mystery box of silver 10. (done)

[Bell]

That question was directed at both A50, Titus, Mastina.

And I suppose I should turn the contempt button down on Mastina because at least they're trying.
I haven't read your case and I never will because I already town told.

[mastina]

As scum would you be above claiming set up ignorance for easy town points?

I don't fake ignorance, but that doesn't mean scumastina can't be genuinely ignorant.

I never fake a mistake, but I can genuinely make a legit mistake.

[April Ludgate]

@Bell - don’t expect that it would be feigning scum ignorance full front. Scum don’t like to read rules either. in regards to the Mastina question. I personally am town reading Mastina here.

[April Ludgate]

Mastina won’t do anything as scum that they wouldn’t do as town.

[superbowl9]

Oh i forgot about you AL. I think you might be scum too

[Bell]

I'm not sure how helpful introducing the concept of thinking about whether your roles were given to you by friends or people that know you as scum versus just not knowing that.

[Almost50]

oh so youre hectic too?

Manic is more like it, I think.

[mastina]

But you have an expectation that you should be having a townread on them, that's the part you left out.

Yes, there is an expectation that I should be townreading them.

That expectation is not burden of proficiency, because burden of proficiency is an expectation of shown demonstrated competency/accuracy.

My expectation requires no skill, no competency, no accuracy.

Just the presence of being town.

I've only seen one post that gave me that feeling at all.

One post

can

be enough, sometimes, but one post can also be scum having made one good post among hundreds of not-as-good posts.
So I want more from them to better judge the slot and get a better read, if the one post was a fluke of them being scum and happening to briefly say something that looked town, or if the one post was just the first of many town posts to follow.

[April Ludgate]

As town, i always forget to capitalise my 'i's. as scum, i always fakeclaim loud vengeful fruit vendor

~Buttercup

You can tell if I’m typing on my busted iPad or not if my I’s aren’t capitalized, and there’s a sense of fuck all when it comes to spelling and punctuation. Or typos.

[April Ludgate]

Oh i forgot about you AL. I think you might be scum too

Can you keep this exact level of pushing me so I can coast until like Day 4?

[Almost50]

That question was directed at both A50, Titus, Mastina.

If you mean this:

As scum would you be above claiming set up ignorance for easy town points?

Then the answer is "probably not". HOWEVER, I do tend to get analytical/mechanical so I don't think it would benefit me in a large at all. I mean, public info is public.

If that's NOT the question you're referring to then please point me to "that question".

[superbowl9]

But you have an expectation that you should be having a townread on them, that's the part you left out.

Yes, there is an expectation that I should be townreading them.

That expectation is not burden of proficiency, because burden of proficiency is an expectation of shown demonstrated competency/accuracy.

My expectation requires no skill, no competency, no accuracy.

Just the presence of being town.

I've only seen one post that gave me that feeling at all.

One post

can

be enough, sometimes, but one post can also be scum having made one good post among hundreds of not-as-good posts.
So I want more from them to better judge the slot and get a better read, if the one post was a fluke of them being scum and happening to briefly say something that looked town, or if the one post was just the first of many town posts to follow.

I don't understand why you have this expectation for only this slot though, if you're not BoPing shouldnt this apply to everyone

[Almost50]

Mastina won’t do anything as scum that they wouldn’t do as town.

Except faking a case on town and miseliminating them by day, or straight up shooting them at night, you mean??

[superbowl9]

Oh i forgot about you AL. I think you might be scum too

Can you keep this exact level of pushing me so I can coast until like Day 4?

Actually yes

[April Ludgate]

Mastina won’t do anything as scum that they wouldn’t do as town.

Except faking a case on town and miseliminating them by day, or straight up shooting them at night, you mean??

She’s gonna call the same stuff out as either alignment, even if you are partners with her.

It’s the level that she pushes is the difference.

[Almost50]

Well, she won't be shooting townies at night when she's town, that's for sure.

P.S. NOT EVEN if she rolls Vig, as -according to her- Vihilante is anti-Town and should always holster.

[Bell]

That's exactly what I meant.
@A50.
Thx.

@April, you're not wrong. I think some players from meta are more prone to read the set ups than others and sometimes scum get a little nervous when I ask town to tell me they're town. Or whether as scum to disagree or not take the absurd question seriously.

[superbowl9]

Anyone wanna hop on the jjh train

[mastina]

I don't understand why you have this expectation for only this slot though, if you're not BoPing shouldnt this apply to everyone

It does, actually, unless I have meta indicating to me that a lack of town/scum isn't a scum-indicator.

By default, given enough posts from a user and with no meta suggesting otherwise, a lack of a read one way or another would be a minor scum-indicator.

[Bell]

Anyone wanna hop on the jjh train

I shall white knight with you.

VOTE: JJH

[mastina]

P.S. NOT EVEN if she rolls Vig, as -according to her- Vihilante is anti-Town and should always holster.

Oh heavens no.

Vigilantes aren't anti-town.

ME getting a vigilante IS anti-town.

And, there is a caveat to me and Vig powers.
If I am in a "use it or lose it" situation with a vig, I will in fact use it.
If the vig is gated significantly, I will probably use it at least once.
If the game is on evens and I am fairly sure my vig is the only way to get to odds, I will use it.
If I need to prove that I have the vig power, then I will use it.

Generally speaking, that means that I actually will use a vig shot in quite a lot of cases--but only if one (or ideally, more) of the criteria above are met.

Otherwise, I will indeed holster because fuck giving me a vig, my townreads are always more accurate than my scumreads so I'm disproportionately likely to shoot town, making it an antitown role for ME to have.

[Bell]

This is all playstyle probably, but that post reads as extremely NAI.

[superbowl9]

Anyone wanna hop on the jjh train

I shall white knight with you.

VOTE: JJH

Thanks my friend

[Bell]

<3 At least we're not scum buddies together this game.

[Almost50]

Actually, here's my first serious vote 9actually my first in-game vote, since my RVS went to a spectator)

VOTE: Gamma

Gamma has been on MS for 4.5 hours now. He made 47 public posts (the last if which was maybe 2 minutes ago) but is yet to even make an ego post in this game.