Mini Theme 2172: Great Idea Mafia - Game Over

[shellyc]

same reason i didn’t vote herta before— there’s two slots who just don’t exist STILL so i didn’t want to push the wagon super duper far without them existing
VOTE: ranny but i’m sick of their shit i’m going through switch vote withdrawal

echo why are you wagon hopping like crazy

[shellyc]

For the above two posts, red cardinal is in my TRs. I like the attitude-its very towny and I believe you believe explaining is good.

noraa what is this inconsistency, did I finally manage to talk you out of scum!redcardinal

[Herta]

The timing on 433-436 for redcardinal is town indicative. It shows a free flow of thought.

[Herta]

I'm not reading any more about post length. That whole convo is meh to me.

[Herta]

I know that mafia games are No Irony Zones but I’m going to say what I want without fear. Thanks for bearing with me.

@Herta do you have any scumreads that aren’t OMGUS?

It's not omgus. It has nothing to do with your push on me. But I think you know that.

[Herta]

To alert town to the fact that shelly is a good scum player and it might be wise to have a bit of caution about her.

I don’t claim to know what alignment she rolled this time.

Why not just say that then? There's no need to hide that from us or make it cryptic.

[Herta]

Nothing has changed my mind on Shelly.

[shellyc]

The timing on 433-436 for redcardinal is town indicative. It shows a free flow of thought.

stream of consciousness is like, one of the thing that i use a LOT as scum

why are you giving townpasses for random reasons. this is probably tmi.

[Titus]

We should execute Ranny. Their reaction to my move was terrible.

[Rannygazoo]

I know that mafia games are No Irony Zones but I’m going to say what I want without fear. Thanks for bearing with me.

@Herta do you have any scumreads that aren’t OMGUS?

It's not omgus. It has nothing to do with your push on me. But I think you know that.

You’re not the first person to hit me with the “I think you know that”. What is this tactic called? The smug psychic? You don’t know me. I was asking if you had scumreads outside of me and shelly.

To alert town to the fact that shelly is a good scum player and it might be wise to have a bit of caution about her.

I don’t claim to know what alignment she rolled this time.

Why not just say that then? There's no need to hide that from us or make it cryptic.

It was never cryptic. People are just blowing it out of proportion and I don’t *really* understand why.

[Rannygazoo]

I’m waiting for someone else to comment on Titus’s posting, because his lowkey trolling is clearly anti-town, but town is not going to hear it from me, it seems.

[Primate]

I just feel this is town pushing on town. I don't see anyone trying to defend Herta. I'll hammer to get the game going, I just think scum are coasting here.

Yeah, the wagons today have been interesting. It's kind of back to normal now but it was notably slow in doing so.

NPOM is pretty tiresome.

Herta is scummier than ranny. I like the ranny wagon though.

Town vibes from EV.

RC went weird for a bit then recovered.

Shelly may actually be scum, I'm more open to that idea now.

[Primate]

I’m waiting for someone else to comment on Titus’s posting, because his lowkey trolling is clearly anti-town, but town is not going to hear it from me, it seems.

Nah I like it.

[Rannygazoo]

Please explain

[Rannygazoo]

I'll hammer to get the game going, I just think scum are coasting here.

Seriously, explain WHY this is okay when I said something similar in 398 and it blew up in my face

[Primate]

Just generally to answer both your questions, it's about execution, and I think it's interesting that you're looking at it that way.

You think titus did a scummy thing that she's not getting enough stick for? Implicit in this course of argument, aligning it with your action like you are doing, you are acknowledging that you did a scummy thing, correct?

[Rannygazoo]

It probably has something to do with redcardinal’s policy of deciding which slots to scumread and then picking reasons later as he explained to me in 463

[Rannygazoo]

@Primate your Jedi mind tricks won’t work on me. I didn’t say Titus’s post there was scummy. I said it was very similar to mine and I want to know why it provokes very different reactions. If someone (not me) thinks I was being scummy, they should think the same of Titus, but he’s flown under the radar. “It’s about execution” is such a non-answer. I think it has more to do with alignments revealed in role pms.

[Titus]

I’m waiting for someone else to comment on Titus’s posting, because his lowkey trolling is clearly anti-town, but town is not going to hear it from me, it seems.

Her.

Also, it's not anti town. It's getting a reaction which lets people sort us.

[EchoVision]

same reason i didn’t vote herta before— there’s two slots who just don’t exist STILL so i didn’t want to push the wagon super duper far without them existing
VOTE: ranny but i’m sick of their shit i’m going through switch vote withdrawal

echo why are you wagon hopping like crazy

you know i wagon hop like crazy especially d1
it's fun to wagon hop

[Primate]

It probably has something to do with redcardinal’s policy of deciding which slots to scumread and then picking reasons later as he explained to me in 463

Not what she's saying there.

And the aligning the actions thing was about the fact that if you think you and titus did the same thing then surely you, as town, would consider that post a towntell from titus, but instead you seem to be scumreading her a bit.

[EchoVision]

fuck we still have a week before deadline
zzzzzzzz
who we killin today boys and girls
VOTE: ranny

[Rannygazoo]

Just generally to answer both your questions, it's about execution, and I think it's interesting that you're looking at it that way.

Am I to read this as “it’s actually a good thing that ranny is the object of titus’s trolling, because of my SR on ranny”?

@Titus sorry, I assumed Titus was a boy’s name. Since we have you here, what was terrible about my reaction?

[Rannygazoo]

@Primate I am not scumreading Titus for that post. I am scumreading Titus strictly for other reasons. However, other people are scumreading me for a post similar to one that she made. I’m trying to suss out why player’s reactions to the two of us are so different. I hope that clears it up.

Some people might say “she posts similarly to me so she must be town” but I deliberately try to avoid that. I don’t want to become pocketed just because I agree with someone’s posts.

[Primate]

Just generally to answer both your questions, it's about execution, and I think it's interesting that you're looking at it that way.

Am I to read this as “it’s actually a good thing that ranny is the object of titus’s trolling, because of my SR on ranny”?

Nah. It's about inviting an attack vs shielding vs an attack. Titus was inviting an attack, imho, which isn't scummy.