Large Normal 229 | Manatee's Musical Mafia | Game Over

[NorwegianboyEE]

Find me a scumgame where i’m this engaged and active.
You can’t, i left my scumrange a long time ago.

That wasn't the question. You said you're more town than you've ever been before. How are you being more towny than previously?

It was just a figure of speech. Don’t be so overly picky.

[Nero Cain]

in fairness, a50 is prob town. MM's posting is wonky and I keep going back and forth on them but he seems like the kind of player that will town read mostly scum and scum read all town but he'll still be right sometimes b/c its almost nearly impossible to have no correct town reads.

[SJReaver]

It was just a figure of speech. Don’t be so overly picky.

It was just a question. Don't be so overly defensive.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

A50: A50's case is bad and unconvincing, but not scummy; in fact, I townread him now

Someone’s case is completely shit and you TR them for it?

More or less, yes! I just don't see the scum intent behind the case against you. Scum!A50, given his level of experience, can't seriously believe that he will convince town to mislynch town!Norwee by saying what he said; therefore, it has to come from a town mindset.

[NorwegianboyEE]

It was just a figure of speech. Don’t be so overly picky.

It was just a question. Don't be so overly defensive.

Ok i’ll just not respond to you then.

[SJReaver]

It was just a figure of speech. Don’t be so overly picky.

It was just a question. Don't be so overly defensive.

Ok i’ll just not respond to you then.

I'm going to guess this is another "figure of speech" as your ability to not respond to others is microscopic.

[NorwegianboyEE]

A50: A50's case is bad and unconvincing, but not scummy; in fact, I townread him now

Someone’s case is completely shit and you TR them for it?

More or less, yes! I just don't see the scum intent behind the case against you. Scum!A50, given his level of experience, can't seriously believe that he will convince town to mislynch town!Norwee by saying what he said; therefore, it has to come from a town mindset.

Have you ever heard of "Burden of Proficiency"?

[Marshmallow Marshall]

in fairness, a50 is prob town. MM's posting is wonky and I keep going back and forth on them but he seems like the kind of player that will town read mostly scum and scum read all town but he'll still be right sometimes b/c its almost nearly impossible to have no correct town reads.

Would I be asking too much if I were to ask you to stop calling me a shit player 2/3 times you address me because I don't agree with you? Like seriously, fuck off lol, that's chlidish

[Nero Cain]

More or less, yes! I just don't see the scum intent behind the case against you. Scum!A50, given his level of experience, can't seriously believe that he will convince town to mislynch town!Norwee by saying what he said; therefore, it has to come from a town mindset.

even though I'm kinda town reading a50 now this is shit reasoning. But I'm a little confused here. If a50 is town and (i know you don't think norway is town but for the sake of the argument) norway is town, who are the scum on his wagon?


lol @ the idea of BOPing a50.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

A50: A50's case is bad and unconvincing, but not scummy; in fact, I townread him now

Someone’s case is completely shit and you TR them for it?

More or less, yes! I just don't see the scum intent behind the case against you. Scum!A50, given his level of experience, can't seriously believe that he will convince town to mislynch town!Norwee by saying what he said; therefore, it has to come from a town mindset.

Have you ever heard of "Burden of Proficiency"?

I think I see where you're going with this, but I don't agree. I'm not saying A50 is a wise old man, I'm just saying he's out of the "relatively new to the game" zone, and that's enough for me to think he can't believe he would convince anyone to lynch you over what he said.

[SJReaver]

More or less, yes! I just don't see the scum intent behind the case against you. Scum!A50, given his level of experience, can't seriously believe that he will convince town to mislynch town!Norwee by saying what he said; therefore, it has to come from a town mindset.

This is a viewpoint I can appreciate. The few times I've read posts that seemed like schizoid paranoia, the posters were townies.

[NorwegianboyEE]

If a50 is town and (i know you don't think norway is town but for the sake of the argument) norway is town, who are the scum on his wagon?

