Open 799 Chosen Mafia (Game Over)

[Battle Mage]

easy pagetop:

If you were scum, who would you have Chosen and crucially, WHY?

[OutWorldER]

If you were scum, who would you have Chosen and crucially, WHY?

I know none of the people here so uhhhhhhhhhh

curious though, why exactly do you think this question helps town? I can actually see how it does, but I want to know your own reasons.

im happy to answer that once people have answered the question (although i think there are probably several reasons, some more obvious than others). appreciate you know none of the people - who would you have picked?

I would've had to metadive people in order to give you a proper answer to that and as it stands I've done none of that so I can't really give you a proper answer.

[Battle Mage]

oh...i just re-read the setup, it isn't what i thought at all.

I thought scum chose the chosen townies.

hmm...tactical retreat.

[benhalkum]

I wouldn't have.

I would have stayed quiet a bit longer to see if there was a trail I could tag in on before casting my first vote.

This is why it's curious to me that for random initial voting, we already have people with two votes on them.

If i was scum here i wouldn't have selected you. Just sayin.

genuine question - why?

Cus i don't think you would have been my number 1 threat. Assuming SvT.

interesting - I won't comment on this yet as I actually think it would be helpful to ask this question of everyone at the outset.

If you were scum, who would you have Chosen and crucially, WHY?

[Battle Mage]

let me re-phrase my question...

who would you have veto'd if you were scum

(thereby preventing them from becoming chosen)?

[NorwegianboyEE]

oh...i just re-read the setup, it isn't what i thought at all.

I thought scum chose the chosen townies.

hmm...tactical retreat.

Hmm, either you're dumbtelling or that's just a dirty trick.

[Battle Mage]

If you were scum, who would you have Chosen and crucially, WHY?

I know none of the people here so uhhhhhhhhhh

curious though, why exactly do you think this question helps town? I can actually see how it does, but I want to know your own reasons.

im happy to answer that once people have answered the question (although i think there are probably several reasons, some more obvious than others). appreciate you know none of the people - who would you have picked?

I would've had to metadive people in order to give you a proper answer to that and as it stands I've done none of that so I can't really give you a proper answer.

ok thanks!

[NorwegianboyEE]

Tbh i'm leaning on it being a dumbtell. Given my extensive knowledge of your playstyle.

[Battle Mage]

oh...i just re-read the setup, it isn't what i thought at all.

I thought scum chose the chosen townies.

hmm...tactical retreat.

Hmm, either you're dumbtelling or that's just a dirty trick.

lol i'm actually wondering if you made the same mistake as me, based on your initial answer?

[Battle Mage]

If you were scum, who would you have Chosen and crucially, WHY?

Essentially

just

Dkkoba cus they kicked my ass in a previous cult game and they're pretty good at pushing their reads.

the word "just" implied you could've picked more than 1 perhaps

[Umlaut]

Hmm. Would scum!Mage try to fake a dumbtell like this?

I don't know for sure, but I think

probably

it's somewhat unlikely? So I'm going to provisionally guess he's town.

[NorwegianboyEE]

oh...i just re-read the setup, it isn't what i thought at all.

I thought scum chose the chosen townies.

hmm...tactical retreat.

Hmm, either you're dumbtelling or that's just a dirty trick.

lol i'm actually wondering if you made the same mistake as me, based on your initial answer?

Nah, i was fully aware scum puts in a veto.

[Battle Mage]

tfw norwee vetod me ): VOTE: norwee

having now read the setup properly, this makes sense.

[Battle Mage]

Hmm. Would scum!Mage try to fake a dumbtell like this?

I don't know for sure, but I think

probably

it's somewhat unlikely? So I'm going to provisionally guess he's town.

excellent, i have accidentally obvtowned by being a fool. a classic BM-move. let's hope I am Chosen and scum are now halfway to being screwed.

[OutWorldER]

I wouldn't have.

I would have stayed quiet a bit longer to see if there was a trail I could tag in on before casting my first vote.

This is why it's curious to me that for random initial voting, we already have people with two votes on them.

If i was scum here i wouldn't have selected you. Just sayin.

genuine question - why?

Cus i don't think you would have been my number 1 threat. Assuming SvT.

interesting - I won't comment on this yet as I actually think it would be helpful to ask this question of everyone at the outset.

If you were scum, who would you have Chosen and crucially, WHY?

who and what are you responding to with this, I'm somewhat confused.

[NorwegianboyEE]

If you were scum, who would you have Chosen and crucially, WHY?

Essentially

just

Dkkoba cus they kicked my ass in a previous cult game and they're pretty good at pushing their reads.

the word "just" implied you could've picked more than 1 perhaps

No it implies that i don't think i would have chosen anyone else on this playerlist.

[Battle Mage]

oh...i just re-read the setup, it isn't what i thought at all.

I thought scum chose the chosen townies.

hmm...tactical retreat.

Hmm, either you're dumbtelling or that's just a dirty trick.

lol i'm actually wondering if you made the same mistake as me, based on your initial answer?

Nah, i was fully aware scum puts in a veto.

in that context, i can follow your dkkoba answer more, although not sure I believe it. I reckon scum-Norweg would hate the idea of having to day-elim me, knowing that i almost never get day-elimmed.

[Battle Mage]

luckily most people in the game dont know me, so probably wouldnt have vetoed me.

[Battle Mage]

I wouldn't have.

I would have stayed quiet a bit longer to see if there was a trail I could tag in on before casting my first vote.

This is why it's curious to me that for random initial voting, we already have people with two votes on them.

If i was scum here i wouldn't have selected you. Just sayin.

genuine question - why?

Cus i don't think you would have been my number 1 threat. Assuming SvT.

interesting - I won't comment on this yet as I actually think it would be helpful to ask this question of everyone at the outset.

If you were scum, who would you have Chosen and crucially, WHY?

dumbtell not withstanding, I don't understand this. Please tell me more Ben!

[Umlaut]

To answer the question being passed around, I don't know who I would veto because I don't have extensive enough experience with anyone here to describe someone as "very good at towntelling" (which would be my top criterion since I would veto someone I expected to be unlynchable) and would have had to do some meta-diving, as someone else said.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I reckon scum-Norweg would hate the idea of having to day-elim me, knowing that i almost never get day-elimmed.

Actually that sounds kinda fun.

[NorwegianboyEE]

To answer the question being passed around, I don't know who I would veto because I don't have extensive enough experience with anyone here to describe someone as "very good at towntelling" (which would be my top criterion since I would veto someone I expected to be unlynchable) and would have had to do some meta-diving, as someone else said.

It's a good answer, but copying what Outworld said. So no towncred for you.

[midwaybear]

Oh this has started

[Battle Mage]

hmm...midwaybear might have veto'd me. doesn't really matter now though now even scum dont know who is chosen.

[Umlaut]

Er, scum do know who is chosen, they're the only ones who know. That's the whole point of the setup.