Newbie 2029—Ancient Arthropods {Game Over}

[The Bulge]

Votecount 1.12

Goticaris longispinosa

notscience

{2}

- osuka, PlusJOYED.

osuka

{4}

- herrcombs, Norfolk Boy1, notscience, Random Canadian.

{E-1}

Noraa

{1}

- wizardastronaut.

PlusJOYED

{1}

- UneducatedGuesser.

Not voting {1}

- Noraa.

Votes needed to Eliminate:

{5}

. Deadline for Day 1 is Saturday, September 19 at 5:46 pm EDT, or in (expired on 2020-09-19 17:46:00).

[UneducatedGuesser]

If Wiz, as the only other person in the thread who is...

a) not voting for Osuka
and b) hasn't posted since Osuka's claim (Noraa, Plus and myself all have)

... has a valid cc to Osuka, I'm of the opinion they should hammer without outing exactly what role they have.

This obviously only applies if their role is one of the ones that can't coexist with Osuka-as-tracker in any possible setup (cop, mason, or tracker himself)

Follow-on from that is that if Wiz is a mason with someone they shouldn't out themselves or him.

This way, if we're in the A or C parts of the setup, the remaining scum doesn't get to know exactly what role he has and what the exact setup is.

This applies to exactly him and him only, given the scenario. (since the only other people who haven't checked into the thread since the claim are already on the wagon)

[herrcombs]

Checking in, I saw the claim.

[Noraa]

Alright I think a few people voting osuka need to back off and unvote for now. otherwise we give scum the opportunity to "accidentally hammer" which btw if anyone does that I am gonna SR u to hell and back if osuka flips green

[notscience]

UNVOTE:

It’s suicide for scum to accidentally hammer and town wouldn’t after all this excitement, but for peace of mind I will.

[Noraa]

UNVOTE:

It’s suicide for scum to accidentally hammer and town wouldn’t after all this excitement, but for peace of mind I will.

thank you

[Noraa]

No ones really doing anything rn so I might as well ask my questions while nothing important's happening. How do I make my signature automatically attach? Or do I need to manually attach it to each and every post?

[Noraa]

I just figured it out. so for anyone that wants to know as well, its
user control panel
board preferences
edit posting defaults
attach signature to every post

[notscience]

We’re waiting for anyone to CC. If no one does we’ll find a new wagon.

[Random Canadian]

So just Wiz and Norfolk haven't said anything yet post claim?

UNVOTE:

[Noraa]

So just Wiz and Norfolk haven't said anything yet post claim?

UNVOTE:

thank you as well. lol I get so much anxiety that we'll end up limming a pr. its proven that its possible lol. my first game, plus, our fn was limmed d1(although I was scum that game lmaoo but still)

[wizardastronaut]

Do mafia here typically choose to claim Friendly Neighbor if in column A, Tracker/Jailkeeper if in column B, and Doctor/Tracker if in column C? (To maximize their probability of their being no counterclaim? E.g., in column A, row 2 gives Jailkeeper & Tracker. Neither of them are able to CC a Friendly.)

[Noraa]

Do mafia here typically choose to claim Friendly Neighbor if in column A, Tracker/Jailkeeper if in column B, and Doctor/Tracker if in column C? (To maximize their probability of their being no counterclaim? E.g., in column A, row 2 gives Jailkeeper & Tracker. Neither of them are able to CC a Friendly.)

no idea but my partner last round claimed doctor when we were in column b setup

[PlusJOYED]

Do mafia here typically choose to claim Friendly Neighbor if in column A, Tracker/Jailkeeper if in column B, and Doctor/Tracker if in column C? (To maximize their probability of their being no counterclaim? E.g., in column A, row 2 gives Jailkeeper & Tracker. Neither of them are able to CC a Friendly.)

no idea but my partner last round claimed doctor when we were in column b setup

>:(

[notscience]

Do mafia here typically choose to claim Friendly Neighbor if in column A, Tracker/Jailkeeper if in column B, and Doctor/Tracker if in column C? (To maximize their probability of their being no counterclaim? E.g., in column A, row 2 gives Jailkeeper & Tracker. Neither of them are able to CC a Friendly.)

My recent game when I was mafia I decided to claim tracker in setup b if run up. I’d either out the good pr with no protective, have a jk/tfn who both thought I could be real or be fucked. Candidly. I planned to argue down if I got cc’d by a tracker

[Noraa]

Do mafia here typically choose to claim Friendly Neighbor if in column A, Tracker/Jailkeeper if in column B, and Doctor/Tracker if in column C? (To maximize their probability of their being no counterclaim? E.g., in column A, row 2 gives Jailkeeper & Tracker. Neither of them are able to CC a Friendly.)

no idea but my partner last round claimed doctor when we were in column b setup

>:(

bahaha that's my favorite face out of all the faces that I use. apologies plus. accept a virtual apology huggie?

[Norfolk Boy1]

UNVOTE:

I believe Osuka's claim and clearly had a bad read on him.

[notscience]

VOTE: joyed

Back to this

[Noraa]

Oh wait I just realized that I haven't yet commented what I think on his claim. Alright so I thought Osuka seemed a bit scummy bc of the astronaut wagon thing. It might've been a joke but it kinda got my scum radar going. Anyways as long as no one cc's, we def should not lim him. I think not sci has been really nice and all but Osuka has a fair point which is that she seems to be fishing for prs(I think I understood correctly?) If I did not, either way it does seem like she is fishing for prs telling the prs to out if their role conflicts Osuka's. Idk its just not a great idea to out a pr in general, day 1 in my opinion. Yes the scum will die but like if ur having say something like a tracker out to kill a goon, its literally 100% not a fair trade. Idk anyways I think whoever the prs r shouldn't out cuz it doesnt really benefit town to lose prs day 1. Thats just my opinion.

[Noraa]

VOTE: joyed

Back to this

I do remember seeing this wagon earlier

[Noraa]

I personally feel like plus just has a scummy play style. I mean ... he got limmed d1 as fn in his last game. it kinda shows that his scummy behavior isn't particularly AI. Its more just a scummy play style

[notscience]

I’ve played with him too but he feels way less aggressive here was my main concern.

[PlusJOYED]

Do mafia here typically choose to claim Friendly Neighbor if in column A, Tracker/Jailkeeper if in column B, and Doctor/Tracker if in column C? (To maximize their probability of their being no counterclaim? E.g., in column A, row 2 gives Jailkeeper & Tracker. Neither of them are able to CC a Friendly.)

no idea but my partner last round claimed doctor when we were in column b setup

>:(

bahaha that's my favorite face out of all the faces that I use. apologies plus. accept a virtual apology huggie?

apology accepted

[PlusJOYED]

I’ve played with him too but he feels way less aggressive here was my main concern.

I was really fired up that game but less so this game

[Noraa]

I’ve played with him too but he feels way less aggressive here was my main concern.

he doesnt seem very aggressive here tbh. I just see the literal exact. same. play as doggos. Like he talks the exact same and he also claimed day 1 in doggos. Idk u should go check out doggos since that would be the most recent game that he came out of ... and he was a pr there