Okay so I've finished the big project that was weighing me down here and am ready to dive back in here
Thank you so much to everyone for giving me that time! I really needed it <3
Looks like El-2 so I've got an uphill battle but we've got lots of time to make this right!
I guess I'll start off looking at the scum wagon from D1 and go from there. If you had any questions addressed to me there's a good chance I'll miss them so please reiterate or quote them. I doubt it'll be much since this is all votes for being vacant from what I can tell, but just in case.
Okay, so starting off, that's one hell of a vote swing between the VCs in 393 and 577. Looking at replacement times I have to assume Vax replaced into the slot with suspicions high already, so I'm going to take a look at Tsunami's descent into chaos, replacement, and the treatment of the slot upon Vax's replace-in.
I will note that it took almost another 500 posts, half the game at that point, to get the last 2 votes on this slot. Makes me thing there was some scum resistance to the wagon. That, too, will be of great interest in this reading.
Notes around Tsunami/Noraa/72 (WHO IS 72!?!?)/Vax:
Endless Terror/Tayl0r/Shelly said they towntold in 416 and those that follow.
The replace out in 494 probably shouldn't have been read into but I'm glad it was. Iunno what my comment is here tbh.
Spoiler: (probably illegal post based on replacement rules but oh well)
In post 497, Gypyx wrote:Oh ok, bye then, could we just get some reads before that?
But I kinda agree on the problem tbh, the mech talk is fine, but the pace of the game is really, like, dense
Since you kindly asked and also had a nice goodbye, I shall break my own rule of last post :/
I am 99% sure Endless terror is town.
I agree with my partner that Bell is scum. This is mostly some soulread shit but generally my soul reads aren't bad.
Everyone else is just confusing and I keep mixing them up.
I keep mixing up the Taly/Titus and then the HBB and HUB and the fish. Yeah @_@
-brainfriednornor
I don't believe soulreads from scum.
The Tayl0r Swift town confidence is very interesting considering I already FoS that slot (see below).
The last line name drops HBB, HUB, Pelican heads, and BEF as apparently confusing? I mean, by name I was confused at HBB vs HUB at first but they seem to be diverging which is good. I have NO Clue why BEF is in this mix!?!?
I should say that I despise the votes on Tsunami at replacement. They're lazy, uninspired, and are so easy to place on a scumbuddy because the chances of them going anywhere are slim considering the stance most people take on replacements. They still achieve the optics of being active and scumhunting but are not really anything.
Endless Terror's vote is utter shite and they deliberately did not respond to Gamma when he questioned them on it. Bell's is at least (badly) supported by a statistical replacement bias. But that's almost as bad. FoS on both of these slots. Bad votes. I can maybe give shelly some room for coming back with 526 but Iunn. I'll have to think on that.
Do you still believe this with the Tsunami flip? What is your current read on Bell?
Unrelated to the flipped scum slot but not fond of the rolefish in 529
In post 556, Bell wrote:I think I favor bussing to not bussing. But never d1. As ydrasse can attest from our forest fire game together(I will get pissed if I get associated with a d1 scum flip I had a hand in).
I don't think Noraa or offsuit like being scum. Though yeah, I probably shouldn't get into that due to the angle shoot issue.
Okay, this is interesting. Post was already placed with little backing and this kind of reaffirms the reason for that vote in the assumption that neither head (I assume Offsuit is 72 tho I am still unsure if I know who tf that is) likes playing scum. An admission to being willing to bus but not on D1 is interesting. It reads as a post I could believe.
BUT I also pointed out that the jump onto the wagon was easy and not necessarily serious. Like even with this Bell could jump off and it would be totally reasonable. I don't see conviction behind the vote so I'm not writing off interactions yet.
I appreciate his noting my schooling tho <3 Thanks Bell, you're a good guy!
Iunno, it's just...there's posts that are making be really think a Bell/ShellET/Tsunami Vaxxer scumteam is possible.
I guess I know where Imma be looking next!
Uggh TGP please tell me there's more to this vote!
I uh, I think I missed HBB's vote somehow. One sec.
