Newbie 2035 - Movie Facts (Game Over)

[NorwegianboyEE]

Were you making a joke? Sorry, not my type of humor i guess.

[Town looter]

Were you making a joke? Sorry, not my type of humor i guess.

Haha, that's what I love about Scandinavians, this is either a genuine reaction or a top class burn, and you will never know which.

[Town looter]

Anyway, im going to bed. You chaps enjoy the rest of your morning.

[Zurel]

Can someone vote themselves here?

[Zurel]

Not that I want to vote myself. I just want to know.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Can someone vote themselves here?

Yeah voting yourself is valid, you shouldn't ever do it unless you're scum and accept your own elimination though.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Were you making a joke? Sorry, not my type of humor i guess.

Haha, that's what I love about Scandinavians, this is either a genuine reaction or a top class burn, and you will never know which.

I’ll keep up that appearance by never clarifying what i meant.

[Trendall]

NorwegianboyEE did indeed vote for themselves as town in the manatee mafia but I really don't think it's a big deal.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Do as i say not as i do.

[Zurel]

Do people here often bring up prior games?

Also can we talk at Night here?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Do people here often bring up prior games?

Some people do and some people don't. I'd say it happens often but some people get really mad when it's brought up because they think meta is bad. It's a bit of an polarizing issue.

Also can we talk at Night here?

This thread get's locked during night, but you can always talk in your PT.

[Zurel]

Also can we talk at Night here?

This thread get's locked during night, but you can always talk in your PT.

For newbie games, can masons talk in their PT at Night, too? Or is that something that's not fixed and determined by the mod?

[NorwegianboyEE]

You are a Town Mason.

You know that PLAYER NAME is Town-aligned. You also share a Private Thread (PT), located here,

where you may talk at any time

.

[Zurel]

Wow, I did NOT read that.

Thanks.

[AuroraDash]

I plan to write a longer analysis post once I've had another look through your posts, Zurel, and compiled my thoughts on them and on the past couple days' worth of material in general, but for now:

Thanks. I'll see what I'm going to do once I get a hang of the game.
So for this random stage, is it necessary for us to get someone eliminated? Also, can someone refrain from voting? Because they're pacifist maybe.

While every other question makes sense coming from somebody familiar with Mafia but not with this forum's particular flavour of it, this one from way near the beginning stands out as a bit off to me. Do you remember what you meant by "Because they're pacifist maybe"? I don't think pacifism is a thing in Mafia, or at least it certainly isn't in newbie setups. Without that context, this post kinda speaks to a misunderstanding of the basics of the game rather than unfamilairity with the conventions of the forum -- implying that you're faking it. Might be reading too deep into that, idk, it's just bothering me.

[AuroraDash]

Anyway -- while knowing that Zurel isn't as clueless as we originally thought does change the way I look at several of those old posts, I don't think Titus + Zurel makes much sense as a team right now.

[brassherald]

Movie Fact: In Titanic, James Cameron Drew that charcoal of naked Kate Winslet.

Votecount 1.04

Titus (4):

NorewegianboyEE, Trendall, Zurel, AuroraDash

NorwegianboyEE (1):

, Titus

Not Voting (4):

Salsabil Faria, wiyvern, TheDuke, Town looter

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to eliminate.
The Day 1 will end in (expired on 2020-10-25 09:30:00)

[Zurel]

I plan to write a longer analysis post once I've had another look through your posts, Zurel, and compiled my thoughts on them and on the past couple days' worth of material in general, but for now:

Thanks. I'll see what I'm going to do once I get a hang of the game.
So for this random stage, is it necessary for us to get someone eliminated? Also, can someone refrain from voting? Because they're pacifist maybe.

While every other question makes sense coming from somebody familiar with Mafia but not with this forum's particular flavour of it, this one from way near the beginning stands out as a bit off to me. Do you remember what you meant by "Because they're pacifist maybe"? I don't think pacifism is a thing in Mafia, or at least it certainly isn't in newbie setups. Without that context, this post kinda speaks to a misunderstanding of the basics of the game rather than unfamilairity with the conventions of the forum -- implying that you're faking it. Might be reading too deep into that, idk, it's just bothering me.

