I think he's supposed to mitigate the power scum had with multiple ways to kill. I also don't think the mods really considered him claiming D1 and he was supposed to be a hidden landmine for scum to operate around.In post 3623, Vecna wrote:In fact, half the abilities that would let you win and leave the game are killing abilities
This doesn't preclude any theory that his wincon is anti-town, of course.In post 3624, Galron wrote:This makes me think Alchemist is not scum. After all that stuff we went through with Lavender post-flip with chkflip detailing how he knew Lavender town-told because of the rolecard label, this looks like a non-scum tell to me.In post 45, Alchemist21 wrote:Actually double checking my original PM I don’t think it was meant to be Town in the first place. The area box is labeled 3p but the wincon at the bottom was the Town wincon and I confirmed as a Hillbilly Absorber.
So it was more likely a mod error in my original role PM.
I'd go Elsa but not Vecna at this point. The point about the 4-5 p massacre seems unlikely but valid. The best way to avoid that would be to remove either the claimed PGO or the claimed 3P. I really don't believe Elsa's claim anyway. It makes more sense for a PGO to claim early on than Day 4. The way it happened was severely anti-town.In post 3626, Titus wrote:I kinda want to vote Vecna even if there's a decent chance he is the townbeard. He defended both scum lynches and now he's all protesting as if pinned down.
Im just trying to find the last scum, as you tried to claim you would.In post 3626, Titus wrote:I kinda want to vote Vecna even if there's a decent chance he is the townbeard. He defended both scum lynches and now he's all protesting as if pinned down.
I don't like claiming early.In post 3628, Galron wrote:I'd go Elsa but not Vecna at this point. The point about the 4-5 p massacre seems unlikely but valid. The best way to avoid that would be to remove either the claimed PGO or the claimed 3P. I really don't believe Elsa's claim anyway. It makes more sense for a PGO to claim early on than Day 4. The way it happened was severely anti-town.In post 3626, Titus wrote:I kinda want to vote Vecna even if there's a decent chance he is the townbeard. He defended both scum lynches and now he's all protesting as if pinned down.
I still haven't read most of the game so could you show me town stuff that you have done that.In post 3629, Vecna wrote:Im just trying to find the last scum, as you tried to claim you would.In post 3626, Titus wrote:I kinda want to vote Vecna even if there's a decent chance he is the townbeard. He defended both scum lynches and now he's all protesting as if pinned down.
But keep voting me even though you know im town.
?In post 3611, Galron wrote:Although I don't know that the Bingle is among the last scum(s). My pool is still Elsa, Alchemist and Adorable. But with everyone saying Adorable can confirm herself so we're not touching her, and leave Alchemist alone too, that narrows it down to Elsa.
Titus, why do you want to go Vecna?
Titus is not trying to find scum, Titus is just looking to park her vote somewhere.In post 3629, Vecna wrote:Im just trying to find the last scum, as you tried to claim you would.
That's where I have been for awhile.In post 3633, Bingle wrote:NGL, I'd throw my support behind anything I think has a chance to flip scum if a wagon showed up. I feel like we've been talking in circles for days and we're to mired in that tedium to really have incredible insights right now. At least a flip would give us something new to go off of, even if it isn't scum.
In post 1048, TemporalLich wrote:I'm trying to say liminating the 3p will leave us in a worse position, we lose a potential townsider for no real gain in info, and I'm pretty sure scum A50 doesn't admit he's scum
pedit: If he's been defensive before as well, I can put Doctor Drew off the radar as my scumcase doesn't go any deeper than him scumslipping
In post 1072, TemporalLich wrote:ah, so NAI and should not be factoring into my read on him then...
well yeah, I was trying to have a good scumcase in D1 so we can get past D1 and I don't think eliminating the 3P is the best idea
In post 1078, TemporalLich wrote:give me ascumcase on Alchemist then, don't just tell me he's 3p and I should vote him
Eliminating a trueclaiming alchemist is bad for the town info-wise
I think someone may have already pulled these quotes, but as I was going through Drew's ISO, I got sidetracked and started reading TLich. This hard defense of Alchemist doesn't look good for Alch, although I maintain Alch has to be a 3P based on that rolecard post.In post 1079, TemporalLich wrote:I really feel like you're looking like you're tunneling Alchemist, just because you're mechtown doesn't mean the possibility of Pooky being a fakeclaimer is off the table completely
Please take a number.In post 3637, Titus wrote:At least my death will likely be fast so I don't have to read DGB's posts anymore.
Lady, this is an Arby's.In post 3641, Elsa Jay wrote:Give me as many chicken nuggets as legally possible.
Please advance to the cash window.In post 3640, Alchemist21 wrote:I'll take a #9, large fries, large coke no ice.
You picked the roast beef restaurant. Drat. If you had picked any other one I had a good chance.In post 3642, DrippingGoofball wrote:Lady, this is an Arby's.In post 3641, Elsa Jay wrote:Give me as many chicken nuggets as legally possible.
We have to do it.In post 3638, Galron wrote:This hard defense of Alchemist doesn't look good for Alch