Ok so just from a game state perspective I think it is probably better to flip town MC than town Pooky. Obviously it’s better to flip scum Pooky than town MC, but that is why I haven’t hard pushed Pooky, I’m not confident enough right now to do that. So this actually isn’t really an attempt to get anyone to vote there unless you independently value anything in here. I’ve also approached this from the perspective that Pooky is scum, so this is all biased in that direction. That is not an accurate assessment of my read on Pooky, I think he somewhere between probably to maybe scum.
Pooky respond to this if you want but I’m not going to fight with you again, it is fun but exhausting. I accept I’m the lim today. This is more for when I flip than anything else.
The early posts are all just poking around and aren’t really that interesting. I do want to point out that if Pooky ever flips scum I think that leads to town points for Blitzo due to
223. That doesn’t read like distancing to me.
399 sticks out to me still compared to how defensive Pooky gets when I start to pressure him, but I’ll come back to that.
Through
448 I still feel like Pooky has mostly just tried to poke at people. I read my own iso and to me it feels like I am trying to work with people but I just don’t get that sense from Pooky. Even the people he is defending I don’t think he actually is claiming their town or trying to work with them in the same way. Like in
214 Pooky claims that Kasu is probably town and Shea’s progressions are good. Other than basically OOG talk in
267 and
273 there is no interaction with either of them until
333 where he asks Kasu a question. In
456 Shea prompts Pooky to work with him and Pooky, to his credit, obliges.
514 is interesting and has been mentioned already. Compared to what Pooky was saying in
399 it is a weird way to leave the RVS vote. It feels like he was caught for not voting and waited a bit before fixing it. He already had the Blitzo read way back in
224 so why not just vote in
399 instead of making a big deal of it? Just feels overly defensive whereas town I would have just said “ok that’s true I’ll vote now.” Pooky defends his actions in
538 for those interested.
601 <3 I still love you Pooky even after all we’ve been through
619 Pooky does act against my point above here. I do think that UG makes a great point in
653 and I don’t feel as if
659 is a real defense for it.
Pooky seems really defensive in
734. The phrase “so when I flip town…” really irks me because to me it assumes that OutWorld is scum. I think I’m repeating myself now though.
757 also feels kind of aggressive to me? Like why is Pooky getting so defensive saying that OutWorld has no case blah blah blah. It just feels really dismissive and not how I would respond as town to someone who from my perspective might also be town.
810 is me trying to engage with Pooky and him dodging the question with a joke, but whatever that might be NAI.
I think I make a good point in
816 and I don’t think that
818 is a good defense.
I still think that
870 is a blatant misrep of everything that I had been saying, but other people agreed so I guess I just didn’t express myself well.
I feel like
886 is a good example of how fast Pooky shifted on me, which feels unnatural. Like, I am scum leaning Pooky and trying to talk to him, he apparently hadn’t been scum reading me before this and in
886 it reads like he is convinced I’m scum? I really don’t think it’s fair to say I twisted anything and I never once tried to get anyone to vote him up to this point.
The beginning of
909 is just ridiculous and Gamma calls it out in
910. It feels like every possible attack he can make he is whereas I was genuinely trying to work with him still. Pooky will take issue with this statement because I do say I’m not questioning him and he thinks I’m not interacting with him, but from my POV I wanted him to calm down so I could actually interact productively. And saying I’m evasive in
919 is just a falsehood, I respond to all of his posts.
Posts like
954 I also feel like are attacks based on my nothing, if you know my meta you know that’s not how I play.
The comment on my word choice in
963 is ridiculous.
1221 never went anywhere as Pooky continues to say I look bad, but maybe he didn’t reread.
1365 is just silly.
If
1369 were true I’d have tried to push Noraa with Shea. I feel like this is obvious and Pooky can’t in good faith believe that I would stick up for Noraa the way I have if she was town and I was scum and there was pressure on me.
Ok make of that what you will, I know we are still eliming me today.