Not convinced about A50 but this is a good question.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

VC1.17

With 21 alive it takes 11 to eliminate

Almost50 (5):

NorwegianboyEE, 72offsuit, Titus, JacksonVirgo, NoPowerOverMe

NorwegianboyEE (3):

Almost50, stan1ey, Glitch

Lapsa (2):

ralph217, Nero Cain

72offsuit (2):

, Fwesnid, superbowl9

NoPowerOverME (2):

Hiraki, Pickaxe Pete

Fwesnid (1):

Marshmallow Marshall

Not Voting (6):

[Lapsa], [Alisae], Town looter, Bell, I Keep Siteflaking, SJReaver

Deadline:

FROZEN

Mod Notes:

1. searching for a replacement for Lapsa & Alisae
   
2. 2006 will not be counted as I cant decypher who the intended target is

@Nero Cain

Nice discredit again

Only looking at my individual reads on each A50 voter, Offsuit and maybe Titus would be scum here (Titus being a pretty inactive and low-content slot).

I'm seeing NoPowerOverMe in the list and am thinking that they are pretty unlikely to be scum, given the interaction with Norwee. Either Norwee is town like I originally thought and is telling the truth about NoPower playing in their meta (which makes sense), or Norwee is scum and he's telling the truth to pocket NoPower. I don't see scum!Norwee protecting scum!NoPower that openly (see early D1).

[Marshmallow Marshall]

More or less, yes! I just don't see the scum intent behind the case against you. Scum!A50, given his level of experience, can't seriously believe that he will convince town to mislynch town!Norwee by saying what he said; therefore, it has to come from a town mindset.

This is a viewpoint I can appreciate.

The few times I've read posts that seemed like schizoid paranoia, the posters were townies.

Exactly.

[Nero Cain]

Nice discredit again

THANK YOU! I wrote it myself

[Marshmallow Marshall]

More or less, yes! I just don't see the scum intent behind the case against you. Scum!A50, given his level of experience, can't seriously believe that he will convince town to mislynch town!Norwee by saying what he said; therefore, it has to come from a town mindset.

even though I'm kinda town reading a50 now this is shit reasoning. But I'm a little confused here. If a50 is town and (i know you don't think norway is town but for the sake of the argument) norway is town, who are the scum on his wagon?


lol @ the idea of BOPing a50.

Why are

you

townread A50, if my reasoning is so shitty, btw?

[Nero Cain]

I think his reaction to getting wagoned and raging @ me is somethng that a50 has done in the past. I can certianly get manipulated but yeah...

[Nero Cain]

schizoid paranoia

this isn't really the impression that I got through. I got more of a Made for tv movie villain. His case on Norway was just so basic and generic. My first thought was "okay how can this guy be town and so bad.?"

[Marshmallow Marshall]

townread

ing*

I think his reaction to getting wagoned and raging @ me is somethng that a50 has done in the past. I can certianly get manipulated but yeah...

I just checked his ISO, and I would not call what he did "raging" at all, just defending himself (and even then, he didn't defend himself vehemently).

[NorwegianboyEE]

His defense was meh but i could chalk that up to town or scum. It’s the way he’s attacking me that’s pinging me. It was so bad. And yet he’s not self-aware sboit it at all, which is scummy.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I don’t scumread players that say i’m mafia if their reasoning is genuine, but A50’s "read" on me is a joke.

[NorwegianboyEE]

And i don’t see how Nero Cain is scummy and should be "vigged" either.

[Nero Cain]

hence rage

[Nero Cain]

im off his lawn though so I hope he chills out

[superbowl9]

I find it difficult to believe scum would be given a night 3 or day 4 ability, but that's an opinion from an uninformed person (I think this is like my second closed setup ever played - most of my games have been newbies)

There are definitely two different styles or approaches or whatever you want to call it in this game.

There's the Stanley/Glitch/TL approach, and the Nero/Hiraki/NBoyEE approach. I wouldn't say one is more or less scummy in the context of this game, they are just different. That said, I know I have a bias here and am probably over TRing the former, and over SRing the latter.

1 of these things is not like the other why is hiraki in there?