Newbie 2031 - The Wild Hunt (End!)

[fferyllt]

The night was long and full of terrors

shellyc was a

Town Jailkeeper

[fferyllt]

Vote Count 2-1

Day 2 Begins!

A column of sober-looking elven folk file out of the woods and into the great clearing.

Not Voting

(7): Redados, the worst, Bluebell, Satisfaction, Egix96, Not Known 15, Mundivore

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to eliminate.

Deadline: October 9, Midnight US Eastern Time.

Countdown: (expired on 2020-10-08 21:00:00)

Mod Notes:

-

[shellyc]

bah!

[Bluebell]

Oh my.
I am sincerely sorry Arthur. I have no excuses. It was a mistake.
And Shelly? My suspicions have led me seriously astray.

[Satisfaction]

I don't even know where to start. Last night I starting thinking that it was interesting that more people weren't waving me off. Originally I was just disappointed and frustrated but now I'm wondering if there's anything to be gleaned from that information.

Overall feeling pretty discouraged.

[Egix96]

I don't even know where to start. Last night I starting thinking that it was interesting that more people weren't waving me off. Originally I was just disappointed and frustrated but now I'm wondering if there's anything to be gleaned from that information.

Overall feeling pretty discouraged.

What were you hoping would happen? Arthur flipping red?

[Satisfaction]

Of course. I didn’t think it was going to happen, but that’s the goal, right?

[the worst]

VOTE: Blue

[Satisfaction]

VOTE: Blue

Is this based on #678?

[the worst]

#678 didn't make it into my brain, past my pre-coffee smog.

[Mundivore]

VOTE: the worst

Current preferred lim order is the worst = satisfaction > Redados.

[Egix96]

VOTE: the worst

Current preferred lim order is the worst = satisfaction > Redados.

Why are you voting tw? You seemed pretty confident that his slot was town in 398 .

VOTE: Mundivore

[Redados]

Oh my.
I am sincerely sorry Arthur. I have no excuses. It was a mistake.
And Shelly? My suspicions have led me seriously astray.

You need to give us more info than that. Who do you think is town now? Who do you think is scum?
VOTE: Bluebell

[Redados]

VOTE: the worst

Current preferred lim order is the worst = satisfaction > Redados.

Why are you voting tw? You seemed pretty confident that his slot was town in 398 .

VOTE: Mundivore

that was like twelve pages ago...

[Redados]

Oh my.
I am sincerely sorry Arthur. I have no excuses. It was a mistake.
And Shelly? My suspicions have led me seriously astray.

You need to give us more info than that. Who do you think is town now? Who do you think is scum?
VOTE: Bluebell

This is E-2

[Satisfaction]

To me, Bluebell just seems like the next easy elimination with little demonstrated scummy intent. Does anybody have an actual case? I’d rather not just do this again.

[Mundivore]

To me, Bluebell just seems like the next easy elimination with little demonstrated scummy intent. Does anybody have an actual case? I’d rather not just do this again.

This is exactly why I'm pushing for the worst.

tw pushed super aggressively onto shellyc yesterday, and happily/contentedly switched to Arthur when he couldn't get his way. Now Day 2 starts, and his immediate target, rather than anyone who interacted with the wagons yesterday, is simply the fluff-target.

[the worst]

it's almost as if I vote people I scumread at deadline and people I nullread while there's time left. wild.

[Bluebell]

Oh my.
I am sincerely sorry Arthur. I have no excuses. It was a mistake.
And Shelly? My suspicions have led me seriously astray.

You need to give us more info than that. Who do you think is town now? Who do you think is scum?
VOTE: Bluebell

I don't know. I'm starting over at square one, but with my reads for scum switched. Sigh. Was Shelly assassinated because of her stated suspicions? Or does a jailkeeper just get jettisoned as a proactive scum tactic?

Redados,
you have been very measured in your approach in the past,
So why did you throw this vote in for me so fast?

[Egix96]

Oh my.
I am sincerely sorry Arthur. I have no excuses. It was a mistake.
And Shelly? My suspicions have led me seriously astray.

You need to give us more info than that. Who do you think is town now? Who do you think is scum?
VOTE: Bluebell

I don't know. I'm starting over at square one, but with my reads for scum switched. Sigh. Was Shelly assassinated because of her stated suspicions? Or does a jailkeeper just get jettisoned as a proactive scum tactic?

Redados,
you have been very measured in your approach in the past,
So why did you throw this vote in for me so fast?

Personally I think it was just a free PR kill, in which case the accuracy of her reads has no relevance to whether she dies or not.

[Redados]

Redados,
you have been very measured in your approach in the past,
So why did you throw this vote in for me so fast?

On Day One, we had much less information than we do now. We're at the point where we have the information from day one to learn from. Also, most players are deciding who they see as scum versus town. You are difficult to judge in terms of alignment because of your lower activity. What I would like to hear from you are your thoughts on yesterday's wagon. For example, how many scum do you think were on the wagon? Who do you think is scum based on who voted ArthurConyl? Or who didn't want to vote for ArthurConyl? Because scum knew the whole time that he was town, so you can go back and look at interactions with hindsight, knowing that.

If you don't give us more information in terms of how you're feeling and thinking, we might think it is because you have something to hide.

Why did I vote for you? The only tool we have to find scum is our votes. I will use it how I think it is most effective to find scum. Without votes on you, you might not feel the heat enough to post more. Maybe some votes will give you more motivation to share your reads etc.

[Redados]

I'll be lower activity for the next day or so since I'll be traveling. Should be back to usual capabilities by Saturday evening or Sunday morning CST.

[Mundivore]

it's almost as if I vote people I scumread at deadline and people I nullread while there's time left. wild.

Fair enough. No need to get snitty.

[Bluebell]

Redados,
you have been very measured in your approach in the past,
So why did you throw this vote in for me so fast?

On Day One, we had much less information than we do now. We're at the point where we have the information from day one to learn from. Also, most players are deciding who they see as scum versus town. You are difficult to judge in terms of alignment because of your lower activity. What I would like to hear from you are your thoughts on yesterday's wagon. For example, how many scum do you think were on the wagon? Who do you think is scum based on who voted ArthurConyl? Or who didn't want to vote for ArthurConyl? Because scum knew the whole time that he was town, so you can go back and look at interactions with hindsight, knowing that.

If you don't give us more information in terms of how you're feeling and thinking, we might think it is because you have something to hide.

Why did I vote for you? The only tool we have to find scum is our votes. I will use it how I think it is most effective to find scum. Without votes on you, you might not feel the heat enough to post more. Maybe some votes will give you more motivation to share your reads etc.

I have been rereading since I read of Shelly's demise, and continue to recalibrate. Especially Shelly as Clarkbar and The Worst as Noraa. And the analyses of all about Arthur.

[Satisfaction]

I think it was just a free PR kill, in which case the accuracy of her reads has no relevance to whether she dies or not.

Agreed.