me to town him. And people keep going back to the gent 7 stuff... maybe he's just scum and played in a different way than what you'd expect.

[Lady 7]

^ That's L-2, L-1 or the hammer I didn't check

[Gentleman 5]

Also gent 2's read on me super shallow, no?

He came into the thread, saw I was pushing him, and then tunneled based off of that.

If you're town and you're doing nothing, am I really scummy for pushing you?

[Lady 7]

Don't quote me on that but I think it was the hammer.

pedit: Meh I just think we mislynched. I don't think their is a strong town case. But I think we lack a scum case outside exactly how L4 decided to handle her read on L3. But that's a weak point at best.

The rest of the votes are votes like yours and L5's which is just POE and "I don't town read them"

[Lady 7]

Although I am not sure what I gain arguing the alignment of a now hammered set.

[Gentleman 5]

I just went back and checked, that does indeed appear to be the hammer

Gent 2, if you have any final thoughts I'm willing to hear them

[Lady 7]

My bad I should have checked first
Good night hopefully I see red in the morning but I am unsure.

[Lady 5]

Yah, that’s hammer, I can’t believe you’d steal it from me when I specially asked for it L7

[Lady 7]

I didn't want the lynch, I at least deserve the satisfaction of the hammer vote I 100% intended to place.

[Lady 6]

i really wanted g3 to post first

i think it would've been really informative

[Lady 5]

Ehh i suppose that’s kind of fair

Now I sort of do hope it flips 2 town because I swear I never get to drop the hammer when it’s on scum

[Lady 7]

Anyway time for bed.
See you all tomorrow o7

[FakeGod]

VoteCount 1.5

Gentleman 9 - Lady 3 [2] - Gentleman 2, Lady 4
Gentleman 5 - Lady 8 [0] -
Gentleman 1 - Lady 7 [0] -
Gentleman 8 - Lady 5 [1] - Gentleman 8
Gentleman 3 - Lady 6 [0] -
Gentleman 6 - Lady 1 [1] - Gentleman 4
Gentleman 4 - Lady 2 [1] - Lady 5
Gentleman 2 - Lady 4 [7] - Lady 3, Lady 6, Gentleman 9, Gentleman 5, Lady 1, Gentleman 6, Lady 7

Not Voting [4]

- Gentleman 1, Gentleman 3, Lady 2, Lady 8

With 16 alive it takes 9 votes to execute

.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2020-08-11 14:34:47)

[Lady 7]

Oops I baited so hard it confused FakeGod lol.
i thought that was L-1 though so it shows what I know.