In post 3331, Galron wrote: In post 3259, Logicalicaltist wrote: In post 3258, Vecna wrote:LogicalCaltist, did you ever get notified that you were roleblocked N1? What response did you get from the GM the night you tracked Alchemist?
“There were no results from the tracking.”
I still think this is an awkward quote from the mod. So in that vein, it supports a scum!Logicalist. I can see a scum!Logic covering for a scum!Thun/Adorable. That "quote" just sticks out like a bee sting. And the Thun/Adorable transition was awkward. It certainly satisfies that Occam test.
It doesn't account for A50's death though, and that's where Vecna's theory makes sense. And I don't hear anyone claiming to have vigged him, unless chk did.
Case A: LC is actually a tracker. The phrasing is odd, but probably originates from the mod.
Case B: LC is not actually a tracker. LC is scum with specifically scum with Thun.
Case B is very low risk for town because both slots are independently highly scumread and still likely nightkills so their continued survival would only continue raising eyebrows.
chk provably didn't vig A50. His role only triggered if he was the elimination and the mod confirmed that. He was nightkilled, and was likely fakeclaiming his role to try to dodge a nk from scum. Given setup information, if Thun isn't a vig, it's almost 100% that one kill was the result of A50's N1 target and one kill was the result of the scum kill.
Further, if Thun/LC is the scumteam, we're missing a significant amount of town power.
2 Masons
Cop
JK
V
Uninformed Scum Traitor with a poisonous fruit vend
1 shot Novice Vig (a low estimate of TL's flipped role)
2x Goon
would be scumsided in a 16p, even without Alch's role (which was almost certainly balanced as an ascetic survivor). Conversely, scum only having 3 people would be pretty weak against the flipped town power, and one of LC/Thun would have to be town anyway.
