Redneck Mafia GAME OVER PARTNER!

[Elsa Jay]

Paranoid Gun Owner. It's on the tin. I'm the variant that always alerts, so I mentioned Compulsive earlier to explain it.

I am not at my desk, can you name players that voiced increased suspicion of you after that claim?

Besides Titus voting me, nobody's really cared. Even Titus moved back to Vecna.

[DrippingGoofball]

The scum presumably can't NK you, so they'd have to pursue you during the day.

[DrippingGoofball]

And since no one is really pursuing you during the day... maybe it's because you're the scum.

[DrippingGoofball]

Your fakeclaim were what, vig? Covers him a scum NK if tracked.
And Miller? Covers up a cop guilty.
Goo? Townies won't target you.
PGO? No one would target you.

[DrippingGoofball]

Reading your posts, the claim comes out as semi-believable.

[Elsa Jay]

The Vig thing was so I could meme with Alch about shooing him night 1 again. It's kinda our thing. Literally only said Miller once as a hypothetical before Titus made me claim. Goo was me telling Townies not to visit me, and to let people know Alch was Gold Goo. PGO is my real role.

Ignoring me like everyone elsa is for the best.

[DrippingGoofball]

Ignoring me like everyone elsa is for the best.

I don't like this last bit.

VOTE: Elsa Jay

[Elsa Jay]

Well it's the truth, especially when I'm offering to get shot by the Vigilante. Or did you forget that?

[DrippingGoofball]

Of course I forget, I'm going to be 55.

[Elsa Jay]

I forget things too and I ain't even 25. That's no excuse.

[Vecna]

Paranoid Gun Owner. It's on the tin. I'm the variant that always alerts, so I mentioned Compulsive earlier to explain it.

I am not at my desk, can you name players that voiced increased suspicion of you after that claim?

Besides Titus voting me, nobody's really cared. Even Titus moved back to Vecna.

you felt I didnt care huh?

[Vecna]

Well it's the truth, especially when I'm offering to get shot by the Vigilante. Or did you forget that?

offering to kill two townies, did you even think that through at all?

that means if we mislynch the game could be over after today

[Elsa Jay]

Yeah I realized that afterwards, but it's the thought that counts?

[Vecna]

sounds more the type of thing scum thinks theyll get townread over, while they dont recognize the huge flaw in the thought

[Elsa Jay]

Well from my perspective it was more "people don't trust me or the Vigi so getting rid of 2 birds with one stone will be nice."

[Bingle]

Do you want to waste your time on that?

Pass. If someone who is not you asks, sure, but attempting to convince you that you're scum is a waste of time. Either you're scum, and you know I'm right, or you're town and you know I'm wrong. (Also, your post= tags are borked and go to the OP, JSYK.)

I will say for the benefit of the thread that the context of the votes IS something I took into account. For example, the TLich unvote/revote was:

TLich claims, Gal unvotes, DGB laughs at the claim, Pooky laughs at the claim, chk laughs at the claim, Gal hammers. That's pretty much the point. He hammered as soon as he saw the town response was "laugh at claim" and knew that TLich was a sinking ship.

Similarly the Froppy unvote.

Spoiler:

VOTE: Froppy

E-1

That's the opposite of letting someone catch up.

I read up to page 112 so far. On page 1 it says TL is red and I'm at the part where TL is being wagoned. I'm town reading Bingle since he is the one who made a case on TL and has been after this slot wanting it to get lynched. The Pooky and DGB confirming each other confused me and I didn't understand that part and it looks like Alchemist didn't get confirmed.

It's been so tempting to lolhammer

I think that it is almost poe so if this is the route people want to take then I think we should quit stalling.

UNVOTE:

UNVOTE:

What, in this sequence, caused you to learn something, Gal? Why did you put the fresh replacement at E-1 in the first place if you were hoping for a catchup?

[Bingle]

that means if we mislynch the game could be over after today

This is the type of little thing that makes me think Vecna is town, btw.

We have 9 alive. In order for a reasonable "We die tonight" scenario, there have to be at least 5 town deaths. If there can still be 5 town deaths after flipping 2 scum killing roles, this was never really a game. Scum Vecna is 100% aware of that, but the statement looks natural to me.


I'm also not opposed to the EJ wagon. It's probably slightly better mechanically

because

Adorable can't shoot there. My gut does say that Gal is the scum and EJ is town though, FWIW.

[DrippingGoofball]

sounds more the type of thing scum thinks theyll get townread over, while they dont recognize the huge flaw in the thought

yes

[DrippingGoofball]

that means if we mislynch the game could be over after today

This is the type of little thing that makes me think Vecna is town, btw.

We have 9 alive. In order for a reasonable "We die tonight" scenario, there have to be at least 5 town deaths. If there can still be 5 town deaths after flipping 2 scum killing roles, this was never really a game. Scum Vecna is 100% aware of that, but the statement looks natural to me.


