Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[Titus]

I am not reading shelley v noraa. I skimmed the last few pages.

I don't like Herta's play but I feel Herta has been scummy.

I don't like Echo but he has a point on Ico.

If Herta is scum, then I expect one of Echo and/or Ico to be scum too.

[Titus]

*I don't like Herta's wagon bc it's unopposed by Herta has been scummy.

[shellyc]

@red not the biggest fan of a forced townblock, but if you insist I’m open to the idea

[EchoVision]

VOTE: redcardinal

:thumbs_down:

[shellyc]

Echo I concur, but why?

echo what’s your thoughts on noraaaaaaaaa btw

[EchoVision]

I didn't realize it said to kill me if shelly flips red

noraa darling i told you this
then red even confirmed it

[Herta]

I'd like to see a VC. My wagon grew like gangbusters out of nothing, over nothing. With 2-3 scum factions likely, I want to see who's on it.

[Herta]

And red cardinal. What the hell kind of vote is that? "Serious vote." So when you switched from RVS it wasn't a serious vote? Or that was a second RVS vote? Maybe explain that.

I wanted to see more from noraa under pressure, but no I don't think noraa is scum

You switched your initial RVS vote to me, long before you said it was a serious vote. I was asking why did you switch to me to begin with.

[shellyc]

it's not... nothing?

Yeah, sounds like newbscum to me.

scumclaim after I said their post sounded like newbscum

Eh..

meh.

no interest / concern in being eliminated, then sudden defensive change of tone

[Herta]

I mean, how do you get scumclaim out of that, Shelly? Seriously. Because that's what people do is scumclaim.

because I called you newbscum
you said you were newbscum

VOTE: Herta

When on this site, on any site, have you seen a literal scum claim at the beginning of a game?

This is daft. You didn't like how I answered your question, so you called me newbscum or an alt. I said yeah must be newbscum. Boom you jump right into dancing the dance of joy. This is so surface level it's painful.

We've got enough scum factions probably that the whole game is going to be like this, people jumping on everything they see.

Does anyone have a case other than Primate? At least that one has some oomph behind it.

[Herta]

it's not... nothing?

Yeah, sounds like newbscum to me.

scumclaim after I said their post sounded like newbscum

Eh..

meh.

no interest / concern in being eliminated, then sudden defensive change of tone

You missed the point of who is being the lazy seal in that gif.

[shellyc]

When on this site, on any site, have you seen a literal scum claim at the beginning of a game?

This is daft. You didn't like how I answered your question, so you called me newbscum or an alt. I said yeah must be newbscum. Boom you jump right into dancing the dance of joy. This is so surface level it's painful.

We've got enough scum factions probably that the whole game is going to be like this, people jumping on everything they see.

ok fine lets just ignore the scumslip

the way where I pressured you about it was "hey whatever" and that's not a town response at all to being said as "scumslipping". you have no concern over the elimination.

like your post when I asked about your thoughts is still IIoA. and basically what you did over the game was say our scumhunting style by asking who is scum is bad. which isnt a read or solving

[shellyc]

even without considering the scumslip you're still obvscum here.

jumping on people and pressuring is strictly NAI btw, cant see how it's scum!AI. opportunism isn't equal to gamesolving efforts.

[shellyc]

I mean, how do you get scumclaim out of that, Shelly? Seriously. Because that's what people do is scumclaim.

like this sounds like hatcheting (discrediting my push without actually sussing me or voting for me) which is very scum indicative. you did same thing to redcardinal as well

[Herta]

Eh.. Ima let you keep teaching me to scum hunt. I'll be back later. Meanwhile, keep an eye on that wagon and think about the possible scum numbers.

[shellyc]

im not teaching you how to scumhunt. im calling you scum.

[Noraa]

noraa shelly how do you feel about a townbloc

why are you asking two people you SR to to be ur town block? I admit I completely misread the other post which got me really confused but I'm reading this right. Im certain you haven't switched either of us to a TR.

I didn't realize it said to kill me if shelly flips red

noraa darling i told you this
then red even confirmed it

yeah I don't really listen. Jellyfish uk how I am -___- I'm listening but not really <.<

When on this site, on any site, have you seen a literal scum claim at the beginning of a game?

This is daft. You didn't like how I answered your question, so you called me newbscum or an alt. I said yeah must be newbscum. Boom you jump right into dancing the dance of joy. This is so surface level it's painful.

We've got enough scum factions probably that the whole game is going to be like this, people jumping on everything they see.

ok fine lets just ignore the scumslip

the way where I pressured you about it was "hey whatever" and that's not a town response at all to being said as "scumslipping". you have no concern over the elimination.

like your post when I asked about your thoughts is still IIoA. and basically what you did over the game was say our scumhunting style by asking who is scum is bad. which isnt a read or solving

Ok so I found this whole thing to kinda be Herta joking around(cuz they are right generally scums don't claim d1-___-) and then underestimating the amount of attention it would rack up. I think they kinda like ... expected everyone to take it as a snarky joke and didn't put too much thought into the followup wagon.

Shelly I feel like loves to "be very confident" which is the opposite of me. I think its not AI. Don't get me wrong. The vibe still reminds me of her scum games so I'm still sticking with that but the being really certain she found scum thing definitely isnt AI.

[Noraa]

noraa shelly how do you feel about a townbloc

why are you asking two people you SR to to be ur town block? I admit I completely misread the other post which got me really confused but I'm reading this right. Im certain you haven't switched either of us to a TR.

For emphasis on the important part, this followup post was made

[Rannygazoo]

Herta, maybe try explaining the scum claim that led to your wagon instead of just complaining about it

[Herta]

Herta, maybe try explaining the scum claim that led to your wagon instead of just complaining about it

Alright, how about this:


Yeah, sounds like newbscum to me.

[Noraa]

Herta, maybe try explaining the scum claim that led to your wagon instead of just complaining about it

Alright, how about this:


Yeah, sounds like newbscum to me.

try again

[Herta]

Herta, maybe try explaining the scum claim that led to your wagon instead of just complaining about it

Have you ever seen a sincere scum claim this early outside of RVs on this site? Has anyone?

[Titus]

VOTE: Ico

I want a counter to this wagon.

[Herta]

Herta, maybe try explaining the scum claim that led to your wagon instead of just complaining about it

Alright, how about this:


Yeah, sounds like newbscum to me.

try again

Sorry, Noraa, I'm not going to dance for you. You saw the sarcasm in it before and now you're choosing not to I guess.

[Herta]

VOTE: Ico

I want a counter to this wagon.

Redcardinal is a good vote.