mystery box of silver 10. (done)

[Morning Mage]

ok im now 40 pages behind and dont see myself spending all day reading those pages. can someone give me the highlights? have we caught scum yet?

just check out my readslist!

[NorwegianboyEE]

ok im now 40 pages behind and dont see myself spending all day reading those pages. can someone give me the highlights? have we caught scum yet?

Have we caught scum? Hmmm.
Let’s see... Can you vote yourself?

that wont work today though lol

Shhh.

[Morning Mage]

ok im now 40 pages behind and dont see myself spending all day reading those pages. can someone give me the highlights? have we caught scum yet?

Have we caught scum? Hmmm.
Let’s see... Can you vote yourself?

that wont work today though lol

Shhh.

[Something_Smart]

DS probs in the scumpool as well due to Poe + I dislike the shading and discrediting

You're... you're scumreading DS for forgetting who's in Nero's faction and writing your name instead of mastina's?

[Something_Smart]

You would probably say that’s a pretty surface-level observation to be discussing over and over again, wouldn’t you??

I mean, it's not like I've just been literally repeating "Nero's faction could have a different wincon" over and over. I've been talking to Nero to try to sort his own story out (and it still doesn't make any sense), and I've been talking to people such as Norwee who seem to trust them but won't share why, and I've been discussing what the faction has done and claimed and how that fits in with their supposed motivation.

Likewise, if someone claimed a PR and there were 10 pages of discussion about whether their play makes sense as that role, and whether it fits in the setup, and whether the way they used it was consistent and believable, that's not a waste of time.

[Titus]

Alright. Time to get to work on my cross-reference table. See you in a few hours.

[jjh927]

I don't have any reason to trust you or not to trust you other than the claims and as you point out, the numbers (where did the exact number of 5 come from though). I don't have any reason to believe that the army isn't scum either. I just don't understand why members of your "town" 3P are acting scummy.

Misread this post

how so?

In relation to this

Of the funky little trio I'm in, I'm a little confused by Pete suggesting nothing indicates the army is scum when Gamma literally claimed scum

What are you talking about? I never suggested any such thing?

[superbowl9]

That’s a town tell because i dont believe scum would not be able to know about that from PT discussions. You can believe it’s lying scum but if you read his posts i think you will find that’s likely not the case

you think town not reading the actual game is significantly more likely than scum not reading the PT? bad take imo

...yes? Lol?? When have you played with scum that hasn’t read main OR pt vs when have you played with town who doesn’t read?

[Titus]

if you're shooting outside of the Mod's trio, I'd go Shelly or Taylor.

You know that readlist I provided you last night? FORGET ABOUT IT.

My reads are so rapidly changing right now they literally change every other page.

Right now I'd say all 4 scum are in the trio the mod listed + Chemist + Diamond, with an outside chance of Bell/Taylor being Scum (that would mean I am wrong on one of the other 5). I find it highly unlikely the mod provides an all-Scum pool for me to execute from (even if it was just a "recommendation"), so I'm thinking Chemist+Diamond are more likely to flip Scum than any of the other 3 (if that makes any sense to you).

Furthermore, the NK analysis S_S pointed out I think points to at least one of DS/jjh being Scum. It was a kill made to prevent something on the future, and "casual Scum" don't make those kinds of kills.

BUT, I could also see it as being "a kill on a confirmed!Townie" if Scum indeed had 2 kills and Norwee was saved by virtue of being the new recruit of the hood, as this means they went for both confirmed Townies on N2, which makes a lot of sense.

IMPORTANT: If anyone has questions, exclamations, elaborations, .. etc. PLEASE DON'T.

If such person is a member of the league of 7 they can ask in the respective PT, but not in the open. THANK YOU.

Saw this in my readthrough... the NKA is garbage. SS is scum.

[Titus]

y TPG instead of DS or Chemist?

Good question.

Also, I so SR Pickaxe, but why would he be early on Gamma but not at all on April? This is the main reason I'm second guessing myself on him.

Pickaxe Pete didn't post at all/very much during the April wagon. He didn't have an opportunity.

[Titus]

DDL vs Pete is just a case of who seems to be playing. Ddl only memorable post for me is about the BTS army. Pete I remember a post here or there.

Jjh is SK or scum because of play and ascetic claim. I disagree with Mastina’s setup spec again. Shocking I know. I lean SK simply because town Vig is too much power and being able to track JJH to a kill would then be either such a boon/bust to be ridiculous.

