Mini Normal 2174 | Korean Pop Music | Mafia Wins!

[Glitch]

Hopkirk: because of all the PR claims derps is still the most out there and freakin weird. But if that won't happen I'm fine with Staarling, Trendall, or VOTE: Johnny.

[Glitch]

Im conflicted on Flubber. The claim seems reasonable but I'm just confused more than anything at this point. Ill compromise on that if we run out of time but would prefer Johnny.

[JohnnyFarrar]

keep in mind that this means that u think the most likely scenario is that a scum hard counter claimed a doc claim near deadline which sure that is a possibility, but walk ur dear friend derp through this

I mean there was a doc. You counter claimed and the doc got limmed. Either you're a second doc (farfetched) or you wanted to 1 for 1 with a claimed pr (less farfetched)

[derp]

keep in mind that this means that u think the most likely scenario is that a scum hard counter claimed a doc claim near deadline which sure that is a possibility, but walk ur dear friend derp through this

I mean there was a doc. You counter claimed and the doc got limmed. Either you're a second doc (farfetched) or you wanted to 1 for 1 with a claimed pr (less farfetched)

derp can kind of see that

but derp still needs johnny to provide some content, u seem to be focused on something more mechanical rather than attempting to solve anything

so johnny boy my dearest friend, if derp is town then what does that mean for u?????????????????????+++++++++++

[Noraa]

We haven't had a VC in 5 days, I think this is kind of right:

Flubber – Hop (idk), Derp (1065) Staaring (1109) – L2
Johnny – Trendall (1223) -L4
Derp – Glitch (1137), Flubber (1147) -L3
Trendall – Nopoint (1128) – L2
Not Voting- Johnny, Norra -Wow, its two days to deadline

Flubber voting Derp is a scumclaim.
@Noraa – you know if you’re town you should probably vote before deadline at some point this game.

I guess if everyone likes Nopo, then I'll have to VOTE: Flubber

[Noraa]

Lowkey forgot about this game. be patient while I read up.

[Noraa]

What is Trendall's readslist?

my question is "where is trendall"?

[Noraa]

nopo, Trendall, Staarling
All 3 are due for a prod.

[Noraa]

What is Trendall's readslist?

1. All or all but one PRs are telling the truth

2. If all PRs are telling the truth then that makes Noraa, Staarling and JohnnyFarrar together as mafia. Which is a weird team because that puts Noraa and Staarling on the same team. So either way it looks massively likely that JohnnyFarrar is mafia.

3. If Noraa and Staarling aren't on the same team then Staarling out of those two is more likely to be mafia.

4. Amongst the PRs, if one of them is fake then I believe derp, and nopointinactinup's thing about 'hider' makes perfect sense. Hopkirk gets more suspicious the more I think about them, so I try not to think about them too much. So ignoring them, the final mafia would be between Glitch and Flubbernugget. Glitch behaves more suspiciously, but I somehow just don't feel like you give town a rolecop given how the setup seems to work to me (see Hopkirk post 1185), and it's not as though Flubbernugget is not acting suspiciously as well.

VOTE: JohnnyFarrar

I like this pov. Out of Johnny and Staarling tho, I defo prefer Staarling. A lot of classic newbscum moves are present.

[Noraa]

I need to look at trend/Noraa again because they're not against each other like I thought they were.

we agree with each other on a lot of things and I'd say Trendall is prolly town.

[Noraa]

not really true, u dont have to do setup spec, that is kind of a fence sitty stance to take

so actually dear derp will ask u the same thing he asked flubber, if u ignore the mass claim for now, readssssssssssssssssssss?

Trendall is my strongest TR if we ignore claims.
Hoppy is next.
Below that, things get murky.

My gun to head solve atm is something like Glitch/Staarling/Nopo

I understand why people started backing out of a scum!Nopo world for decent reasons but I still feel pretty unsettled about that slot.

[Noraa]

I'm fine with Staarling

I'm fine with this.

Why is Trendall scum?

I might be willing to compromise on Johnny.

[Noraa]

nopo, Trendall, Staarling
All 3 are due for a prod.