I'm also not opposed to the EJ wagon. It's probably slightly better mechanically

because

Adorable can't shoot there. My gut does say that Gal is the scum and EJ is town though, FWIW.

Your post was pretty convincing I must reckon.

[Adorable]

I guess this is better than no lynch, but I really haven't had the time to get comfortable yet.

VOTE: Icerint

VOTE: Lavender

Let's make it interesting.

VOTE: Gobble

VOTE: Lavender

Time's running out.

Galron and Elsa both have made votes that were not explained. These quotes above are examples and I'm asking here what made you guys vote these players since they were not explained. I see that you both have been hopping on wagons on day 1, day 2, and day 3.

I'm going to kind of defend Elsa here I guess without looking at the actual votes and say that this is lame. Day 1 of a large is a free for all. No one knows anything for sure except their own role. I'm pretty sure when I repped in we were under deadline pressure, and Iecerint and Lavender both were decent wagons, although wrong. I unvoted Iecerint to vote Lavender to tie them up if I recall correctly. Both wagons were wrong. That means, what, exactly?

You said day 1 of a large is a free for all and I don't know what you mean by this.

[The Baker]

Vote Count 4.04

Galron (1): Bingle
Elsa Jay (1): DrippingGoofball
Vecna (1): Titus
Bingle (1): Vecna
Not Voting (5): Alchemist21, Froppy, Elsa Jay, Adorable, Galron

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to blast someone!
Day Four ends on Thursday, August 27th at 2:00pm EST in (expired on 2020-08-27 14:00:00)

[Froppy]

I guess this is better than no lynch, but I really haven't had the time to get comfortable yet.

VOTE: Icerint

VOTE: Lavender

Let's make it interesting.

VOTE: Gobble

VOTE: Lavender

Time's running out.

Galron and Elsa both have made votes that were not explained. These quotes above are examples and I'm asking here what made you guys vote these players since they were not explained. I see that you both have been hopping on wagons on day 1, day 2, and day 3.

I'm going to kind of defend Elsa here I guess without looking at the actual votes and say that this is lame. Day 1 of a large is a free for all. No one knows anything for sure except their own role. I'm pretty sure when I repped in we were under deadline pressure, and Iecerint and Lavender both were decent wagons, although wrong. I unvoted Iecerint to vote Lavender to tie them up if I recall correctly. Both wagons were wrong. That means, what, exactly?

You said day 1 of a large is a free for all and I don't know what you mean by this.

Is it bad that I kind of get town vibes from it. I don't see scum!galron defending elsa when Galron is under the gun.

[Bingle]

Why not? Do you think Galron's defense is going to convince anyone. More importantly, do you think Galron thinks his defense is going to convince anyone?

[Adorable]

I guess this is better than no lynch, but I really haven't had the time to get comfortable yet.

VOTE: Icerint

VOTE: Lavender

Let's make it interesting.

VOTE: Gobble

VOTE: Lavender

Time's running out.

Galron and Elsa both have made votes that were not explained. These quotes above are examples and I'm asking here what made you guys vote these players since they were not explained. I see that you both have been hopping on wagons on day 1, day 2, and day 3.

I'm going to kind of defend Elsa here I guess without looking at the actual votes and say that this is lame. Day 1 of a large is a free for all. No one knows anything for sure except their own role. I'm pretty sure when I repped in we were under deadline pressure, and Iecerint and Lavender both were decent wagons, although wrong. I unvoted Iecerint to vote Lavender to tie them up if I recall correctly. Both wagons were wrong. That means, what, exactly?

You said day 1 of a large is a free for all and I don't know what you mean by this.

Is it bad that I kind of get town vibes from it. I don't see scum!galron defending elsa when Galron is under the gun.

I think what Galron meant was he was talking about day 1 and not about the current day phase we are in. When I iso Galron I saw he voted Elsa on day 2 and during this day phase he said he has Elsa on his poe pool.

[Vecna]

that means if we mislynch the game could be over after today

This is the type of little thing that makes me think Vecna is town, btw.

We have 9 alive. In order for a reasonable "We die tonight" scenario, there have to be at least 5 town deaths. If there can still be 5 town deaths after flipping 2 scum killing roles, this was never really a game. Scum Vecna is 100% aware of that, but the statement looks natural to me.


I'm also not opposed to the EJ wagon. It's probably slightly better mechanically

because

Adorable can't shoot there. My gut does say that Gal is the scum and EJ is town though, FWIW.

....?

You even reading what was being talked about?

Mislynch = 1
Townvig shooting town pgo = 2
scum killing DGB = 1
Scum getting extra nightkill due to DGB death = 1

No scum ability except the NK involved.

This is the type of post why I think bingle is scum. He doesnt care about the contents about what he's commenting on. He just grabs a person he doesnt need mislynched, and finds reasons that make no sense from a town pov to format further reasons for his townread.