A warlock, a werewolf, and a vampire... [Game Over]

[Gentleman 5]

There are significantly more town players than there are scum players, so analyzing town players not being able to wagon people isn't a good case

[Lady 8]

Please for the love of god don't let Lady 3's third replacement leave Gent 9. If they're around in second intermission I'm like 90% sure that scum needs to make them leave to win

[Gentleman 5]

I have literally been beating that drum all day

Keep up the good work gent 6

[Gentleman 6]

The drum ran into my knife...

The drum ran into my knife ten times.

[Gentleman 4]

I mean we already have two T-T pairings. L3-G9 is not one of them IMO(yet)

[Gentleman 5]

I mean we already have two T-T pairings.

Who are your two T-T pairings?

[Gentleman 4]

you say that like it's a good thing

well you have been a pretty good ic, so it is good.

[Gentleman 8]

My pair next? Am I understating your post correctly?

her thoughts were basically

gentleman 5 and lady 8, then...

if gentleman 5 were to flip scum, go gentleman 1/lady 7 -> lady 1 / gentleman 6 -> lady 6 / gentleman 3 -> gentleman 4 / lady 2

if gentleman 5 were to flip town, go gentleman 4 / lady 2 -> gentleman 1 / lady 7 -> lady 6 / gentleman 3 -> lady 1 / gentleman 6

(but the gentleman 1 order in that is purely because i've been talking a bit about how i don't really trust the gentleman 1 slot, and she is trusting that i think i am onto something when i don't actually think i'm anywhere near as strong as i'd like to be there lol)

(also i think part of the reason she wants to flip gentleman 5 / lady 8 is pure paranoia that no one else is going to want to do it after intermission regardless of who's flipped before intermission)

[Gentleman 8]

ive just been saying i didn't really like gentleman 1 v1 (or at least i didnt see anything particularly town in his play) and i have difficulties reading players like gentleman 1 v2 because nothing they say makes much sense to me and i can't really determine the motivation if i can't really understand the thought processes in the first place

though if people think he's town i'd like to hear why

[Lady 3]

Please for the love of god don't let Lady 3's third replacement leave Gent 9. If they're around in second intermission I'm like 90% sure that scum needs to make them leave to win

time for me to make like a tree and

Spoiler:

read the game

[Gentleman 4]

though if people think he's town i'd like to hear why

I think he's town because he seems enthusiastic about what he is saying and he seems like he believes in his reads. This is very townie especially since people think he's a newer player.

[Lady 3]

which i'll probably do later when i have more time!
anyone down to help me catch up? someone other than g8 would be slightly preferred please.

[Gentleman 6]

Yet another traumatic replace-in post.

[Gentleman 5]

His read*

He has one of those

[Lady 8]

Hi Lady 3 #3.

it's nice to meet you again

[Lady 3]

i aim to please. or traumatize. or both. whatever.

pedit: thank you, nice to re-meet you too !

[Gentleman 5]

though if people think he's town i'd like to hear why

I think he's town because he seems enthusiastic about what he is saying and he seems like he believes in his reads. This is very townie especially since people think he's a newer player.

I don't agree with these post in general

[Gentleman 5]

this

[Lady 3]

can you show us why you think he's scum please?

[Gentleman 4]

but why? I thought that was a good way to read players like G1.

[Gentleman 5]

I don't, really, I'm pretty neutral/willing to follow other peoples reads there. I think the reasoning Gent 4 is using is bad

[Gentleman 5]

but why? I thought that was a good way to read players like G1.

"He believes what he is saying" How do we know that?
"He believes his reads" He only has one and it's not a very good one
"People think he's a new player" That doesn't really matter

[Lady 3]

sure, i respect that.
do you think g4 is scum or just wrong?

[Gentleman 5]

sure, i respect that.
do you think g4 is scum or just wrong?

I think he's definitely suspicious.

[Lady 8]

I somewhat like Gent 1's effort post more than Gent 6's effort posts, I want to say the tunnelyness is harder to fake than Gent 6 mostly giving uncontroversial reads. It isn't bad posting by either but I think I could probably fake Gent 6's easier as scum

But I still flip flop on that. At the same time, Gent 6 has posts that make me like him for town. Smh

Regardling Gent 4 / Lady 2, I think Gent 4 is more likely to be the town in his pair with Lady 2 possibly being scum. I don't have a scumcase though. They're collectively the lowest pair in my reads (4068) and Lady 2 is one of three players at the bottom

Lady 2 was here for the first 2/3rds of the game but not the last 1/3rd. I don't have a read on her. Gent 4 is below some other Gents but not all.