Oh, I see it.
Meh it's the best of the replacement-era votes I suppose.
Reads as I read through but with no reasoning attached:
Gamma - Town
HBB - Nullscum?
HUB - Nulltown?
Shelly/EndlessTerror - Scummy
Sam - Towny
Ydrasse - Towny
Bell - Scummy
BEF - Towny
Cool, so that's the stuff between the mentioned posts and up to Vaxx's replacement.
In post 583, Endless Terror wrote:Tl;dr on Tsunami, im not including the repout for integrity reasons to be a Serious Player that doesnt get modkilled...
- Noraa: fluffposting, only lazy sheeping of 72's reads and not wishy-washy like town!her is at all
- 72: weird Bell/gypyx lockscum reads that arent fleshed out, isn't hitting usual towntells
-shellyc
I'm going to take back my Trio read of Tsunami Vaxxer/Bell/ShellET but I wouldn't be surprised if there's a second one in that trio. I'm gonna look into them next.
Actually, I don't anticipate getting anything out og these pages that I can't glean in Iso or later in the game. Maybe I should just jump to it.
Imma check where the wagons are other than on myself for this phase too, because that should be interesting and tbh I haven't looked that closely...
I could easily see TayTay/shelly as scum tbh. I'll maybe do a case another time. I am losing steam and it's not gonna get a good case out of me. But they shaded people like Gamma in the right spots for it to be scumshade and Iunno what to think of the Commuter claim as I haven't really read that part. But the way they go about it feels odd. Plus interactions with Tsunami etc etc.
In post 1608, samantha97 wrote:just for clarity, did you read to page 24 and then change to reading iso's, or did you catch up and then double back?
I read half of the page before switching to Isos, if that's of any help.
Oh, sorry I think I misread this.
I read up to halfway through 24 but did not catch up on the entire thread. I was going to do a pg 24 to Elim (post what...1066?) but I found that cumbersome and figured it wouldn't give me much.
My Isos were also light reads, as noted. I burned up a lot of motivation in the first bit.
In post 1606, Aristophanes wrote:I could easily see TayTay/shelly as scum tbh. I'll maybe do a case another time. I am losing steam and it's not gonna get a good case out of me. But they shaded people like Gamma in the right spots for it to be scumshade and Iunno what to think of the Commuter claim as I haven't really read that part. But the way they go about it feels odd. Plus interactions with Tsunami etc etc.
I could see shelly as scum but until I get a better picture of the setup I'm treating that slot, as well as GPX, as untouchable
<Embrace The Void>
“A flipped coin doesn't always land heads or tails. Sometimes it may never land at all...”
In post 1606, Aristophanes wrote:I could easily see TayTay/shelly as scum tbh. I'll maybe do a case another time. I am losing steam and it's not gonna get a good case out of me. But they shaded people like Gamma in the right spots for it to be scumshade and Iunno what to think of the Commuter claim as I haven't really read that part. But the way they go about it feels odd. Plus interactions with Tsunami etc etc.
I could see shelly as scum but until I get a better picture of the setup I'm treating that slot, as well as GPX, as untouchable
Noted and appreciated.
I'll keep an FoS on them but will drop them down a level for now.
In post 499, Tsunami Slayer wrote:I agree with my partner that Bell is scum. This is mostly some soulread shit but generally my soul reads aren't bad.
Everyone else is just confusing and I keep mixing them up.
I keep mixing up the Taly/Titus and then the HBB and HUB and the fish. Yeah @_@
I think Ari does a good point in drawing attention to this post. The Bell read doesn't super feel like s/s tbh, although probably not enough to heavily to say it heavily spews him town. The stated conflation of me, HBB, and BEF I don't know what to do with, forcing 'the fish' in there is kinda weird I agree but I don't know what to do with it
In post 1535, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:It's just super weird and awkward because Ari just said he was going to be busy working on a project so I'm not sure why he thought a reaction test at that moment made sense
My fake hammers aren't just for a reaction from who was hammered, its also on how other people react to it. Ari shut it down right away though.