[Trendall]

I posted like two pages ago pipe down

[Trendall]

A lot of classic newbscum moves are present.

I thought we thought they weren't a newb and they were 'hectic' or something though?

[Noraa]

I posted like two pages ago pipe down

well its not really the pages ago. its the hours ago. on the activity view, it showed u as haven't posted in 2 days which is one prod.

[Noraa]

A lot of classic newbscum moves are present.

I thought we thought they weren't a newb and they were 'hectic' or something though?

dunno if its hectic. hoppy gets final say in that but if its hectic, then staarling looks even worse.

[Trendall]

It's very hard to get a word in edgeways what with all the posts complaining about the low activity levels, that's the thing.

[Noraa]

Sorry

[Trendall]

I don't mind either Staarling or JohnnyFarrar, I just think people are more likely to vote for Johnny so it's like..less effort.

[JohnnyFarrar]

but derp still needs johnny to provide some content, u seem to be focused on something more mechanical rather than attempting to solve anything

I'll cop to this. Low effort here. I feel like one of the prs is lying, so if you ARE second doc I'd probably trust my actual read on nopo assuming we don't just lose.

[nopointinactingup]

Ew that sounds like an awful role

Yes, what I do is kinda creepy if you think about it.

everyone got a cool ability but Staarling :<
but is it really too many? i was in a game where i think everyone had an ability

Pretty sure that's not a normal queue game. About 1/3 - 1/2 of towns are PRs in a normal set-up.

Nopo I'll have to think about because maybe the weirdness i picked up from them was role weirdness and not scum weirdness.

Expand on that "weirdness" if you're gonna put it out there.

Good day all! It's good to make a first post after a four year hiatus. Forgive me if I'm not familiar with the current meta and probably some new terminologies. Looking to do some mighty fine scum-hunting with a

secret

weapon o' mine. Will leave an analysis post on what happened shortly

I'm sure the scum must have already realized it, but I left a hider crumb on my first post of the game. I tried to sound like PR and was also hard-accusing people all D1 to bait scum into killing my slot.

I need to look at trend/Noraa again because they're not against each other like I thought they were.

If you read their ISO, they have never been against each other. Nora White-Knighted Trendall on D1 and Trendall has been indirectly defending Noraa and chainsawing me ever since. Their blind defense of each other leads me to think that these are town-reads by decision rather than town-reads by analysis.

This game is really just setup spec at this point which I really can't do. Someone that's good should really stand out and make a say right about now.

I don't see how this would help town considering the person who stands out might be scum. I myself am pretty confused about all these claims as there were way fewer PRs in my days. Also, I want you to elaborate that Trendall-town read you have.

i suppose

third person slip, must be caught scum

lolol

I'm not getting this, can you elaborate?

[nopointinactingup]

At this point, I do believe both Glitch and therefore Hopkirk is town among the PRs.

I don't think derp and Flubber are town or scum together, as that would make town PRs swing too strong or too weak? (also depends on scum-team composition and someone can debate this premise but for now this is what I think)

Trendall/Nora is a decent solve due to their interactions, plus one of Flub/derp. It's interesting to see that Flub is not voting derp, who is literally his counter-claim right now. That might be a sign that he's town.

If it's not Trendall + Nora then it's still likely to be one of them plus one of Johnny/Starling.

[nopointinactingup]

What is Trendall's readslist?

4. Amongst the PRs, if one of them is fake then I believe derp, and nopointinactinup's thing about 'hider' makes perfect sense. Hopkirk gets more suspicious the more I think about them, so I try not to think about them too much. So ignoring them, the final mafia would be between Glitch and Flubbernugget. Glitch behaves more suspiciously, but I somehow just don't feel like you give town a rolecop given how the setup seems to work to me (see Hopkirk post 1185), and it's not as though Flubbernugget is not acting suspiciously as well.

Can you elaborate further on why you think my claim "makes sense" and why Hopkirk, Glitch's claims are "suspicious". Hard to understand your thought process when you're just throwing out words.

[Staarling]

i thought Johnny was townie because he asked a bunch of questions when he came into the game, like he really wanted to find the bad guys
i'll follow whatever Hopkirk does i think, he's the only one i trust completely