. [/spoiler]
Day 3 begins now. With 9 players alive, it takes 5 to vote somebody out. Deadline is on Wednesday, October 14, at 2pm EDT, in (expired on 2020-10-14 14:00:00).
I thought about this game while the thread was locked and this is my analysis on the end of day 2:
On wagon we have Ythan who was the most eager for a tn lim. I think this is kinda questionable on Ythan's part since tn flipped green. But, in the end I feel like Ythan was pretty convinced tn was scum. Like genuinely convinced which would be a town tell since scums would know exactly who the scums are and wouldn't ever be truly convinced a townie was scum.
Next three people that voted tn were me, gamma, and skies. We were all on the same boat thinking that tn was being scummy as hell putting me at E-1 without announcing and prodging. Ngl I'm a little surprised tn wasn't a scum still bc his actions were very much scummy. Doing an ISO on him just reconfirmed that for me and idk what to get out of that.
Something fishy I found here was that gamma unvoted and went to the dr. pepper wagon. I originally kinda thought this was bc gamma didnt want to bus scum partner Tn but then tn flipped green which makes me think that Gamma knew this was gonna happen and wanted to be off wagon. I may be overthinking here but idk.
The next two were vpb and reck who put him at E-2 and E-1, respectively without announcing. I kinda hate that bc it makes me feel like neither cared enough to make sure another speedwagon would go thru without good discussion beforehand. It's not too AI tho.
Then was UT dropping the hammer without declaring intent first. Except he "counted wrong" and thought Reck's was the hammer. no idea if he actually did. still pretty null on this slot tho.
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE
I find it interesting that the only person that was on my wagon is dead. It honestly kinda makes me think scum tried really hard to see me up but I don't particularly understand why that would be prioritized over pr hunting unless they though they did a big brain move with getting a pr and setting me up. idk
Gamma and tn are voting Dr Pepper which is kinda meh. I agree with Agar here that limming an active scummy slot is better than limming a lurker.
On Ythan's wagon we have Haschel. I never really understood this too much since Ythan is pretty universally TRed and pretty towny in general.
And then ofc our lurker wasn't voting. I'm not sure how to read into that so I'm leaving that alone for now.
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE
I think reck isn't trying to solve much at this point. We just got a mislim and u come back and vote someone with zero hesitation or thought put in. If ur town, untunnel and try to solve everyone not just me.
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE
can we first have a very brief talk about why you visited AGar last night?
me or reck? If me, ur scum, ur lying, and I'm fine with dying to get u killed tmrw. If reck, then this would mean you've caught scum or u just outed two prs and town is now fucked.
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE
cool, according to the mod you visited AGar and Ythan last night.
did you block night 1?
___________________
so the rules explicitly state that mafia has multitasking and the mafia is allowed to assign a group of roles amongst themselves. so let's game out some possibilities for last night based on what I know
If Reck is telling the truth about being a roleblocker:
1. He is mafia, and blocked Ythan and killed AGar
2. He is town, and he blocked AGar but there's some kind of WaCkY ShEnNaniGanS that made me see him visit two people
If Reck is lying about being a roleblocker:
1. He is town and has some kind of role that allows him to visit multiple players
2. He is town and has a role that he's lying about for some reason but there's some kind of WaCkY ShEnNaniGanS that made me see him visit two people
3. He is mafia and is lying about being a roleblocker for some reason and there are some kind of WaCkY ShEnNaniGanS that made me see him visit two people
4. He is mafia and is lying about being a roleblocker but has a different targeting role.
p.edit: i 100% absolutely did not visit ythan last night so that's wild
yes i blocked n1. VPB.
well, this isn't a bastard game to my knowledge so you *did* visit Ythan last night. whether that is because of wacky hijinks or because you're a mafia roleblocker is what is up for discussion here.
also: I also tracked you N1 and my role was blocked. you can obviously see why your claim of roleblocker here is... concerning.... to me.
PEdit: you not fullclaiming is obviously fine with me because I explicitly asked you not to do it unless it explains why I tracked you to two different players last night. you claim that it doesn't so.... no worries.
p.edit: i 100% absolutely did not visit ythan last night so that's wild
yes i blocked n1. VPB.
well, this isn't a bastard game to my knowledge so you *did* visit Ythan last night. whether that is because of wacky hijinks or because you're a mafia roleblocker is what is up for discussion here.
also: I also tracked you N1 and my role was blocked. you can obviously see why your claim of roleblocker here is... concerning.... to me.
PEdit: you not fullclaiming is obviously fine with me because I explicitly asked you not to do it unless it explains why I tracked you to two different players last night. you claim that it doesn't so.... no worries.
Is it possible to have two role blockers in a mini theme game? Also are there any roles that can target more than one person besides mafia ofc cuz those can always multitask?
Dream as if you'll live forever, live as if you'll die today.
Come play Guess that Scummer OR ELSE
this is gonna get me yeeted but i have to correct myself
i ORIGINALLY sent in a block on vpb, that was the PM i checked when you asked for my claim. i just checked and ORIGINALLY i blocked vpb *last night* and sent a correction in this morning (tues @ 12:38am vs wed @ 10:38am). i thought that older pm was from n1 but it was from n2.
[/spoiler]