If I had a three way nuke I wouldn’t cry about them dying. I just don’t think wagoning any of them gives anything since their entire play is lurker hell.

Not posting every 8 hours is lurking. Figured that out end of Day 1.

You just said a whole lot of jjh is scummy for reasons but didn't say anything about ddl or me. Why should ddl or I be wagoned for lurking

if we're town

and jjh is scummy?

Ahem.

[Something_Smart]

the NKA is garbage.

It's garbage to suggest that scum killed a player with a power role to prevent him from using his power?

[Titus]

the NKA is garbage.

It's garbage to suggest that scum killed a player with a power role to prevent him from using his power?

The NKA regarding who made such a kill. Scum making such a kill isn't out of the ordinary. Plus is more likely to be protected on the night he gives out the power, if town even has a doctor.

[Titus]

Player Name	Execution Preference
shellyc	DDL>Pete>jjh
Chemist1422
Bell	DDL (doesn't disagree - yucky)
mastina	DDL
Nero Cain	DDL (but prefers outside)
MathBlade	DDL
Morning Mage	DDL, or outside mod's trio shelly or taylor
Almost50
superbowl9	jjh
Tayl0r Swift	DDL
jjh927	not DDL so Pete by PoE
Titus	Pickaxe Pete
NorwegianboyEE	DDL
Pickaxe Pete	DDL until "latest stunt by jjh"
DiamondSentinel
Something_Smart	Not jjh [JJH is town, and SS is scum]
DrDolittle	Pete?
TheGoldenParadox

[Titus]

I'm starting to see where Taylor gets there's scum in my nulls, it's just not DDL.

I feel A50 should nuke SS imo.

[MathBlade]

Player Name	Execution Preference
shellyc	DDL>Pete>jjh
Chemist1422
Bell	DDL (doesn't disagree - yucky)
mastina	DDL
Nero Cain	DDL (but prefers outside)
MathBlade	DDL
Morning Mage	DDL, or outside mod's trio shelly or taylor
Almost50
superbowl9	jjh
Tayl0r Swift	DDL
jjh927	not DDL so Pete by PoE
Titus	Pickaxe Pete
NorwegianboyEE	DDL
Pickaxe Pete	DDL until "latest stunt by jjh"
DiamondSentinel
Something_Smart	Not jjh [JJH is town, and SS is scum]
DrDolittle	Pete?
TheGoldenParadox

This is wrong. I prefer Pete (can see why when you’re caught up.) well really prefer TGP but that’s not one of the three.

[superbowl9]

I'm starting to see where Taylor gets there's scum in my nulls, it's just not DDL.

I feel A50 should nuke SS imo.

Why elim outside the confscum group??

[Titus]

Give me a readslist that convinces me otherwise SS.

Pedit: Thank you Math. I honestly skimmed over all the posts in the middle that happened Saturday night.

[MathBlade]

Give me a readslist that convinces me otherwise SS.

Pedit: Thank you Math. I honestly skimmed over all the posts in the middle that happened Saturday night.

K I am going back to lurking now. Gotta get stuff done.

[Titus]

I'm starting to see where Taylor gets there's scum in my nulls, it's just not DDL.

I feel A50 should nuke SS imo.

Why elim outside the confscum group??

Because I feel DDL is a misexecute and if we're taking a shot, I'd rather hit scum. So Pickaxe Pete or SS.

Then we have Chemist as scum too.

I'm just short one last one and I'm thinking it might be Bell.

[Titus]

Shooting outside the confscum group frankly gives DDL more time to obvtown.

[superbowl9]

Because I feel DDL is a misexecute and if we're taking a shot, I'd rather hit scum. So Pickaxe Pete or SS.

I'd rather hit scum so let's shoot outside confscum?? If DDL is town then we have a guaranteed 1/2 scum!

[superbowl9]

I say we shoot jjh anyways he's clearly more scummy than DDL

[Titus]

Because I feel DDL is a misexecute and if we're taking a shot, I'd rather hit scum. So Pickaxe Pete or SS.

I'd rather hit scum so let's shoot outside confscum?? If DDL is town then we have a guaranteed 1/2 scum!

So then we should execute Pickaxe but based on the popularity of DDL, I don't feel that's happening.

So your position is I should accept the misexecute?

[superbowl9]

Everyone's just bought his ascetic claim that *may I remind you* he pulled out randomly in the middle of D1?? I'm honestly puzzled what town mentality anyone sees in that slot