A warlock, a werewolf, and a vampire... [Game Over]

[Lady 5]

Mine!

[Lady 5]

What did L3 and G9 argue about?

I think G9 scumslipped but dannflor didn't think it was a scumslip and now dannflor is gonebyebye

Can you run me through what you think the scumslip was pls?

[Lady 5]

don't have more than one tab open on mafiascum at a time i figured out that's a way you could altslip

Just change the theme

I’m finding maf!tiger to be very nice tbh

[Lady 5]

Do you think (G5-G3) or (G3-L2) make any sense as scum together?

[Lady 3]

L7blue
L6dewgong
G5boromir
G3sherlock
G4tennis
G9banana
L2rosa
G6bowler
L1cry
L8ghos
G1nagito

G3sherlock is underwhelming just now
I only feel strongly about my top 2 reads

[Lady 3]

What did L3 and G9 argue about?

I think G9 scumslipped but dannflor didn't think it was a scumslip and now dannflor is gonebyebye

Can you run me through what you think the scumslip was pls?

He suggested us leaving the dance, talking about it as though it were an act of teamwork. But it doesn't work like that, he should be thinking of me as an opponent if he were considering leaving the dance.

L1ghost has done almost the same thing in the game thread now
it seems like a perspective slip while LAMISTing to me

[Lady 3]

Do you think (G5-G3) or (G3-L2) make any sense as scum together?

uh I'm not that good with this kind of stuff

G3 is trying to PoE L2 out right now which would be credless partner loss??

G5-G3 makes lots of sense since he opened up the game whaling on L8 when she had too much towncred to actually die from it.

[Lady 5]

I’m not sure I get what you mean when you say “talking as though it were an act of teamwork”?

[Lady 3]

he said for us to like both leave

instead of like "i'm going to leave because I think you're scum"

and later he made it into this PoE thing but I still don't like it

[Lady 5]

Do you think (G5-G3) or (G3-L2) make any sense as scum together?

uh I'm not that good with this kind of stuff

G3 is trying to PoE L2 out right now which would be credless partner loss??

G5-G3 makes lots of sense since he opened up the game whaling on L8 when she had too much towncred to actually die from it.

Okay, this is all useful, thanks! I think I wanna y’all a bit more with G8 in the PT before I out anything more about this

[Lady 5]

he said for us to like both leave

instead of like "i'm going to leave because I think you're scum"

and later he made it into this PoE thing but I still don't like it

Who is his PoE and when did you fall into it? Also can you point me to -roughly- where he talks about this in thread

Approximate page range would be fine

[Lady 5]

Also, if we pretend that I was the great dictator for a second, and I said we were evicting either G5-L8 today or G3-L6 who would you choose to leave/who would you choose to stay and why?

I’m not saying those are who I want to leave, but I’m not saying they aren’t either

[Gentleman 5]

Don't leave. I'm going to towncase you tomorrow.

speaking of which, i would like to hear gentleman 5's town case for lady 8 too

I will towncase her tomorrow. Ladies 1 and 8.

Lady 8

Spoiler:

towny tone

[Lady 3]

PoE isn't the right word. It was this if not X then Y thing of if we don't find scum our pair should go

[Lady 3]

page 145

[Gentleman 5]

Lady 8 has thoughts about the game that feel real, and that don't seem to have an agenda attached. When you play as the mafia in this setup, you need to scumread other pairs to justify keeping your own pair alive. Lady 8 tends to townread a lot of people (which is also where I'm at) and has pairings to make it to the end which doesn't include our pair. And has extras that she needs to sort through on top of that, it's not how I expect scum to play the setup.

As I mentioned, I've been thinking the same things as her/agreeing with her as well. And that makes me trust her more as well - she has a lot of good opinions, and I don't expect scum to emulate that as effectively.

The counterargument to the above points would be that she is simply trying to appear as town for the finale. I don't think the way she is going about this game is indicative of that, though.

She reads as genuine to me in the pt, including frustrations with people criticizing the way she plays, which feels genuine (lady 1 also did this).

Reading her posts since dance start, there's nothing that makes me believe she is scum, only things that are neutral, and things which seem town indicative. And posts with good tone.

I don't think not having strong stances is scummy here because she is discussing things and this game state is hard and it makes sense, and scum can just force reads anyway - there's no reason to keep waffling when it's drawing the ire of other players.

[Gentleman 8]

L7blue
L6dewgong
G5boromir
G3sherlock
G4tennis
G9banana
L2rosa
G6bowler
L1cry
L8ghos
G1nagito

G3sherlock is underwhelming just now
I only feel strongly about my top 2 reads

uh...

hmmm...

my first thought when reading this list was "where's lady 3, she's pretty town" and then i was like "oh... oh, yeah, that makes sense"

... this is who you have as confirmed town in this game. does this depress you?

[Lady 3]

That's a confusing question and now I'm wondering how accurately I could read myself in a game if someone used the MIB flashy thingy to make me forget playing in a game and then I read it.
I guess I would have 1 more townread if I was not one of the most active posters who has managed transparency this game. I would probably have another townread ontop of that if you weren't confirmed, with as much energy as you've played the game with.

I don't think I usually find unsolved games depressing though? It just means it's more challenging. Like one of my favorites was this game where I kept missing as doctor and every dayphase felt like wandering the desert to find scum, but we finally found them at the very end and that made it all the more gratifying.

[Lady 5]

G8 and I would strongly prefer that no wagon go beyond L2 until we’ve both reappeared in thread

[Lady 5]

Can you hit me back on 4011 misty?

[Lady 3]

VOTE: Lady 9

[Lady 3]

I'd rather make L8 leave than L6

[Lady 3]

L6 is hard town so G3 just has to catch up somehow to be a good last pair (or I'm smarter than everyone and you're making me doubt my smartness and it was always a great last pair)

G5 and L8 are each shaky

[Gentleman 5]

Why am I shaky?

[Gentleman 5]

Why is L8 shaky?