Newbie 2031 - The Wild Hunt (End!)

[the worst]

worsty lets talk; whats your read on egix?

eh he could to either way

you literally spent the last page posturing that we're partners because your crappy scumread on me didn't make sense with your default scumread of Arthur. why on earth would I engage you on this and why do you think it's a productive idea to engage me on this?

[shellyc]

cause I wannnnnnna entertain a world in which you're town and im wrong?

but the more i think the less I see it

[the worst]

oh my god you're not even pretending to be town are you
you know what I'm gonna let the busier people catch up
see you tomorrow or so

[shellyc]

worst isnt even solving me; they're trying to shade me

and they aren't trying to solve egix

[the worst]

I don't see what you're seeing. I don't really have a read on egix yet; he's kinda solvingish idk maybe town but could go either way. I doubt I'm gonna have a better read on egix until later in the game. you're going to come back and say we're scum together again. why do I need to be a party to this conversation? you made up a narrative, got caught for being a floppy fish, so you're making a more complicated narrative to try and squirm out of it.

idrc what you're saying past being superficially irritated at being shaded. I'm spending as much time on egix as everyone else in this game except you; i don't know where to land on him yet. your scumcase doesn't make me feel anything except like "maybe?"

[shellyc]

fence-sitting alert

idrt egix is "solving-ish"

[the worst]

I am fence sitting. I'm pretty null on egix. He could go either way.

[shellyc]

oh my god you're not even pretending to be town are you

^

DIE, MAFIA SCUM!

[Bluebell]

bluebells I want a readslist asap[/quote]

Your readslist missed what I wished to solicit.
But if you insist...

Mafia:
Arthur

Town:
Egix96
Satisfaction
Bluebell

Mystery Mafia Member:
Noraa/The Worst?
Clarkbar/Shelly?
Mundivore?
NotKnown15?
Redados?[/quote]
Who do you think is most/least likely to be the mystery member? Even if it's just gut.[/quote]


Projectile producer placed to my principle pondering part, I lean looking at Shellyc as the most likely murderous mafia

NotKnown15 to me, towards town

[Bluebell]

mundivore can you explain further your read on satis as they're pretty townie

worsty isnt happening so VOTE: Arthur

bluebells I want a readslist asap

Your readslist missed what I wished to solicit.
But if you insist...

Mafia:
Arthur

Town:
Egix96
Satisfaction
Bluebell

Mystery Mafia Member:
Noraa/The Worst?
Clarkbar/Shelly?
Mundivore?
NotKnown15?
Redados?

Who do you think is most/least likely to be the mystery member? Even if it's just gut.

Projectile producer placed to my principle pondering part, I lean looking at Shellyc as the most likely murderous mafia

NotKnown15 to me, towards town

[Bluebell]

Technical query: How do I just answer a question without including the previously included quotes in the question?

[fferyllt]

Technical query: How do I just answer a question without including the previously included quotes in the question?

You can highlight the part of the post you want to answer, and then click the quote button, to quote part of a post.

[Bluebell]

Thanks!

[fferyllt]

ArthurConyl has been prodded.

[Satisfaction]

Egix, Bluebell you've both posted since I shared my scenario. May I have at least an initial impression of it, if not a detailed response? Specifically some kind of alternate explanation for the last part, the recent events surrounding the vote counting and (from my perspective) role hunting. Same question to Mundivore, Redados, etc. I need some town brainpower.

At this point I'm ready to see shelly swing. We are running out of daylight. If we have to do Arthur to push something through today, I will support that (based on my most recent explanation, primarily anti-town behavior).

[Satisfaction]

Something just happened. My interpretation may not be 100% correct, but I am convinced something happened.

[Egix96]

Ok Hot Take: I scumread Egix96 now.
81 is fence-sitting on Arthur’s Alignment
fluffposting until 186 which is mainly prodding people to give their thoughts + IIoA
235 hard defends arthur which is super weird especially if arthur is red
350 CLATS (confirmed lurker and therefore scum) vanity vote on lurker isnt giving any game advancing info?
357 is subtle shade at mundivore whos pretty town so far?

like overall i dont feel like this is a very protown iso and egix has been fallen under the radar
this makes me reconsider worsty tbh
arthur is still scum

81 - Tbf that was quite early in the game, and would you rather if I had created unnecessary bias by not stating both sides of the argument?

