Smoke-Filled Antechamber [Endgame]

[Tammy]

I don't think anyone is town reading him because he's aggressive.

And if he is aggressive as scum and as town then his aggression null because it's play style. Unless you have an understanding of his town and scum play and the different ways he's aggressive, otherwise you're using something null to claim someone is scum, which makes your argument faulty.

[Nahdia]

brb having an anuerism

[Tammy]

and I'm trying to figure out if your argument is town motivated or scum motivated.

[Nahdia]

as evidenced by my spellng of "aneurysm"

[Nahdia]

tammy, lass, is this a bit? are we doing a bit rn?

[Tammy]

you can be condescending all you want. I don't care.,

Still gonna scum hunt you anyway!

[Nahdia]

sorry, not trying to condescend. just trying to express my frustration.

i hereby refuse to engage on this subject. the answers to your questions are in the posts i've already made in response to you.

[Tammy]

I understand your answers.

I find them faulty and lacking. I'm trying to figure out if it's genuine or not because I suspect you.

Your argument is akin to

This swan is white
That swan I saw before is white
All swans are white

(Diamond sentinel might be scum; I'm not absolutely convinced he's town, but it feels like you're latching onto something weak and faulty to get lynchbait lynched.)

[Nahdia]

Seems like you don't understand my answers, actually.

[Gamma Emerald]

DS is aggressive this game.
DS is aggressive as scum.
is DS aggressive as town? i dunno, maybe. but even if he is, his aggression isnt a reason to townread him.

Cakez has been saying DS is aggressive as town for some time now.

[Nahdia]

This swan is white.
That swan I saw before is white.
We can't determine these two swans aren't the same swan on the basis of their color.

[Tammy]

I understand what you are saying now is that you tacked on "his aggression is consistent with his scum play" not as a reason that you scumread him even though that was what you were asked, and the reasons you were giving. I wouldn't have thought it odd if after that you said, people shouldn't townread him for being aggressive because he's aggressive as scum.

When asked, you referred to that as a "people shouldn't townread him for being aggressive" even though nobody is town reading him for being aggressive.

If you meant the second line when you said the first that is not at all that clear; the language is imprecise. And it read to me like you trying to tack meta knowledge onto your DS case to pad it. When asked about meta and etc., it reads as changing your original meaning.

[Nahdia]

you can try to tease unintending meanings out of my posts all day if you want but im just gonna keep telling you i meant what i meant.

[Tammy]

Are you always so insufferable?

[Nahdia]

i try not to be.

[Gamma Emerald]

I can’t believe the second I got out of my blind DS tunnel Nahdia starts one of their own

[Nahdia]

if im being blind, tell me what im not seeing.

[Jake The Wolfie]

This swan is white.
That swan I saw before is white.
We can't determine these two swans aren't the same swan on the basis of their color.

Nahd, can you tell me what this means?

[Tammy]

Nahdia the thought i like the best from you regarding DS is the thought that his attitude stems from feeling like the setup is unfair to him as scum. That had a certain amount of depth that I've felt has been missing in your other explanations for things. That, I think is a good alternative explanation to him being paranoid.

His play makes no sense to me, and quite frankly I don't know what to make of his alignment. I've decided he gets set to the side until I have to deal with it.

[Gamma Emerald]

if im being blind, tell me what im not seeing.

You’re not really accepting the fact that DS is just generally aggressive

[Nahdia]

yes i am

[Nahdia]

yall really seem to be struggling with this. idk why. ive never said DS' aggression makes him scum. ive said it DOESN'T make him town. tammy is essentially correct when she says im pointing out something that's functionally null. im doing this because i have other reasons to put him in the scum column. under other circumstances i might say "well but DS' aggression is kinda towny" but in this case im giving a reason it's not; he does it as scum.

[Cabd]

Novit enim Dominus qui sunt eius.

Let's fucking get on with it.

[Cabd]

We're at 145 pages now... do we really need to hit 200 before the game day ends?

[midwaybear]

Yeah, let's go to D3
VOTE: The Bulge