Open 800 - Donner Party | Game Over

[PlusJOYED]

Alright. I'm gonna chill out for a bit since I'm heated.
I'll probably just attach a hide script for DoubtingThomas's posts if his rude behavior continues.

[Gamma Emerald]

gamma what are your thoughts on this. seriously. this guy admits that he hasn't read bulk of my posts while giving an initial scum read on me for not liking my posts. and then now double downs on voting me even though my thought here is very transparent and easily followable for towns. take a stance.

It's dumb but PJ doesn't strike me as the pinnacle of intellectual play. It doesn't seem like what I've seen of him so far either, though.

[DoubtingThomas]

alright. to be fair I kind of ignored a good chunk of your posts because you came off as someone I don't wanna play with.

Please. you have no reason to be mad. You are the one who tried to lie about reading me and push me without due diligence. Your reaction here doesn't make any sense as town. For some reason, if you are actually mad, I am sorry, but your unfair, (and from my POV) wolf-agenda-y treatment of my slot is the cause of any sort of saltiness from my slot.

[PlusJOYED]

see Thomas when I play with someone rude it kills my desire to play. People like you are why I've been playing less. I'm not great at this game. Having a good time is more important than winning to me.

[DoubtingThomas]

gamma what are your thoughts on this. seriously. this guy admits that he hasn't read bulk of my posts while giving an initial scum read on me for not liking my posts. and then now double downs on voting me even though my thought here is very transparent and easily followable for towns. take a stance.

It's dumb but PJ doesn't strike me as the pinnacle of intellectual play. It doesn't seem like what I've seen of him so far either, though.

catching people from blatantly lying is dumb? man i am not sure what you people on this site consider intelligent then? maybe you can enlighten me as to why it's dumb?

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm saying what PJ is doing is dumb

[DoubtingThomas]

see Thomas when I play with someone rude it kills my desire to play. People like you are why I've been playing less. I'm not great at this game. Having a good time is more important than winning to me.

i don't understand why you lie about reading people when you are here to have a good time. having a good time while acknowledging that you are not great at this game gives absolutely 0 incentive to lie about reading people.

[Guillotina]

I'm gonna guess it's PJ based on posts regarding him from you? I also don't think Ari's been active enough you'd feel the need to make him feel comfortable.

Bingo!

I'm gonna go deep into their ISO's to see if I can figure out who is the less likely scum out of those 4.

[DoubtingThomas]

Like can someone explain to me if this thought process is incorrect?

- You like playing mafia
- You are not great at this game
- Someone who (you aren't sure if they are mafia or town to begin with) points out that you have lied about reading posts

- SURE you don't HAVE to read everything that's said in the game. I don't either. However, when I pushed someone and someone points out that I was lying, like my first reaction isn't to react with hostility and say that that person is rude and try to shrug off the lying part I have conducted as if it's nothing. Like acknowledge that you lied and then maybe even reevaluate your pushes because obviously you haven't done a great job in pushing that place if someone pointed out that you've lied?

but you doubling down on me despite me pointing out your own fault , a fault that you admit was yours, doesn't strike me as townie at all

[Tayl0r Swift]

this game is a shitshow rn. im just gonna sheep gamma for today.

[DoubtingThomas]

townies who have lack of information are more accepting of new information coming in. you did not accept the new information of me figuring out you have blatantly lied in a townie fashion. that's why you are scum

[PlusJOYED]

I did read your iso. I skimmed it but I did read it

[DoubtingThomas]

and i pointed out that you lied, and you admitted that you did not read any of the important posts. your push on me came from your understanding of your skim of my iso that i didn't make any posts, and i pointed out that evaluation is wrong. that should give you more than enough reason to reevalute your push on me. However, instead, you voted me, omgus'ed me and said that i am rude and that makes me wolfy.

I strongly believe that if you were town who mistakenly read my slot to be wolfy, you would NOT vote me immediately, and instead, reevaluate my slot or go somewhere else with it. But me pointing out your own lie didn't strike any bell that I might be a town?

Like you want to kill me because you don't like my play and you think I am rude, sure. But that has 0, absolutely 0 townieness to it.

[DoubtingThomas]

and i pointed out that you lied, and you admitted that you did not read any of the important posts. your push on me came from your understanding of your skim of my iso that i didn't make any

reads

, and i pointed out that evaluation is wrong. that should give you more than enough reason to reevalute your push on me. However, instead, you voted me, omgus'ed me and said that i am rude and that makes me wolfy.

I strongly believe that if you were town who mistakenly read my slot to be wolfy, you would NOT vote me immediately, and instead, reevaluate my slot or go somewhere else with it. But me pointing out your own lie didn't strike any bell that I might be a town?

Like you want to kill me because you don't like my play and you think I am rude, sure. But that has 0, absolutely 0 townieness to it.

[PlusJOYED]

This might be omgusing; this has happened in the past. This might be a battlemage situation. But I am being 100% genuine in that you've been making this game less fun, so I view you in a more negative light naturally.
I think your analysis for the most part has been superfluous though I'll admit I can see how you would see me as scum if you are town.

[PlusJOYED]

Why are you insisting I lied again?
I still think you votes and reads have been like nothing so far. Your read on me is the inly one I can understand if your town

[JohnnyFarrar]

*dad voice*

Take a step back you two. Bickering doesn't help.

[Guillotina]

@DT given your certainty about PJ, would you say that the Hydra team is spewed town as a result? Or do you think they are w/w and just did pretty good theater?

[Gamma Emerald]

I think DT genuinely believes the point they are making. I’ll pencil them in as town.

[Guillotina]

I think DT genuinely believes the point they are making. I’ll pencil them in as town.

Good to know.

How about your personal read list. Do you have one yet?

[Gamma Emerald]

Yes. Posting it again with adjustment:

town: tay, guillo, dt
weak town: chk, johnny, pj
bleh idk: superb, ari
actually idk: sirius, poblong
scum: chaos

[Guillotina]

this game is a shitshow rn. im just gonna sheep gamma for today.

Why?

Is it because I town read him and I said that I'm gonna try to find the less likely wolf in my PoE list, and you think sheeping him would make you look less wolfy? Or are you trying to make me suspect him because I suspect you?

[DoubtingThomas]

@DT given your certainty about PJ, would you say that the Hydra team is spewed town as a result? Or do you think they are w/w and just did pretty good theater?

why do you think they are spewed town? because she voted them initially?

i think PJ being scum makes them more likely to be town, but i prob won't clear them. i probably won't push the hydra slot anymore today though

[Guillotina]

Yes. Posting it again with adjustment:

town: tay, guillo, dt
weak town: chk, johnny, pj
bleh idk: superb, ari
actually idk: sirius, poblong
scum: chaos

Thank you Gamma.

Why do you town read Taylor? If you already explained it, I missed it, sorry.

[Tayl0r Swift]

have we suddenly figured out how to read each other gamma? im still down to do the thing we discussed to learn.