Smoke-Filled Antechamber [Endgame]

[Alisae]

....i'm leaning towards it being pooky rn, actually.

Pooky is a doctor

[Tammy]

What I don't understand is why alisae did this. In alisae v pine Katsuki went along with LLD's suggestions they be mason and it fucked over town. Like there were memes about how he agreed to be mason with scum.

And alisae makes the mind numbingly stupid claim that it's a team game thing to do? Like what the everliving fuck? This isn't clever. This isn't funny. This is fucking stupid. Games get absolutely trashed over this bullshit. Town waste their fucking time rereading and rereading to see if your claims make sense and figuring out the game around these dumb as claims and you guys are sitting here congratulating yourselves for this dumb ass fuckery.

Step off with this bullshit.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

elim me b4 alisae. alisae locktown

[Alisae]

how does Pooky win this game Nahdia?

[midwaybear]

I didn't like that quote when I saw it, and now I realize it had a meaning I didn't even forsee!

[midwaybear]

elim me b4 alisae. alisae locktown

Guilty conscience huh pooky

[Nahdia]

how does Pooky win this game Nahdia?

how does anyone?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

r u saying bell knew his teammate was a fake mason lover and decided to out them. u must be trolling

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Guilty conscience huh pooky

i literaly save alisae last night e is locktown. you just mad ur scumteam got hosed

[Alisae]

how does Pooky win this game Nahdia?

how does anyone?

Claiming doctor is so bad for him tho

[Alisae]

What I don't understand is why alisae did this. In alisae v pine Katsuki went along with LLD's suggestions they be mason and it fucked over town. Like there were memes about how he agreed to be mason with scum.

I think you're thinking about the wrong game

[Alisae]

Also even if Pooky was in some universe a janitor and was able to janitor my flip, it wouldn't clear him because he claimed lovers.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

sorry tammy *hugs*

[midwaybear]

r u saying bell knew his teammate was a fake mason lover and decided to out them. u must be trolling

It's not really outing them because I originally thought Bell was discrediting your claim. However, now that I look at it again, yeah he basically outed one of you. And yes, I can see Bell doing that.

[Tammy]

What I don't understand is why alisae did this. In alisae v pine Katsuki went along with LLD's suggestions they be mason and it fucked over town. Like there were memes about how he agreed to be mason with scum.

I think you're thinking about the wrong game

I am. it was guy in freezer's game.

[Alisae]

Tammy that was GiF's game and I wasn't in that game.
I knew about that happening but for Pooky to try to make a play like that in thread seems really bizzare for scum to do. If he did kill me and janitor my slot, people just need to read his ISO and they'll realize that everything Pooky did was in this thread.
in LLD and Katsuki's case, they were in a neighborhood and that couldn't be proven unless you were in the hood yourself. At least thats how I remember that playing out?

[petapan]

i still need time to process this, but the cabd and jake shots make me think the last scum knew alisae and pooky aren't lovers.

strictly speaking after ds was eliminated, it would have been necessary to kill jake to keep up the ruse. and i was considering the possibility all of the night if that was what happened because i was having such a goddamn hard time figuring out who was scum otherwise.

but w/e, we can no elim and have tammy check someone, that's the safest route

[Alisae]

Peta why isn't it safer to elim midway?
I feel like I'm missing something when it comes to that because it seems like the next day phase we do that anyway except when we do it we lose a doctor.

[midwaybear]

Isn't the best route
elim in Alisae/me
Tammy check Pooky
gg
No eliminating keeps all three of us alive?

[petapan]

i don't think it makes a difference but it's less likely to drive tammy further insane

[midwaybear]

What happens if we no eliminate?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

tammy checks mwb/alisae
i protect tammy
i get shot

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

like the game is over just give up

[Tammy]

Tammy that was GiF's game and I wasn't in that game.
I knew about that happening but for Pooky to try to make a play like that in thread seems really bizzare for scum to do. If he did kill me and janitor my slot, people just need to read his ISO and they'll realize that everything Pooky did was in this thread.
in LLD and Katsuki's case, they were in a neighborhood and that couldn't be proven unless you were in the hood yourself. At least thats how I remember that playing out?

It doesn't matter why or how or what the read was. It creates a warped gamestate and it's disrespectful to every other member of the town.

We don't need to keep going on about this though. You think it's fine, and I never will. Even if you guys are both town here, I still won't. Fake claims and gambits of this type pretty much top my list of things I do not like in mafia.

And if one of you is scum it makes so much sense why I was having such a hard time finding scum in midwaybear, nahdia, cakez and peta.

[midwaybear]

I just realized I had early scumread on both Pooky and Alisae
scummy lovers that's right
I want to reread Bell/DS reaction to claim and their earlier interactions with Pooky and Alisae.