Because I used to be against lynching on the first Day. However, back where I played, the Day phases were extremely short. Only 24 hours, and then much later they updated it to 48 hours. I had never played in a phase that went on for 10 literal days, so I found it hard to imagine what people did during such a long duration. I think I just just said pacifist either as a joke or because I would like to know if there was any reason someone did not want to vote on Day 1.

Now I'm all for lynching because I can't handle the loss of 10 days doing nothing.

[AuroraDash]

If I die early, can I put my name in the next newbie game sign-up? Or can I already do that now?

Because I used to be against lynching on the first Day. However, back where I played, the Day phases were extremely short. Only 24 hours, and then much later they updated it to 48 hours. I had never played in a phase that went on for 10 literal days, so I found it hard to imagine what people did during such a long duration. I think I just just said pacifist either as a joke or because I would like to know if there was any reason someone did not want to vote on Day 1.

Alright, that's fair enough.

[Salsabil Faria]

If you are the

doctor

, then NorwegianboyEE is the

scum

.

Things don’t work that way though.

What I meant there was, one of you is lying. So, if Titus says the truth about her role, then you're the scum here. On the other hand, it's vise versa, you're telling truth, so, Titus fake claimed.

That’s what i don’t like about your post. As i know i am town, if Titus is confirmed town it still doesn’t change the fact that it could be TvT. Not saying it necesarilly is as i still don’t trust Titus at all. But pushing the narrative that i HAVE to be scum if Titus isn’t is very suspicious.

It seems like everything is very suspicious for you, but whatever, I feel either Titus or you is lying, so I strongly feel that one of you is town and the other one is mafia.

[NorwegianboyEE]

It seems like everything is very suspicious for you, but whatever

Replying like that is also suspicious.

[Salsabil Faria]

Trendall, while we wait for someone to hammer or Titus to return.
Who's your reads on scum if Titus was town. And who do you think would be likely teammate to Titus if they are scum?

1. You guys all went around saying ‘Zurel asked a question so they’re town’, so nowadays later on in the game

Salsabil Faria is asking questions like ‘can there be three mafia?’

to make themselves look more town or something.

2. NorwgianboyEE post 410 looks really bad because new players do this stuff all the time. Again it’s so arbitrary like…Zurel did a thing that wasn’t indicative of alignment whatsoever and gets a townread for it on the basis that it’s ‘genuine noobiness’ even though they were literally not even a new player (aahaha), but when Salsabil Faria makes an actual very common newbie error, they are ‘sus’.

4. Nobody had any good reason to think Zurel was town from those questions at the start of the game, as you all now know. Because you were all like ‘that’s a genuine newbie asking genuine newbie questions and I'd know because I've played this game before' and you were all wrong and it wasn't even a newbie lol so...

Thank you for brought these points up here. I cut the points 3 & 5 because it's not relevant to my answer.
For 1st point here, I asked the question (green marked) because initially, Zurel's statements seemed genuine noob but when the conversations/arguments increasing, Zurel's statements seemed more like an experienced player to me (I wanted to ask if Zurel play the mafia game before but NorwegianboyEE asked the question already), then our mod updated the vote count and I saw there Titus has 3 votes against are and the voters are Zurel, NorwegianboyEE and Trendall. As the mod can change the game set up, so I thought if 3 mafias were a possibility or not.
For 2nd and 4th point, I totally agree with you specially point 2 is very hillarious

[Salsabil Faria]

In my defense, it would have been easier for me to continue pretending ignorance and let those who believed I was a noob plus town to read me so. I would have flown under the radar, at least for this phase, and if I was scum lynching town that would have been good job me.

When I made a comment against going after Salsabil, I was fully aware that someone might realise that I was not actually a noob.

But I decided not to play it safe anymore.

sounds like you get caught, so you decide to agree to save your own skin

[Salsabil Faria]

It seems like everything is very suspicious for you, but whatever

Replying like that is also suspicious.

doesn't matter to me

[Salsabil Faria]

Titus is on L-1, anyone voting?