Mini Normal 2177 | Town Win

[Shoshin]

Why aren't you giving reads on the main wagons of the day? This is mafia 101 -- townies give reads on main wagons, scum avoid doing so.

[Herta]

It's probably going to come down to one of them so now's the time to decide which. One of them has claimed VT. Enough people think he's scum and if he isn't we won't be losing a PR. It's a crappy way to approach it, but if we're not going to have more info to work with, I don't know what else to do.

[Shoshin]

VOTE: Herta

[Herta]

Why aren't you giving reads on the main wagons of the day? This is mafia 101 -- townies give reads on main wagons, scum avoid doing so.

That's made up standard of play. I already said I don't like the wagons and I don't find any of them particularly scummy. I don't know why you want to trust that into me dance sitting.

[Herta]

*twist that into me fence sitting

[Tayl0r Swift]

Because I'm rereading the game with an open mind, meaning I have no reads atm.

??? you have no reads? but youre voting and have said several people are scummy.

[Tayl0r Swift]

Why aren't you giving reads on the main wagons of the day? This is mafia 101 -- townies give reads on main wagons, scum avoid doing so.

says the gal avoiding giving reads!

[Herta]

I don't understand why me answering that I don't find any of them particularly scummy is scummy in itself.

[Herta]

VOTE: Herta

I guess I should ask since you provided no context why?

[Herta]

Why aren't you giving reads on the main wagons of the day? This is mafia 101 -- townies give reads on main wagons, scum avoid doing so.

What wiki page did you read this from?

[Shoshin]

Why aren't you giving reads on the main wagons of the day? This is mafia 101 -- townies give reads on main wagons, scum avoid doing so.

says the gal avoiding giving reads!

I haven't avoided giving reads at any point, & I was very clear about the fact that I'd get back to you on this. Herta's been absent for most of the game, he attacked me earlier for not saying anything, and then he comes back to the game while saying virtually nothing substantive about the main wagons of the day.

[Shoshin]

I'm going to finish rereading. Everything will be explained in time.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

yeah..I know I have not been as active as I am usually am ..... like I said I had a major project do for school. I can see how people might think I am lurking.

UNVOTE: Not Mafia
I am kind of waffling on NM.Alot of things he done this game pings me as scummy however I did a dive into NM meta and there are definitely things that town NM does. For example his opening jester claim is something town NM does. I only saw one scum NM game and he did not seem o do that. Being generally useless is another thing it seems. I hope the cop will eventually investigate him and sort him out.


will reread the thread later tonight and hopefully post something useful.

[Herta]

You have one main wagon that hasn't dissipated from beginning to end. That's scum indicative. Two counters that aren't gaining steam. If scum were trying to depressure the main wagon they would not form two competing wagons, just one.

[Herta]

Even if I don't find tgp particularly scummy the wagon dynamics say otherwise.

[Hiraki]

shoshin i really really really want to join you but i dont think today is the day where herta is eliminated

would be cool if i'm proven wrong

[TheGoldenParadox]

VOTE: herta poor logic, generally scumreading them, and i see this wagon today.

[Tayl0r Swift]

TGP is flailing. will latch onto any wagon that seems viable.

[Shoshin]

TGP is flailing. will latch onto any wagon that seems viable.

No. Please throw the word "flailing" out of your mafia vocab.

[Shoshin]

I've been rereading the game with as open a mind as possible. I'm at page 16 & by far the scummiest players are Herta/Taylor. Rock/Zurel are the towniest.

[Shoshin]

Hiraki's probably third towniest.

[Zurel]

VOTE: herta poor logic, generally scumreading them, and i see this wagon today.

I don't like this. Especially after that vote on Geraint. I agree with Taylor, this looks like flailing scum.

[Zurel]

VOTE: TGP

And that's it from me today.

[Shoshin]

Zurel, please unvote TGP & allow me to have a conservation with you. I'm 99% certain I can convince you to vote either of Herta or Taylor today over Golden.

[Zurel]

No, but say what you want to say. I don't think I will change my mind, though.