186 - I get it if you think that that last paragraph seemed IIoA-ish, but you can see how it was jusitifed by my first impression of Satis.

235 - Come on, you can hardly say that this is a hard defence. It's not like I'm saying, "ArthurConyl is town and here are 13 reasons why!"

350 - How is this not game-advancing? I'm sure there's at least one person who wouldn't have considered the problem I was addressing had I not brought it up.

357 - So what, you'd rather I had just kept that thought to myself? IF Mundi is scum, I'm sure you can imagine how unfortunate that could end up being further down the line, yes?

Also, seeing as you like to talk about your own playstyle a lot...

"egix has been fallen under the radar"

I usually am quite UTR on D1 of games, which is something you should have inferred from reading my posts since I did touch on the subject in an earlier post of mine.

I kinda TR egix as well

Also also, why did you say this before?

Look, if you're gonna write a case on me and bend the truth in an effort to make it have more clout, you could at least try and make it more believable.

[Satisfaction]

If anything, Egix has been climbing more and more onto the radar as the game progresses.

[Egix96]

Egix, Bluebell you've both posted since I shared my scenario. May I have at least an initial impression of it, if not a detailed response? Specifically some kind of alternate explanation for the last part, the recent events surrounding the vote counting and (from my perspective) role hunting. Same question to Mundivore, Redados, etc. I need some town brainpower.

At this point I'm ready to see shelly swing. We are running out of daylight. If we have to do Arthur to push something through today, I will support that (based on my most recent explanation, primarily anti-town behavior).

I don't think I could fully comprehend the situation since all that happened while I was asleep, but honestly I can kinda buy that TW just made an honest mistake since he would have been distracted with work stuff?

Anyway yeah, I would rather vote shelly than Arthur, especially considering the disingenuity of her case on me. Don't wanna vote until I know the count tho.

[Bluebell]

Egix, Bluebell you've both posted since I shared my scenario. May I have at least an initial impression of it, if not a detailed response? Specifically some kind of alternate explanation for the last part, the recent events surrounding the vote counting and (from my perspective) role hunting. Same question to Mundivore, Redados, etc. I need some town brainpower.

At this point I'm ready to see shelly swing. We are running out of daylight. If we have to do Arthur to push something through today, I will support that (based on my most recent explanation, primarily anti-town behavior).

Your reasoning seems extreme rational. Shelly's oodles of noodling and reactions and re/deflections, are a kind of a cover, but also a true trend. Your motion is quite competent calling out of the multifarious nefarious. Multiple emotional mistakes hardly seem moral from the practiced player. And now, serious silence from the continual cawing. I appreciate your close attention to all the flying facts. I don't have enough experience to enumerate, but you seem to have struck a nerve that deemed itself undefeatable. And I would not pronounce you paranoid. The set of circumstances was all really wacky and weird.

I would assist to achieve either a Shelly or Arthur vote today. Do I dare say Shelly dances more daringly and may misstep to give away glances in fortuitous future fandangos?

[Egix96]

VOTE: shelly

I think that's

E-1

[Satisfaction]

Reminder, we do have a request from Redados to wait for his evaluation.

[the worst]

If anything, Egix has been climbing more and more onto the radar as the game progresses.

second this. my read on egix has been trending upwards. I actually like Blue calling egix town when she did - I wouldn't say I'm also townreading him as strongly as Sati but like, sure. On the contrary shelly's null => null => town => scum with a scumcase I'm really hard pressed to believe feels more agenda-driven.

[the worst]

I don't think I could fully comprehend the situation since all that happened while I was asleep, but honestly I can kinda buy that TW just made an honest mistake since he would have been distracted with work stuff?

To be candid: more that I want Arthur/Shelly as lead wagons, I'm comfortable with either or both of them claiming (and nobody else), and I was just busy enough that I couldn't be bothered checking if I was /actually/ giving intent to hammer or whether I was just yelling it for the pressure.

Sati is correct that I was pretending to try and kill someone; I wouldn't have lolhammered Arthur, I like my vote on shelly too much

[Satisfaction]

I found some really good news for shelly last night.

Spoiler: phew, close one